January 21, 201115 yr Hi Guys, Would Appreciate some constructive feedback on these logo designs. Thanks in advance!
January 21, 201115 yr i think its too obvious. my issue with it is that its been done before. there is nothing new there. if i was u i'd bring it back to the start and try out other concepts.
January 21, 201115 yr Author Thanks Alzer, the problem is want to create something simple and I loved the concept of the other one I just couldn't simplify it! Where as this one, I totally agree similar stuff has been done before but it works. So my heads in two places. I'm leaving filters out for the moment because I don't want fancy effects to distract me from the actual design. Maybe I should try harder with the other concept?
January 21, 201115 yr <useless response> Are you using Hero font? </useless> I preferred your 3d concept from a while back, though, thought that had potential.
January 21, 201115 yr Yes no. 5 & 6 - I actually like no. 9 as well. I almost prefer it to 6. The thing about 5 is I don't think you should use block capitals - can you try 5 with 6's text? And can you try 9 with the logo on the left? Why not try another one with a more abstract placement of the logo vs the text as well?
January 21, 201115 yr 5, 6 and 9. The reason being is that I love the blue and black 'm' and 'w' shape. Better as two colours rather than one. Also loving the 3D logo design too, looks real nice. Great work!
January 21, 201115 yr Relive the old 3D concept! What do you think?? Yes! Very good. Looks like there's a bit of work gone into it. The only thing I would say without putting a cat amongst the pigeons is your use of gradients to bring out the lighting on the logo - how well is this going to translate into print, business cards etc. ? If you think it would be ok then - go for it. Any way you can make the colours more solid/basic without losing the 3d effect? But I think it's excellent.
January 22, 201115 yr I'd take the 3D idea and run with it, I feel the font used on the other logo's is somewhat lacking. Remember some of the most recognisable brands out there use good old fonts: Little example
January 22, 201115 yr Author The 3D logo was created from scratch. Thank you Singleframe, I actually saw that article and I think switching too a bolder font is better and more striking.
February 18, 201115 yr I like 5. It's nice and compact and a good contrast between the use of the two colours... just right.
February 20, 201115 yr i also liked 5, but maybe try a different approach for more variety they are all about the same, or has the client already narrowed it down to this look and feel?
February 22, 201115 yr Relive the old 3D concept! What do you think?? Infinitely superior. This could easily be made to work in one/two/three colour, if necessary, as well as full colour. Your newer designs are a backwards step. Sorry.
February 28, 201115 yr I drove past a design shop not far from me @ weekend. Saw this and thought of this thread. Also, look at their website for lols. No idea how they make money... ~evu.
March 5, 201115 yr I also found through the course but can be used five, maybe six, no, no, even better 5.
March 14, 201115 yr Relive the old 3D concept! What do you think?? Conceptually this is a much more interesting idea than what you posted in the first post, but the implementation is a bit off. You should really design in black and white first. If you can't make the logo clear with only one color you really should start over. A good logo works at any size and in any medium without losing legibility or form. I don't think the shape would reproduce well in a one-color situation. You'd probably need to find a way to make the M more obvious in the negative space. I could be wrong though, it's hard to visualize without seeing it done. The logos (all of them) don't really tell me what you do. Are you a video editor? News network? Graphic Designer? I shouldn't really have to ask, or I should at least have an idea based on the symbol, type, color, etc. I also think that your choice of font in the first batch is... unenthusiastic. When I hear enthused I think of something fun, energetic and happy, while whatever you have chosen is not. In the 3D version it's the same story, I don't think the type fits the name (though it fits the mark quite well). I don't mean to come across as rude or discouraging. I'd really be keen to see what you can make of this, so keep at it.
March 15, 201115 yr The logos (all of them) don't really tell me what you do. Are you a video editor? News network? Graphic Designer? I shouldn't really have to ask, or I should at least have an idea based on the symbol, type, color, etc. Not really, take a look at some very famous effective logos they don't really tell you what they actually do. For instance Coca Cola, Pepsi, McDonalds, KFC, Samsung, Mitsubishi, Ford the list goes on...
March 15, 201115 yr Not really, take a look at some very famous effective logos they don't really tell you what they actually do. For instance Coca Cola, Pepsi, McDonalds, KFC, Samsung, Mitsubishi, Ford the list goes on... This is a fair point, but I'd argue that these brands were established at a time when branding was a different beast. In today's sea of technology or design related companies you need to set yourself apart, and having a logo where the viewer has to ask what you do is one more obstacle to overcome. I'd also argue that a good number of those brands probably evolved from a logo where you had more explanation. McDonald's used to be "McDonald's Hamburgers", Pepsi and Coke both had/have "Cola" in there name, KFC used to go as "Kentucky Fried Chicken", etc. After they established solid brand recognition they evolved into what you see today. Either way, to the OP, I'd still love to see some tweaking with the 3D version of the logo. Edited March 15, 201115 yr by porkchops
Create an account or sign in to comment