Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

iPhone 5

Featured Replies

Awesome video :D thanks for making me laugh for like 20 minutes Andy :D

  • Replies 118
  • Views 11.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • So, you've not even seen, or used, the product, yet it's a complete let down. Sounds fair. As for losing their way, apparently the global market would disagree. And that phone on your desk - it was or

  • Yeah, best to read only the actual specs.     Thought the spam had been quiet on here lately...

Posted Images

forgive me if I'm wrong, but wern't phones running windows ce considered "smartphones" before IOS, Android and Symbian?

Most probably. Again, I never said the iPhone was the first Smartphone - we all know that's far from the truth.

Due for an upgrade in January. I think I'll pick one up then. Kind of miffed about the new adaptor though. I have two or three iOS devices that I use regularly and I like the fact they all use the same connector. Ah well.

I got an iphone4S and a ipad3 - When you hold them you can just feel the quality (sounds silly to say that I know) but one thing above all is the user experience, I have played with a few other phones and the Nexus tablet and they seem very complicated and busy.

 

For me its not the spec - I don't think oh that screen is much better then that one, or thats got 64gb and thats got 32gb - its the ease of use for me.

 

I'm not a techy guy, I know what I like so I guess the above gives you an idea what a non-techy thinks.

Edited by opensesame

Well if you're an iPhone user already it is an upgrade, a minimal one yes but still a welcome one.

Also a hell of a lot of people would get it with their contract any way.

Is it worth to purchase, this much expensive device for just a few new features?

 

The way I see it, it's either that or a Samsung with a slightly bigger screen, as it stands. If you do not have the spare cash, a plastic Samsung is for you. If not, or perhaps you just like spending your money on technology, the iPhone has an incredibly better build quality. Hence this "premium" you're referring to.

 

What does it matter? I certainly won't be judging anyone if they have a Samsung or an iPhone. Hell, I'm still somewhat caught up on which to get. As described before, I'll most likely opt for the iPhone purely because, in my opinion at least, it's not any worse than the S3, but primarily because I'm tightly invested in the Apple product line - owning two iMacs, a MacBook Pro, an iPad 2, an iPhone 4, and an iPhone 3G (don't worry, it sits in a drawer!). If I start to include family products in that, the list expands. My girlfriend has also just bought a MacBook Air, and is waiting for the iPhone 5 to be released so she can get the 4S for cheap (she's no tech fan!). I can't help but imagine that the Samsung would wreak havoc when connecting to all of that metal and glass!

Edited by andyl

Saw this on Twitter, chortled.

 

var iPhone5 = $('.iPhone4S').clone().css('-webkit-transform', 'scaleY(110%)');

Edited by Renaissance-Design

"iOS - The world's most advanced mobile operating system."

 

Been looking through Apple's iPhone stuff on Apple.com. They're still claiming the above - can it be claimed without basis? I would like to know how it's more advanced than Android, purely out of interest.

maybe it's relative ie. it's advanced more from where it came than the others?

Preordered mine at 3:45 am. Going to be here on the 21st. I just love how it works so well with everything I have and I love airplay to my apple TV. The quality of apps on the iPhone are 10x's better than on Android...

The quality of apps on the iPhone are 10x's better than on Android...

 

Are they not mostly the same? There's only so much my torch app can accomplish. :mellow:

Edited by andyl

 

 

Are they not mostly the same? There's only so much my torch app can accomplish. :mellow:

 

Pretty much. Most of the top decent apps have a version for each OS, the only difference being that Android is (was?) a little less 'policed' meaning there's a lot of crap about but the same could be said for all mobile app stores.

Pretty much. Most of the top decent apps have a version for each OS, the only difference being that Android is (was?) a little less 'policed' meaning there's a lot of crap about but the same could be said for all mobile app stores.

 

That's what I thought. There's more dross on the Android store, or whatever Google call it now, but amongst the dross is an array of Java ported popular iOS apps.

 

I just watched some S3 promo adverts from the likes of Samsung, Vodafone and other phone shops who aren't worthy of mention. I like, very much. It really is just a cheaper iPhone. If I didn't rely on FaceTime and iMessage so much, I could see myself getting the S3 and a SSD for my MacBook Pro. Two birds with one iPhone. Only thing I dislike is the cheap build quality, I must admit.

 

Edit: Line spaces galore.

Edited by andyl

The thing is, like you've said, if you're a mac user and your day is spent using the 'i' line of products then the iPhone is the perfect accompaniment.

 

That's the reason i went with an Android phone, my day was spent dealing with Google products,the hackability was just a happy extra.

 

I've been eyeing up WP8 lately mind you, in particular the Nokia Lumina 920.

 

I've been eyeing up WP8 lately mind you

 

*shudder*

 

I'll go as far as Android, but WP - no way. Feels like someone block filled a wireframe and sold it as an OS! :p

Haha yeah the whole Win 8 thing is a bit Marmite. However i've been finding Windows 8 an absolute beauty to work with and the connectivity between it and the XBOX is superb. I feel that adding a new WP8 device could really complete the family for me (and then replace my iPad with a Surface at a later date ;) ).

Plenty of people design websites like that. It's different, technically quite difficult to achieve, and looks fantastic on screen. If I were that capable with Photoshop, I'd be making bits and bobs in that style too. Ok, perhaps not a full website.

 

For me, WP8 looks like an Android/iOS predecessor - not good if it's the youngest.

 

I can't believe that either of you could deny that this would be a better interface than a drop-down selection. At the moment he's using it for a website, but you could use it in an app, or anywhere.

 

Perhaps I'm still a little immature, in this sense, and student-y? (Shiny is better!!1!1) Functionally, they all get the job done for the most part.

Edited by andyl

  • Author

The way I see it, it's either that or a Samsung with a slightly bigger screen, as it stands. If you do not have the spare cash, a plastic Samsung is for you. If not, or perhaps you just like spending your money on technology, the iPhone has an incredibly better build quality.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elKxgsrJFhw

 

The iPhone 4S doesn't have better build quality than the Galaxy. The build of an iPhone feels better, but it isn't better quality in terms of durability and it's ability to cope with accidents.

 

Case in point, the most common accident we have with our phones - dropping. This video clearly demonstrates that when dropped, even from a fairly low height, the iPhone is bricked. The glass just cracks and shatters. The S2 on the other hand suffers nothing close to the same damage and is still a perfectly usable phone. No cracks, no shattered glass.

 

This notion that plastic is cheap and tacky is wrong. It's a very deliberate design choice. Plastics can be engineered to have selected properties much more easily than alloys. Metal is, by and large, extremely rigid. Rigid feels good, but it's not good for dealing with impacts. Rigid materials simply act as extremely good shock conductors, which is why the 4S' screen shatters when dropped. It's not the screen, it's the metal case.

 

The S2s plastic body allows it to absorb shock, protecting the screen far better. It may not feel as good, but frankly for me, I'd rather have a phone I can drop and not have to replace. If I had an iPhone 5, I'd have to wrap it up in a protective case, making it chunkier and heavier.

 

Even when it comes to toughness, the S2s plastic is not really any worse than the iPhone. Admittedly, plastic tends to look shabbier over time then metal, but in terms of scratches my S2 has held up fine, and I don't use a case or protective sleeve or anything.

 

Also, the battery cover. Yes, it's flexible. Again, this is deliberate. A rigid battery cover is much easier to break when you take it off. A peelable, flexible cover allows you to remove it in such a way that you'll never break it. There's dozens on videos on YouTube showing people flexing the cover numerous times and it just returns to normal.

 

Anyway, point is, plastic is often actually a better design choice. Apple use metal because it feels good, they're concerned with how the customer feels and reacts emotionally when they hold their phone. That's fine - until the customer drops it. Samsung on the other hand stuck to using modern plastics that are far better at dealing with drops and impacts.

 

I'm sure you will say that you've dropped your iPhone numerous times etc etc - but the only fair comparison is to drop both phones in the same way from the same height, and as the video shows, one holds up, the other doesn't. I know which I'd rather have in my pocket.

Edited by brightonmike

Good point BM.

 

What about mi solution?

post-16168-0-35098000-1347884507_thumb.jpeg

  • Author

"However, the cheap build quality of the Galaxy S3 - which was established when we opened up the back to insert the SIM, a task that made us cringe with the fear that it might actually break - means the Iphone's design and build quality has to take the crown in this round.

The Inquirer (http://s.tt/1hE5U)"

 

This is how most comparisons go. And it's wrong. Why? This bit:

 

"a task that made us cringe with the fear that it might actually break"

 

Did the cover break? No, it didn't. It did exactly what it was supposed to do. But they marked it down anyway basically because they were scared it would break. That doesn't seem fair or logical to me.

 

These people, they mark down the Galaxy's on build quality, but they always judge it on how it "feels". How something feels is not build quality, and if you are going to judge it like that, make sure you're up to date on your materials. Plastic does not mean cheap and prone to cracking/breaking. The Galaxy's for example are made of polycarbonate, which is an extremely solid and tough material.

To illustrate my point about how the two sides have evolved in comparison.

 

Android, Android Phone, iPhone - 2007

 

android2007.jpgiphone.jpg

 

 

Android, Android Phone, iPhone - 2012

 

android-jelly-bean-01.jpgbuiltinapps_image.png

 

I think that just highlights how much Apple has had with regards to influence in the production of Android products.

 

Don't get me wrong, I too (being an iPhone user since they came out) was a bit underwhelmed and will not be buying the phone whilst in contract like I have done previously.

 

I just think that all these phones are starting to hit the ceiling for lack of a better analogy; there really isn't much more they can do hardware-wise without the cost of the devices rising exponentially.

 

It will come down to software in the end, and at the moment, I will be sticking with Apple because it works so well with everything in my life and work.

I'm sorry bmike, but in my books, oleophobic coated glass and brushed aluminium is a better build quality than (insert poly-word) plastic. Glass breaks if you're unlucky when you drop it, sure. Plastic scratches worse though. Your S2 is easier to scratch than my current iPhone, but it's harder to shatter.

 

I know which I'd prefer to have in my pocket, alongside my keys. My pockets don't have holes in. Touché.

Plastic scratches worse though.

 

Depends on the plastic. "Plastic" covers a greater spectrum than "rock" these days - which covers everything from talc (1 Mohs) to diamond (10 Mohs).

 

For the record: I have a phone which is alu and glass. It's glass only where it needs to be (the screen), and the screen is surrounded by an extruded lip of aluminium, so falling on a flat surface cannot scratch the glass. This has been borne out by experimentation. That fact alone sets it above the last couple of generations of iPhone, which have set form above function to such a degree that they use a sub-optimal material for the rear of the device. Add to that the fact that the aluminium body of the device fits the hand perfectly, and to my mind that's a win.

 

Andy, if one of your mates has a Desire HD, fondle it - if your iPhone fits your hand better, it can only mean that your hand is a crude prosthesis.

Edited by Renaissance-Design
Typos.

i have an iMac and iPhone I will be getting the iphone5 next week, i stick to apple because all the devices work well together and sync nicely, I've played with android a lot (HMV every morning before i start work on a tablet) but i never liked it.

 

i dont think it boils down to something as little of which is "slightly" better i think there is a lot more to consider, also im really excited about 4G coming to the UK at Christmas i think a iPad will be on the cards then

I'm not in any rush to trade up my 4S, that's for sure. Taller? m'eh! Big deal.

 

I am desperately awaiting the new iMac though :D

Andy, if one of your mates has a Desire HD, fondle it - if your iPhone fits your hand better, it can only mean that your hand is a crude prosthesis.

 

Oh yeh, I've already agreed that the iPhone isn't the most comfortable thing in the world. I'm referring to the quality of the materials used and the finished product from a build perspective.

 

I suppose if you factor usability/ergonomics into the build quality, the iPhone may not win. But, to me at least, build quality is the quality of the finished physical item, the materials it's comprised of, the manufacturing precision/techniques, all alongside it's complexity. The build quality of a Ferrari is greater than that of a Toyota Corolla (in my books), but I bet the Toyota withstands the average crash (or being dropped...) better than the Ferrari.

Edited by andyl

  • Author

Oh yeh, I've already agreed that the iPhone isn't the most comfortable thing in the world. I'm referring to the quality of the materials used and the finished product from a build perspective.

 

I suppose if you factor usability/ergonomics into the build quality, the iPhone may not win. But, to me at least, build quality is the quality of the finished physical item, the materials it's comprised of, the manufacturing precision/techniques, all alongside it's complexity. The build quality of a Ferrari is greater than that of a Toyota Corolla (in my books), but I bet the Toyota withstands the average crash (or being dropped...) better than the Ferrari.

 

I think you're confusing ergonomics and build quality. Ergonomics is how nice the device feels to use, how it makes you feel, how well it works for you. In that respect, I imagine when most people hold an iPhone it would win. It feels nicer, it feels sturdier, more solid, more dependable.

 

But that isn't build quality. Build quality (for me at least) is a combination of how well it withstands the test of every day use as well as how well it copes when accidents of varying sorts happen.

 

The same goes for your car analogy. A Ferrari will feel better built but it probably isn't better built than the average family car, supercars are well known for often having terrible build quality. Bits falling off, cracking. Hell, one of the latest Ferrari's has been plagued with build quality issues that caused the vehicle to spontaneously combust at any moment.

 

As far as I'm concerned and am aware, the most common accident people have with their phone is dropping it. I'm not sure about keys in pockets with phones, it feels extremely tight and uncomfortable for me, so I don't know for sure but personally I always just put my keys in the other pocket so scratching isn't an issue for me. Whilst polycarbonate itself has low scratch resistance, a coating can be applied to add this. How good that coating is will depend on how much the manufacturer can spend on it, for example on CD's and DVDs which are made of polycarbonate the coating is cheap so they scratch very easily. I can't see any scratches on my phone though so I think the coating on the S2s plastic is pretty good.

 

Aside from dropping the phone, which I think the S2 is much better at coping with, there is the issue of day to day use. I'm not sure exactly where I stand between the two on this. There's my girlfriends 4S and my S2 and both are a similar age and to be honest if you put them side by side I don't think you could really pick a winner as to which phone still looks the best.

 

All I can say is I've dropped my S2 probably hundreds of times and it's never damaged in any way. My girlfriend dropped her 4S from her waist and the corner of the back cover is cracked and shattered. I don't want a phone that does that, I want one that can cope with accidents, because with me at least, accidents will happen!

 

But if you want something that feels nicer and feels better built...then I wouldn't hesitate in agreeing with you that the iPhone wins. It may just be our definition of build quality that we disagree on.

I've had my 3GS for over a year now. I bought a decent quality polyurethene case which doesn't add that much to the form factor and leaves the entire front facia uncovered, but it's still protected it from the numerous times I've dropped it (once on a tiled floor. Watching that happen was the longest 3 seconds of my life). I'll be getting a 5 in January when my contract renews I think.

I think you're confusing ergonomics and build quality. Ergonomics is how nice the device feels to use, how it makes you feel, how well it works for you. In that respect, I imagine when most people hold an iPhone it would win. It feels nicer, it feels sturdier, more solid, more dependable.

 

It is widely accepted that the iPhone (since the 4) is not ergonomic. Search the net - it's looks over ergonomics, and even members here agree with that (myself included). If it feels sturdier or more solid, then that is the build quality. A hot dog is ergonomic, that doesn't feel sturdy though.

 

PS. Good video :good:

Edited by andyl

It is widely accepted that the iPhone (since the 4) is not ergonomic. Search the net - it's looks over ergonomics

 

And for a product that's meant to be used in the hand, that's a design ****-up of monumental proportions. Luckily for Apple, Marketing picked up the ball.

And for a product that's meant to be used in the hand, that's a design ****-up of monumental proportions. Luckily for Apple, Marketing picked up the ball.

 

Well, that and the fact that until recent months, it ran the best mobile OS on undeniably reliable hardware, all whilst looking pretty damn sharp in comparison to almost every other phone. Arguably still the best mobile OS for non-techies - I'd argue that.

 

Of course, for 27% of all mobile users to own a single model of phone - "The iPhone" - some crazy marketing has gone on.

Edited by andyl

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.