Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

PC or MAC?

PC or Mac? 86 members have voted

  1. 1. Which do you prfer?

    • PC
      58%
      48
    • Mac
      41%
      34

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

5. When your biggest rival holds 80% of the desktop/laptop OS market then it's pretty dam hard to compete! Marketing is something that Apple excel at so it's naturally going to be their most effective approach to tackling Microsoft's dominance.

 

Apple can never and will never compete with MS in the desktop PC market. Especially in the corporate market.

 

They are not trying to take on Microsoft at all. You can't, it would be completely futile.

 

Apple's success comes from iPod/iPhone/iPad. Not Mac.

  • Replies 150
  • Views 18.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • This is based on the discussions with numerous professional in both photography and graphics as well as embedded systems developers and other non web based computer or software engineers.   In terms

  • "Retina" is just a marketing term, agreed, but there's no commercially available 13-15" screens out there with the same quality as those offered by Apple at the moment. I'd be immensely surprised if m

Apple can never and will never compete with MS in the desktop PC market. Especially in the corporate market.

 

They are not trying to take on Microsoft at all. You can't, it would be completely futile.

 

Apple's success comes from iPod/iPhone/iPad. Not Mac.

 

I believe they can.

Microsoft's grip on the desktop OS market in weakening, their market share is falling and most of their loss is being consumed by Apple.

 

Steve Jobs has even said in interviews that they are competing with Microsoft in the desktop/laptop OS market, he genuinely believed that Windows is an inferior OS and he wanted the world to realise it. The corporate market are adopting OS X at a considerably fast rate - it's more secure and the restrictions make it easier for employers and educational institutions to limit its use. My University alone has more Macs to PCs on a ratio of about 10:1 (maybe higher).

 

Apple's success did indeed come from the iPod --> iPhone --> iPad but they are using that success and powerful brand image to market their laptops and desktops which is currently working.

Apple can never and will never compete with MS in the desktop PC market. Especially in the corporate market.

It'll be interesting to see in the future. Of my friends, I believe every University is heavily investing in Macs. If this generation, or younger ones are brought up with Macs...of course that'll start to leak into corporate world.

 

Just read Alluziion's post - looks like his Uni too. It's a seriously sharp uptake Mike, I kid you not. Even larger in the US.

IMO it's PC all the way, Mac used to be the design standard, but then again so did QuarkXPress ... where did QuarkXPress go? Oh that's right, InDesign (£660.51) vs QurakXPress (£799.00) is cheaper in price and better in all the ways I use it ... just like a PC really. Macs are for the pretty people wanting everything to match their poodle :p

I believe they can.

Microsoft's grip on the desktop OS market in weakening, their market share is falling and most of their loss is being consumed by Apple.

 

Steve Jobs has even said in interviews that they are competing with Microsoft in the desktop/laptop OS market, he genuinely believed that Windows is an inferior OS and he wanted the world to realise it. The corporate market are adopting OS X at a considerably fast rate - it's more secure and the restrictions make it easier for employers and educational institutions to limit its use. My University alone has more Macs to PCs on a ratio of about 10:1 (maybe higher).

 

Apple's success did indeed come from the iPod --> iPhone --> iPad but they are using that success and powerful brand image to market their laptops and desktops which is currently working.

 

If you think Microsoft's grip on the market is weakening and Apple's is getting stronger, you should read these numbers closely http://www.netmarketshare.com/operating-system-market-share.aspx?qprid=10&qpcustomd=0 The grip looks pretty tight to me! Not sure how Apple can ever compete with Microsoft on their home turf when Windows works on a silly range of hardware and Mac OS...well is for Apple only. Apple hasn't made its silly money trying to beat Microsoft at what it does well, it's made it by doing what Microsoft has not done well. Then again if Apple spent some of it's profits on a decent amount of R&D rather than stuffing in under their bed they make some progress elsewhere...they can only ride the Ipad/Iphone wave for so long.

If you think Microsoft's grip on the market is weakening and Apple's is getting stronger, you should read these numbers closely http://www.netmarketshare.com/operating-system-market-share.aspx?qprid=10&qpcustomd=0 The grip looks pretty tight to me! Not sure how Apple can ever compete with Microsoft on their home turf when Windows works on a silly range of hardware and Mac OS...well is for Apple only. Apple hasn't made its silly money trying to beat Microsoft at what it does well, it's made it by doing what Microsoft has not done well. Then again if Apple spent some of it's profits on a decent amount of R&D rather than stuffing in under their bed they make some progress elsewhere...they can only ride the Ipad/Iphone wave for so long.

 

I came across those figures quite recently and they still say nothing more to me than Windows consumes 80% of the desktop/laptop OS market... it's a mere snapshot of the status-quo with no information regarding historical figures and predicted trends. Mac OS once had a good grip on the desktop OS market but were surpassed by Windows. Microsoft has lost 10% of the market in recent years and although 10% seems small, when it's a global market involved it's actually an enormous number. Windows is holding it's grip because of generational familiarisation, people have been brought up with Windows and therefore continue to use it because they aren't adventurous enough to try something new (not everyone but most). However, this is all changing and I know many teenagers now who have no idea how to use Windows but are absolute wizards with OS X. Apple has gripped the next generation of computer users and in the years to come we will see how that affects the figures. For now we can debate it but neither of us know what will happen but the facts are still clear - Microsoft still have a monopoly (barely) but they are slowly losing grip.

I came across those figures quite recently and they still say nothing more to me than Windows consumes 80% of the desktop/laptop OS market... it's a mere snapshot of the status-quo with no information regarding historical figures and predicted trends. Mac OS once had a good grip on the desktop OS market but were surpassed by Windows. Microsoft has lost 10% of the market in recent years and although 10% seems small, when it's a global market involved it's actually an enormous number. Windows is holding it's grip because of generational familiarisation, people have been brought up with Windows and therefore continue to use it because they aren't adventurous enough to try something new (not everyone but most). However, this is all changing and I know many teenagers now who have no idea how to use Windows but are absolute wizards with OS X. Apple has gripped the next generation of computer users and in the years to come we will see how that affects the figures. For now we can debate it but neither of us know what will happen but the facts are still clear - Microsoft still have a monopoly (barely) but they are slowly losing grip.

 

I must say I this is quite a statement " Apple has gripped the next generation of computer users"! When I was quite a bit younger I was exposed to Windows and Macs at the same time. Macs were quite fun, but no use as I couldn't pull them to apart! My own windows machine (95) was slow by todays standards. However it inspired me to become quite obsessed with PC's. I took it to pieces, put it back together and it worked! I broke Windows so many times but at the same time discovered things that others around me didn't know. The idea of what you imply with your statement actually scares the crap out of me. Sure kids will know how to do cool stuff with software (great you can do that with windows and linux too). My concern is they won't know how their computers work, they won't even think about it and if your statement became true then they would be as locked to Apple as the hardware and software is.

 

I don't think Apple are bad, they have done some good things, however even investors are getting nervous that they will be unable to keep the gravy train flowing. I'm sure Apple has some amazingly talented people working for them, however if the people at the top can't see the big picture...well we all know what happened in the 90's.

I agree with both Durden and Alluziion. Durden is right in that it is probably quite ignorant to truly believe that Apple is suddenly going to sweep the market (not that Alluziion ever implied that)...it simply won't happen - and Apple aren't trying to do it. How many Mac adverts have you seen in the past 5 years?

 

However, as Alluziion has said, my generation (I'm currently 21) is growing up with these Macs. Tens of people I know are getting fed up with their budget Windows laptops (generally laptops, in my age-group) getting slow and breaking. Yes, most of the time this is user error, or cheap manufacturer hardware problems, but it doesn't matter how - that's irrelevant to the fact that they are buying Macs, and liking them. You don't get viruses on Macs - I'm not saying it's impossible, simply that right now it just doesn't happen.

 

As BMike has said, iPhones/iPads are Apple's main revenue source - but Apple are not backing out of the personal computer market. They're buffing up their products as much as any other medium-high end manufacturer is doing, and they're bathing in what must be an astronomical amount of user satisfaction and publicity from the massive success of iOS, the iPhone, the iPod, and the iPad.

 

Now, I'm no fan of iOS - but we're nerds here (sorry!), and we look for more from software than the masses. Applying that to OS X, the majority will see it on a well-designed product, read that there's no viruses, there's no real way to clog it up, and that you have 4 years guarantee, with free official repairs, for £40...and 'poof'...sold. Another young-ish person growing up with OS X, not Windows...another potential business venture using OS X, not Windows. And so it begins.

 

A small business I work with is currently in the process of replacing all office desktops with Macs. They're not a tech-related company, either.

 

Of course, most of the above is hypothetical...and to be honest, with the current markets, it's likely an Android desktop OS would crush any hope Apple had. One thing I'd probably put money on - it's not going to be 80% Windows in 30+ years time. Ubuntu, Android variants, OS X...they'll start snapping up share. I'm hoping for a stable Unix OS to pull through with the backing of a decent hardware manufacturer, that'll be the day for everyone. A "new Apple", if you will, but with fewer restrictions.

Edited by andy9l

Durden, I do agree that it is scary to think that, especially during times where incentives are being provided to schools in order to encourage children to interact more with computers and software engineering (the Raspberry Pi is a good example). However, there are more and more methods becoming available to modify Apple products, even down to the hardware so although they aren't as easy to modify as a Windows PC rig, the option is still there except it takes a bit more effort and probably a bit more cash as well.

 

I also agree that Apple's board have no idea what they're doing... okay maybe some idea seeing as though they multi-millionaire investors but that's the problem, they are investors and not necessarily tech experts or innovators. They don't give a toss about innovation as long as the money keeps coming in and when it stops then they'll just sell up and move onto the next phenomenon. It happens to most big PLCs who lose all of their original executives, the ones that wanted the company to succeed and for the consumers to be happy without all the emphasis on profits etc. It seems like a reductionist statement to make but the loss of Steve Jobs seems to be really damaging Apple. I had faith in Tim Cook but he's being whipped so darn hard by the greedy shareholders and directors that he's losing sight of what was important. Steve on the other hand was very stubborn and wouldn't take that sort of crap from the directors - even Wozniak has began publicly showing his concern about Apple's future.

 

Andy, I agree with everything you said and the thought of an Android desktop/laptop OS sounds intriguing and very likely in the coming years as well. Google know that it wouldn't be easy to steal Microsoft's market share but if Apple are able to take a big chunk then I think Google would try and take it from Apple instead.

Durden, I do agree that it is scary to think that, especially during times where incentives are being provided to schools in order to encourage children to interact more with computers and software engineering (the Raspberry Pi is a good example). However, there are more and more methods becoming available to modify Apple products, even down to the hardware so although they aren't as easy to modify as a Windows PC rig, the option is still there except it takes a bit more effort and probably a bit more cash as well.

 

Andy, I agree with everything you said and the thought of an Android desktop/laptop OS sounds intriguing and very likely in the coming years as well. Google know that it wouldn't be easy to steal Microsoft's market share but if Apple are able to take a big chunk then I think Google would try and take it from Apple instead.

 

You're right - more companies have started offering Mac compatible upgrades. Apple's response? Start soldering previously swappable parts to the motherboard - making it literally impossible to upgrade components within certain Macs. I kid you not. I'm not sure what their argument is for making this move...but I can't imagine it being a strong one. It's disappointing. Silently locking customers into buying a new Mac in the not-too-distant future when they're told, "Oh no, sir, you can't swap your RAM sticks, or hard drive - it's all soldered to the motherboard...this was mentioned in small print on the website at the time of purchase.".

 

It's this behaviour from Apple that grinds my gears. Really, really gets to me. I don't know enough about their supposed reasoning for this to make any judgements as to whether it's morally incorrect, but I have my worries. I'm just glad I've read about this before buying the new MacBook I'll be forking out for soon - I'd be a little cheesed off if I'd bought with the intention of upgrading later, only to find I've royally screwed myself over courtesy of small print.

 

It would indeed be interesting to see what Google could do in that market...and I'm sure they've got some plans going, what with Chrome OS being pushed a little more with the launch of the new GoogleBook Pro Chromebook Pixel.

 

@Durden, do many people know how a computer works now? I mean, how a computer really works - not just the basics. I would say no, but perhaps I'm being a little negative about it?

Edited by andy9l
Typos.

You're right - more companies have started offering Mac compatible upgrades. Apple's response? Start soldering previously swappable parts to the motherboard - making it literally impossible to upgrade components within certain Macs. I kid you not. I'm not sure what their argument is for making this move...but I can't imagine it being a strong one. It's disappointing. Silently locking customers into buying a new Mac in the not-too-distant future when they're told, "Oh no, sir, you can't swap your RAM sticks, or hard drive - it's all soldered to the motherboard...this was mentioned in small print on the website at the time of purchase.".

 

It's this behaviour from Apple that grinds my gears. Really, really gets to me. I don't know enough about their supposed reasoning for this to make any judgements as to whether it's morally incorrect, but I have my worries. I'm just glad I've read about this before buying the new MacBook I'll be forking out for soon - I'd be a little cheesed off if I'd bought with the intention of upgrading later, only to find I've royally screwed myself over courtesy of small print.

 

It would indeed be interesting to see what Google could do in that market...and I'm sure they've got some plans going, what with Chrome OS being pushed a little more with the launch of the new GoogleBook Pro Chromebook Pixel.

 

@Durden, do many people know how a computer works now? I mean, how a computer really works - not just the basics. I would say no, but perhaps I'm being a little negative about it?

 

I would say a fair few people know how they really work. However I worry for the generation that is younger than myself (and I'm only 28) that they won't know how they work or be truly inspired to do great things with them. There is a new school being built where I live and every child will be giving a free Ipad! Buy in a load of Raspberry PI's and inspire kids with small projects that will show them the potential of technology. If kids in this country were inspired the right way in school then our computer industry might actually be good in this country in a decade or so.

 

As far as I am aware schools and universities get massive discounts from Apple and call me cynical, but it's a clever tactic by Apple. Have the kids using thei stuff at school and their parents and themselves will be future customers.

 

At the end of day Apple will probably never let customers tinkle with the hardware. That sort of thing is not Apple's strong selling point...theirs is the brand.

 

@Alluziion You are so right about the board. Jobs didn't create much for the products, but he knew what customers would buy and how to be able to charge a premium for the product and get the customer to still feel grateful. The man was a genius of business. Cook on the other hand is a numbers man, not a visionary.

I believe they can.

Microsoft's grip on the desktop OS market in weakening, their market share is falling and most of their loss is being consumed by Apple.

 

Steve Jobs has even said in interviews that they are competing with Microsoft in the desktop/laptop OS market, he genuinely believed that Windows is an inferior OS and he wanted the world to realise it. The corporate market are adopting OS X at a considerably fast rate - it's more secure and the restrictions make it easier for employers and educational institutions to limit its use. My University alone has more Macs to PCs on a ratio of about 10:1 (maybe higher).

 

Apple's success did indeed come from the iPod --> iPhone --> iPad but they are using that success and powerful brand image to market their laptops and desktops which is currently working.

 

 

OSX is not more secure than Windows. It is simply not attacked as much. That doesn't equate to being more secure - even their own security experts admit that Windows 7/8 are more secure operating systems. And, when you place them side by side with a team of hackers - it's OSX that gets hacked quickest.

 

http://www.dailytech.com/Apples+OS+X+is+First+OS+to+be+Hacked+at+This+Years+Pwn2Own/article21097.htm

http://www.tomshardware.com/news/hack-windows-security-snow-leopard,8704.html

 

Windows is more secure specifically because it gets targeted. I've run three separate installs of Windows 7 and Windows 8 over the last 6 years and I've not had one single virus or malware. Nothing. Nada. Zilch.

 

As for market share, I have a copy of Custom PC magazine from 2006 that states OSX's share in the desktop market at about 6%. Apparently it's now 7%, so their market share has barely changed in 7 years. You say Windows has lost 10% but I think that's rubbish, only when you start factoring in mobile devices and iPads can you portray MS as having lost market share. Windows 7 was the biggest and fastest selling OS in history. And Windows 8 has already overtaken Vista and using projected sales Windows 8 alone will be used by more people than OSX by about March/April time.

 

That isn't even the point however. The point is, specifically when it comes to the corporate market. Microsoft have it all sewn up. A few students and young people and trendy businesses adopting Mac OSX isn't going to change that because those are still very small numbers.

 

Take a bank for example. My brother helped build the IT infrastructure for one of the biggest banks in the world. Their entire network and systems and infrastructure runs on Windows, with some Linux on the back end. Their tens of thousands of staff know how to use Windows, and all the software that they use has been coded to only run on Windows.

 

Now are you seriously suggesting that there is a threat to that? Why would they switch to an OS that isn't designed to be used in that manner (OSX is designed for the end user) at a cost of hundreds of millions of dollars...only for every single one of their staff to need training at great expense and great loss of revenue and all their software also need to be completely re-written to work on OSX? It would be such a tremendously huge operation for little or no gain.

 

I nearly forgot - you'd have to replace every single computer with Macs. Yeah - it's not going to happen.

 

Sorry, but Apple may make some minor inroads into the consumer desktop PC market, but Microsoft and Linux have the corporate industry sector sewn up so tight it will never switch over to OSX. It would be far, far too expensive and unnecessary. You can get a PC workstation suitable for general use for about £300...cheapest Mac is what...£1000? Come on, use your brain, it's never going to happen.

@bmike, I think the discussion is around Windows not being the dominant OS, not OS X being the dominant one. I also fear your interpretation of OS X being less secure is a little naive. Read a little more around the fundamental differences of the Unix architecture vs. Windows - specifically related to robustness and security. My understanding from my research is that, theoretically, you cannot get a true virus on a well-written *nix OS.

 

I'm not trying to be "clever" with you - just have a read for yourself. If you find anything credible that contradicts the above, I'd certainly be interested in reading it.

 

[Edit: The above all sounds a bit snarky, it's definitely not supposed to. Poorly written, sorry Mike.]

 

Whilst I agree that Mac OS <insert number> is an extremely unlikely candidate for majority corporate market-share, I'd also give Windows that same arbitrary likeliness value. I fully expect it to be a new, or further developed, *nix OS.

 

I prefer Unix over Windows. I personally think it has several benefits for users in our industry, and I enjoy the near-perfect robustness of it. As discussed, this is subjective.

Edited by andy9l
Grammar.

I used to use Windows and bought my first iMac a few years ago and haven't looked back since as in there isn't anything I miss about Windows. I now have a nice Apple collection consisting of an iMac, MacBook Pro, iPad, iPhone and even bought Apple TV for the hell of it.

1. Really - can you link me? Especially if it's retina laptops since I'm thinking of buying one.

2. Aluminium and glass generally costs more than plastic, and why are other companies trying so hard to replicate Apple designs?

3. Subjective (you also contradicted yourself here on point 2!)

4. So Coda (2), arguably one of the best code editors available, is no good? Final Cut? Aperture? Sublime Text? Terminal? FaceTime? Pages? Keynote?

5. Agreed, but they need to market!

6. I've upgraded mine using products from third-party manufacturers so I think that's probably proof that this is untrue ;)

 

Your point about gaming may also be short-lived, as EA and other manufacturers start supporting OS X (more...). Personally I don't game much at all, but you might be interested :)

1. There are videos, on YouTube, based on these computers overheating. When I say overheat, I mean the computer's slim designs are causing no air flow, and these computers get really hot, and really loud.

2. Never knew that they are replicating it. Do not know why, either. The designs are too slim, and that causes problems with heat. Besides: buy an iMac for $1,299, or buy computer parts to build your own power machine for $1,000. Which one will I choose? The PC!

3. Not gonna say anything.

4. Coda does suck. Final Cut is a total... crashing freak. Adobe After Effects is one-million times better. Dreamweaver is best for making web design/development much easier. Terminal runs best on Linux, not the iMac. Pages sucks. Keynote is pretty good.

5. Sure. They need to market the "Good" things.

6. Not sure if you understand what I mean. Not gonna hear my own voice, again.

 

Yeah! I can finally play Crysis 3, and modern games on these specs: iMac Tech Specs. Sounds fun, doesn't it? Please... stay with your "Working" category. There is no way in hell that PC gamers that can customize their cases, and eye candy with a cheesy white plain/stale slim/heating box. Imagine the heating overload that these slim designs are gonna be facing? Unless you buy the Mac Pro for $2,400 that has a quad core. What the hell?! A quad core coming with a $2,400 computer?! Damn... I have a six core processor, 16GB of DDR3 RAM, Nvidia GTX 660 Ti, and a Gigabyte motherboard with a 1TB HDD. The total cost of my system: $1,400. Look at the specs of that Mac Pro. Totally not worth it. Mac Pro Tech Specs. My computer runs pretty damn good, and one-million times better than any ordinary iMac. I can put cooling fans/mods into my PC and make them last for ages. These Macs don't stand a chance.

Edited by GoldRush98

Apple are going the wrong way about cracking the corporate market: sidelining the Mac Pro (workstations are a big market and iMacs simply can't compete in that space, especially for intensive tasks like CAD or rendering) and completely killing their server line.

Homogeneous Windows networks have a much lower TCO, from the point of view that admins don't have to be knowledgeable about more than one platform.

As far as personal preference goes: I game heavily (yes, games companies are taking more notice of OSX, but hell, Valve are even porting Steam and their Source-based games to Linux now), I'm a hardware nut and most importantly, I can't afford the dip in productivity that a platform switch would cost me. The best platform is always going to be the one you're most familiar with.

 

Edit: obviously my love of building my own kit can't really extend to laptops, and I hate the way the world and his dog are copying Apple's designs. Until someone comes up with a better-designed Windows laptop than this, I'm keeping mine.

Edited by Renaissance-Design

1. There are videos, on YouTube, based on these computers overheating. When I say overheat, I mean the computer's slim designs are causing no air flow, and these computers get really hot, and really loud.

2. Never knew that they are replicating it. Do not know why, either. The designs are too slim, and that causes problems with heat. Besides: buy an iMac for $1,299, or buy computer parts to build your own power machine for $1,000. Which one will I choose? The PC!

3. Not gonna say anything.

4. Coda does suck. Final Cut is a total... crashing freak. Adobe After Effects is one-million times better. Dreamweaver is best for making web design/development much easier. Terminal runs best on Linux, not the iMac. Pages sucks. Keynote is pretty good.

5. Sure. They need to market the "Good" things.

6. Not sure if you understand what I mean. Not gonna hear my own voice, again.

 

Yeah! I can finally play Crysis 3, and modern games on these specs: iMac Tech Specs. Sounds fun, doesn't it? Please... stay with your "Working" category. There is no way in hell that PC gamers that can customize their cases, and eye candy with a cheesy white plain/stale slim/heating box. Imagine the heating overload that these slim designs are gonna be facing? Unless you buy the Mac Pro for $2,400 that has a quad core. What the hell?! A quad core coming with a $2,400 computer?! Damn... I have a six core processor, 16GB of DDR3 RAM, Nvidia GTX 660 Ti, and a Gigabyte motherboard with a 1TB HDD. The total cost of my system: $1,400. Look at the specs of that Mac Pro. Totally not worth it. Mac Pro Tech Specs. My computer runs pretty damn good, and one-million times better than any ordinary iMac. I can put cooling fans/mods into my PC and make them last for ages. These Macs don't stand a chance.

 

Goldrush,

 

I have no problem with you stating your opinions, but some of your sarcastic comments are factually incorrect (to my knowledge), and I'd like to pick up on them...

 

Main points are in bold, with some, mostly factual (to the best of my knowledge), information below.

 

Dreamweaver/Code comment

Dreamweaver is often regarded by many professionals, here or elsewhere, as poor web editing software - unless you're using "Code View". At the point when you're just using code view, you've just spent several £100's on something that you can get for cheaper/FREE...that's faster, and open-source. Netbeans, Coda 2, Sublime Text, etc..

 

Price of Macs Apple products

The price of a Mac an Apple product is irrelevant. It's a premium brand, and you get more than just a product when you buy into it. In the case of their Mac range - if you don't care for that, or you prefer Windows, I agree that a PC is better. This is completely subjective.

 

Final Cut

Honestly I have no experience with this software, but considering the number of hugely successful films that have been edited on it, I find it hard to believe it's a "crashing freak". It's professional video editing software, made by a company who are famous for their extremely reliable software. I'm not saying their software doesn't go wrong sometimes, but on the whole, it's pretty damn robust. I personally believe the success of iOS is largely based on this reliability.

 

Terminal runs better on Linux than Mac

This is incorrect. Mac OS X is built on the Unix architecture. Linux is built on the Unix architecture. Terminal is 99.9% equal on both. They run absolutely identically. Command Prompt is not Terminal, but Linux Terminal is OS X Terminal.

 

Your point regarding 'no upgradability options'

Again, there are countless threads on forums of people who are upgrading their Macs with SSDs, RAM, new monitors, the usual lot. Sure, they're not as customisable as a PC - I would never dispute that - but you said it's impossible unless you go through Apple, which is incorrect. I've done it with my own Macs.

 

Quad-core processors

You seem to have a fairly fundamental misunderstanding here, and I'll never claim to be an expert - but I'll try to explain as best I can. Besides the fact that nearly all Macs come with a form of quad-core processor (which you said isn't true), there are different CPU microarchitectures. The processor in the Mac Pro (Xeon architecture) is considerably better than other quad-core Sandy/Ivy Bridge CPUs at certain tasks. It does not have built in graphics capabilities, because a Mac Pro is used with 1 or more high-end graphics cards. However it has 8MB shared L3 cache (per processor) which is far greater than the typical 3-6MB you get on typical consumer PCs/Macs. There's a hell of a lot more to a processor than number of cores - I suggest you research into this. Again, nearly all of the Macs used quad-cores, except low-end laptops, of which some try to cater for by using i7 hyperthreading. You do not need to buy a Mac Pro for a "quad-core processor". I don't know what processor you're using, so cannot make a more specific example.

 

I'm no gamer, so cannot comment on gaming experiences. A PC is undoubtedly better for gaming in the current climate - I was simply directing you to some information about gaming on Macs, there was no need to reply sarcastically.

 

Anyway, as I said, I've tried to be as useful/informative as possible by keeping factual and refraining from sarcasm. Please respect that if you reply.

 

Hopefully others can pick up on any mistakes/misunderstandings I've written in my post - I'm striving to understand more about this stuff, as Chris (Renaissance-Design) knows. I'd like to be corrected...preferably not sarcastically.

I have a six core processor, 16GB of DDR3 RAM, Nvidia GTX 660 Ti, and a Gigabyte motherboard with a 1TB HDD.

 

Very happy for you, but I think you've made a poor platform choice there. How do I know? Well, you said you have a 6-core processor and 16GB of RAM. The multiple of 4GB rather than 6GB means you've gone for an AMD Phenom II: a 6-core processor with lower performance per clock than an equivalent Intel chip, lower L3 cache and lower memory bandwidth. Two Intel cores easily outperform three AMD at the same clockspeed in all but the most heavily multithreaded tasks (rendering, encoding etc). Apple have made a smart move by going with Intel.

 

You mention having a 1TB disk where I'd hope you'd have solid state, because that makes more difference than any other component. Spinny platters are slow.

 

Finally, you've mentioned the major component specs, but what make and model are your case, PSU and cooling? Unless you've made some smart choices there, you've totally negated the PC advantage. Yup, you've been using PCs for a long while. Andy's coming from a background of the hardware being a black box of no-touchiness, and he's making a concerted effort to understand the subsystems under his shiny aluminium kit. He's even disapproving of some decisions Apple are making, due to being better-informed than people who are content to accept the Mac as a sealed-box appliance.

 

Lemme tell you something for free: Andy has cracked open an iMac and made a modification that it was never intended to take using third-party components, and my hat's off to him. It's not like our world of easily-accessible components in there, this is more akin to when I used to overclock Prestonia-core Xeons by wiring the pins together, and he deserves a bit of kudos for that.

Edited by Renaissance-Design

Sorry I jumped a fair few posts in this thread, my opinion is:

 

Windows is always open to attack and vulnerabilities, after a year of use, you have no clue what could be residing on your machine, it also needs to be defragmented often, when using in a critical environment where you simply can not afford a crash, like a live event, be prepared for a crash.

 

Mac: Although more expensive, looks loads better, imo runs a lot smoother, no viruses (99% of the time) no malware, doesnt need defragging as thats always done automatically, and will not let you down when you need it the most, ie: live event etc

 

Linux: Due to cost (Free) I would say this is the best option of all, the downside of Linux is you do need to understand the CLI (command line interface) but everything is open source and free, also no viruses, and doesnt need defragging.

 

I use all of these OS's and some, and I have also used PC and Mac in a professional enviroment where crashing is not an option, needless to say the PC always crashed in this kind of enviroment, since I used a mac in gigs/events Ive never had a crash since, yes the mac is more expensive, but its not about cost, its about performance at any price, so I will leave that part to you, if you can afford to have a machine let you down from time to time go with the PC, if you want something that 99.9% of the time wont crash, and in that very rare occasion does and backs everything up for your restart, go with the latter.

 

Linux is free, and you dont need to install it to test it, you can run it off a USB stick, check Ubuntu for the latest and greatest Linux OS.

 

Good luck

This is probably the most intelligent and "friendly" discussion on PCs and Macs. All the other ones I've come across on the web end up in personal stuff. The discussion here is based on facts and everyone is respecting each other's opinions.

 

Having that said, I think I am going to switch to a Retina MacBook Pro later this year.

 

To share my opinion though, I think I could sum it up to this:

Find a system (whether OS X or Windows) that works for you and your needs. Then, maximize its potential.

Having that said, I think I am going to switch to a Retina MacBook Pro later this year.

If you're planning on getting one a bit later - make sure you wait until the new Summer/Autumn releases for Haswell processors! ;)

With all this discussion going on, methinks a view on macrumors is due. Itching for a new iMac.

BUY NOW! They've only just sorted out the production lines for them - no way are they going to update it again until later this year, or early next.

 

I'm waiting for the new bloomin' Thunderbolt Display (TBD)! iMac production problems causing delays...they're handing out free adapters with the current ones since the charging cable isn't natively compatible with newer MBPs (not very "Apple-like"). If it weren't for that problem, I'd have bought a 13" rMBP and a TBD right now - but the longer they put off the new TBD, the more likely I am to wait until June for Haswell. There's a thread over there with people in the same position that I'm following - I'm sure supplier executive heads are rolling somewhere.

 

As for MacRumors - that is a place where the deluded Apple fans live and breed. If you dislike Apple, or their products, I suggest you never visit the forums - for the sake of your own blood pressure.

 

The buying guide, however, is useful. Saved myself and friends a few disappointments in the past.

Edited by andy9l

Currently in the process of forking out for some stationary at the moment (no, not pencils ;)) so I might have to wait a tad longer. I got my MBP in October or November as a way of being a bit more mobile but have found I use it for everything except graphics. Wish I forked out for the retina now. Still, off to that J word I use too much in the summer. Thinking about getting some Mac stuff then as it's cheaper and I'll always associate the product as a holiday purchase ;)

 

Was a frequent user of macrumors a while back. I was brought into the Apple world (ooer!) by a hardcore Apple Texan (there's a title for you). We used to discuss macrumors and used to listen to Ken (forgot his name) mac updates via podcast all the time as well as Kevin Rose stuff and Leo whats-his-face. Since coming back a couple of years ago, I've stopped listening to podcasts and haven't looked at macrumors either. It's a sense of welcome nostalgia so I've just bookmarked the page.

 

Ooohh... thunderbolt. Great stuff. Been thinking about getting an cinema display too but can't justify £899 at the moment. More likely to get an elusive Intuos first (pending permission). Hello eBay!

I like options in the hardware department, the amount of times I have to listen
to other designers i know complaining about the bill to fix or replace mac
parts. You can just rock into a computer store and grab a component of the
shelf and fit it yourself in a mac, you can with a pc. saying all that i have
both, because I'm a tech hoarder! but 99% of all my work is done on pc.

 



Great thread so far people, i'm contemplating getting a mac at the moment but so far my budget is £1000 but i am in no rush so i could save and pay more,what i'm asking myself is what is better for future proof? Retina and ssd drive? I dont want to rush be to hasty, so keep on selling ideas to me ;)

To be honest the reason I'm PC and Windows is becase of games. You can only play a fraction of the games on a Mac or a PC running linux. Then again, as soon as my PC gets too old to play games I usually install linux unbuntu instead of windows...

I've used both, and I like both. I really appreciate Apples UI and fantastic quality as far as hardware goes, but when it comes to price and upgrade-ability, PC's are hard to beat!

Great thread so far people, i'm contemplating getting a mac at the moment but so far my budget is £1000 but i am in no rush so i could save and pay more,what i'm asking myself is what is better for future proof? Retina and ssd drive? I dont want to rush be to hasty, so keep on selling ideas to me ;)

 

For a £1000 budget I would probably suggest you also look at Windows powered Ultrabooks. There is no denying that Macs are expensive, but part of the reason for this is that there are no "budget" Macs. They start at relatively high-spec, and so when compared to other manufacturer equivalents, the "premium" people talk about is not so significant (but it's still there).

 

You do NOT need a "retina" display. If you have a tight budget, it's not worth the money right now. Relatively few websites and apps are optimised right now, so most of what you do on there will not show in retina quality anyway. They're a bit ahead of their time in that respect. A SSD, however, is an absolute must. I'd actually argue that buying a PC/Mac these days without a SSD (as the primary drive) is a complete waste of money - regardless of the other specs. Regular HDDs have become a bottleneck.

 

Do you have a system that works well for you now that you could post the details of? Everyones needs are different, and this is something I've learned to appreciate in recent years. Too many developers, and I'm guilty of this, head into an Apple store with this in their mind: "I'm a developer, I need POWER". It's simply not true. You do not need a high-speed quad-core i7 to run Photoshop and a code editor...in-fact on a Mac, my 4 year old Core 2 Duo handles those tasks to near perfection. The processor will never be utilised to its full potential...let alone start hyperthreading. The top end 15" MacBook Pros are almost fully-blown high-end desktop replacements.

 

This is why I am looking at getting a very "mid-spec" Mac for my next Mac, and saving myself some dollar to buy the Apple Thunderbolt Display with it. Regardless of what some people say, in my experience, Macs last a bloody long time. Buying myself a mid-spec 13" retina MBP (I want the smaller 13" laptop for portability) will keep me going for another 2-3 years without a flicker of doubt. I'd actually put a hefty bet on the fact that it'll still be a fairly "instant" machine in 2 years time, in fact. In 2 or 3 years from now, however, I hope Apple will have developed a proper touchscreen desktop OS, and be selling touchscreen MacBooks/iMacs...but we shall see.

 

That's just my opinion, and as you probably noticed, I'm a Mac user.

For a £1000 budget I would probably suggest you also look at Windows powered Ultrabooks. There is no denying that Macs are expensive, but part of the reason for this is that there are no "budget" Macs. They start at relatively high-spec, and so when compared to other manufacturer equivalents, the "premium" people talk about is not so significant (but it's still there).

 

You do NOT need a "retina" display. If you have a tight budget, it's not worth the money right now. Relatively few websites and apps are optimised right now, so most of what you do on there will not show in retina quality anyway. They're a bit ahead of their time in that respect. A SSD, however, is an absolute must. I'd actually argue that buying a PC/Mac these days without a SSD (as the primary drive) is a complete waste of money - regardless of the other specs. Regular HDDs have become a bottleneck.

 

Do you have a system that works well for you now that you could post the details of? Everyones needs are different, and this is something I've learned to appreciate in recent years. Too many developers, and I'm guilty of this, head into an Apple store with this in their mind: "I'm a developer, I need POWER". It's simply not true. You do not need a high-speed quad-core i7 to run Photoshop and a code editor...in-fact on a Mac, my 4 year old Core 2 Duo handles those tasks to near perfection. The processor will never be utilised to its full potential...let alone start hyperthreading. The top end 15" MacBook Pros are almost fully-blown high-end desktop replacements.

 

This is why I am looking at getting a very "mid-spec" Mac for my next Mac, and saving myself some dollar to buy the Apple Thunderbolt Display with it. Regardless of what some people say, in my experience, Macs last a bloody long time. Buying myself a mid-spec 13" retina MBP (I want the smaller 13" laptop for portability) will keep me going for another 2-3 years without a flicker of doubt. I'd actually put a hefty bet on the fact that it'll still be a fairly "instant" machine in 2 years time, in fact. In 2 or 3 years from now, however, I hope Apple will have developed a proper touchscreen desktop OS, and be selling touchscreen MacBooks/iMacs...but we shall see.

 

That's just my opinion, and as you probably noticed, I'm a Mac user.

 

At the moment i have a desktop with 1 TB Hard drive just regular and 8 gig of memory Kingston 1066 mhz and a AMD A6 3500 processor on a ASUS F1A55- MLE motherboard, operating system Windows 7 64 bit, for my needs at present its fine, there is room for upgrade like SSD drive and a quad core processor currently 3 or more memory up to 32 gig, For my home needs.

 

For out and about, I don't have a laptop, so i thought to myself "Ok i could maybe get a Mac" i'm not in a great rush, but when i buy i want bang for buck and have a friend who could get me a discount of nearly £200.I have always used Windows so fancy a change or challenge.

 

My main programs is Sublime text 2, Photoshop ,Illustrator, Blender and also i am learning myself photography and web design

not much of a gamer.

 

You know your stuff on Macs, and the more i read the more i am sold.

Edited by spweb

I'm just gonna quite giving my thoughts. I hate fighting over stupid stuff. Before I say goodbye to this cat-fight, I want to say that "Mac Books are diffidently better than Windows laptops". The end :p

PC for me.

 

I just bought a new Samsung laptop; i5 processor, 8GB ram, GT650M, 1GB HDD for just over £500 brand new and its nice and nippy and capable of running every game I've thrown at it so far on, at the minimum, middle of the road settings.

 

I could never jusify the cost for a Mac, but then, that it just me.

 

It takes all sorts to make the world go round :)

I'm a Mac user, simply because my background is music, and Logic Pro is Mac specific, makes a nice design platform too :)

 

- Nemo

@spweb, Like you, I get a reasonably hefty discount at Apple - 15% to be precise - which does help take away some of the pain of inserting my debit card to their modded iPhone portable tills!

 

My main programs is Sublime text 2, Photoshop ,Illustrator, Blender and also i am learning myself photography and web design not much of a gamer.

 

Any Mac in the entire shop will run those without trouble. Regardless, I'd recommend steering clear of the Airs because they're not sporting the most future-proof specs right now.

What kind of hard-drive space do you need? Could you deal with putting your tv shows/movies on an external drive, just leaving music media on the primary internal one?

 

Edit: Two possible recommendations for you would be the baseline 13" retina MacBook Pro - giving you SSD performance, a reasonably processor, and of course an indisputably impressive screen. This is about £50 over your budget after your discount.

 

If you want to avoid retina (you lose a CD drive), there's also the baseline MacBook Pro with the RAM and SSD upgrades (make sure you tick them on that page) - taking you to £1239, which, after your discount, leaves you about £40 over budget.

Edited by andy9l
Spacing

I can't vote as I haven't used MAC enough to cast a fair vote. Hoping to get one in the future though. Linux on a PC at the moment is a win!

Linux is good. They are improving with their UI. The latest Fedora is great. I remember using it around 2007, and the UI was simple, but ugly compared to Windows Vista, Snow Leopard, etc.. Linux is peaking around the corner.

Edited by GoldRush98

Linux is good. They are improving with their UI. The latest Fedora is great. I remember using it around 2007, and the UI was simple, but ugly compared to Windows Vista, Snow Leopard, etc.. Linux is peaking around the corner.

 

It's better than Windows but unfortunately I can't see it going mainstream as Microsoft is huge and people like the familiarity. Non-techies also struggle with resolving issues within Linux as well. Vista was an abomination!

We use both but love Mac's in the office. Most of the time thought we run with either BootCamp (Windows 7 Ultimate) or VirtualPC installed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.