Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Client logo feedback

Featured Replies

I am creating branding and a new logo for a client, this client owns a chandelier cleaning company, they have been established since 1910 and want to bring both their branding and website up to modern standard

 

The owner is very passionate about the business and I want to continue the traditions of the company through the branding but still bring it up to date.

 

The current old website is here http://www.elitechandelier.com

 

All I want to ask is if you think the following logo is befitting as two of the things I have considered when designing this logo is the font and style - on this page http://www.elitechandelier.com/aboutus/index.php you will see an old van of theirs, with the logo on it and the typeface they used back then, to keep the essence of the business I think this has to absolutely right, so please tell me if my following logo hits my requirements in your opinion, thank you

 

 

Morning,

 

i'm thinking, what was the brief? Have you spent "time" with the owner, to get to know him/her?

 

I think you are onto something but something doesn't sit right with this, as a concept, it's decent but I'm concerned it's too much. Could there by a way to simplify this and make it "grab" your attention more. My eye focuses on the leafs on the first glance.

 

I think the grey you have used, works best. The yellow seems a "misty" I can see why you've used it.

 

Hope this helps..

Far too much going on in that logo.

 

The thumbnail in this thread tells you that - I can't even read the name of the company. And not sure what the leaves are supposed to represent. And having the words in the logo will mean duplication in the site header (where you will also have the name of the company).

 

Why does the site need a new logo? The one they have already looks fine to me.

 

A logo needs to be scaleable from a favicon all the way up to the one on the side of the van.

Edited by fisicx

I actually quite like it and, aside from the leaves possibly being a bit distracting, don't think it's bad at all.

But can you see the detail in the thumbnail? That's about the size it will be in the header on a tablet or a phone. And even smaller as a favicon.

 

PS: I know someone who has used their services, they are really good at what they do. Just about all their work comes from referrals

Edited by fisicx

Could also be worthwhile sorting out the red rating which WOT has applied to the site.

 

https://www.mywot.com/en/scorecard/elitechandelier.com

 

Nice new logo or not having that pop up when landing on the site might mean many just move straight on elsewhere.

 

In regards to the logo it looks as if it has tipped over to one side TBH. I would rotate the outer ring clockwise so the lettering is in a more horizontal plane.

Good point, I think an alternative logo might be needed for mobile headers. Not that bothered about favicon though, they are what they are... it could just be a very simple chandelier.

So maybe just have the chandelier as the logo and put the business name to the right when needed (like on a letterhead or business card). That way there won't be any restriction on how large or small the two elements are in relation to each other.

 

That WOT thing is a total waste of time to be honest. I've just checked a few of the websites that I either built or manage and they either have no ratings are silly ratings. One of the brochure sites that I manage has practically nothing dynamic, hardly any JS and is the website of a company that has been going for over a century and it only scores its trustworthiness as 60%. I won't be using that site again.

 

WOT doesn't just look at malware and viruses it also allows for rating the trustworthiness of the business itself. Even though it is crowd sourced and therefore open to manipulation having a big red pop up warning visitors that the site and/or business is not to be trusted is in many cases going to be an issue. When the visitor is contemplating parting with a sizeable sum of cash and probably lives in a property worth burgling the last thing you want is a warning being popped up that your business is dodgy.

 

Probably a disgruntled customer or even the competition trying to put the boot in but unfortunately the general public are influenced by that sort of thing, especially when money is part of the equation.

  • Author

WOW, so many replies, thank you to all, as there are so many I will try to reply to the most important points

 

 

Morning,

 

i'm thinking, what was the brief? Have you spent "time" with the owner, to get to know him/her?

 

I think you are onto something but something doesn't sit right with this, as a concept, it's decent but I'm concerned it's too much. Could there by a way to simplify this and make it "grab" your attention more. My eye focuses on the leafs on the first glance.

 

 

We have spent a lot of time with the owner of the business, he is an existing client who we just did little bits and pieces for, only now has he decided to go for a new website and rebrand. I agree the leafs seem to be distracting so will do something with them or change them with something else, (don't want ti looking like just any ordinary stamp)

 

 

Far too much going on in that logo.

 

The thumbnail in this thread tells you that - I can't even read the name of the company. And not sure what the leaves are supposed to represent. And having the words in the logo will mean duplication in the site header (where you will also have the name of the company).

 

Why does the site need a new logo? The one they have already looks fine to me.

 

A logo needs to be scaleable from a favicon all the way up to the one on the side of the van.

 

It is a very legitimate concern, the fact you cannot read the company name when it is that small but we have a solution, and that is, within the branding guidelines we will state that under a certain size, the text can also be placed next to the logo, although we are in the process of creating guidelines, I would have thought we will come to that sort of conclusion. The business needs a logo, what is there at the moment is a family crest, and since the owner wants to take it back to its roots I feel it important to go back to the fact they used to use a chandelier as their logo. Again with the favicon, we could just simplify what we have.

 

I believe someone else asked a question about the reason we need the leaves, well we are trying to use just a piece of the crest, which has leaves on it, I think the idea is sound, I have just not implemented it the right way.

 

Lastly someone mentioned about simplicity too, I agree that under most circumstances logos must be kept simple etc, but this is an exception I think, the vintage/regal/traditional feel that the owner is looking for, that very well suits his business requires a not so usual solution.

 

I'm no designer but I'd have thought that it would look more modern if the circle was done in block colour rather than with a stamp-effect fuzzy edge.

 

I actually quite like it and, aside from the leaves possibly being a bit distracting, don't think it's bad at all.

 

Thanks, I will try the block colour but I was trying to give a classic old familiar look to it, maybe I have no quite captured the essence just yet.

 

 

Could also be worthwhile sorting out the red rating which WOT has applied to the site.

 

https://www.mywot.com/en/scorecard/elitechandelier.com

 

Nice new logo or not having that pop up when landing on the site might mean many just move straight on elsewhere.

 

In regards to the logo it looks as if it has tipped over to one side TBH. I would rotate the outer ring clockwise so the lettering is in a more horizontal plane.

 

I would not worry about WOT, any issues will be fixed with the swap to a better website, I don't think there is a popup or my adblocker blocking it, either way, we certainly have no plans to include one and would advise against it. As for the comment about the logo, swinging it around like that give it the feeling of motion, to try to give the impression that the business is moving and not just stuck in one place, but thanks.

 

 

 

Good point, I think an alternative logo might be needed for mobile headers. Not that bothered about favicon though, they are what they are... it could just be a very simple chandelier.

 

Agreed, I am not bothered about the favicon too much either, but I think the mobile site could still use it, maybe something like this (although obviously, I have a lot of research to do so this is just one possible solution )

 

 

 

 

Attached is an image of what the WOT plug in pops up in my Firefox. It is entirely independent of the actual site and you have no control over it as it is a crowd sourced review and rating site. I'm fully aware that it is probably incorrect but to the general public they will tend to believe it and possibly move on elsewhere. The browser add-on has been downloaded by over 140,000,000 users mainly in the US and UK and is available for both Firefox and Chrome.

 

Also attached is a perhaps more traditional style of logo which might possibly appeal to the older generation like what I is.

post-33158-0-94582100-1470414939_thumb.jpg

post-33158-0-66374400-1470414971_thumb.jpg

  • Author

Attached is an image of what the WOT plug in pops up in my Firefox. It is entirely independent of the actual site and you have no control over it as it is a crowd sourced review and rating site. I'm fully aware that it is probably incorrect but to the general public they will tend to believe it and possibly move on elsewhere. The browser add-on has been downloaded by over 140,000,000 users mainly in the US and UK and is available for both Firefox and Chrome.

 

Also attached is a perhaps more traditional style of logo which might possibly appeal to the older generation like what I is.

 

Thanks for showing the screenshot, again, I think that will improve when we change the site.

 

Although your version of the logo looks ok, I don't think it would quite hit the mark to what we are after, one of the biggest things is to modernise the site whilst still keeping the charm of the long history and although your logo would probably be suitable in the market you suggest it is not the one the client is looking for, the research we have done actually points to it needing to keep the charm (like your logo does) but also give it a modern twist, I was leaning in the direction of more personal, homely feel, believe it or not, most his audience are not actually that old, 30's to 50's.

 

Of course I will keep working on it, maybe make a few and then ask again..

The problem will always be the amount of detail you put in the logo. The more details there is the less scaleable the logo. So you may need a range of logos, with and without the words and borders.

 

You can have a really modern looking logo with lots of old world charm. Loads of ideas here: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=chandelier+logo&biw=1350&bih=711&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&sqi=2&ved=0ahUKEwjGq5aUgavOAhVcOMAKHaCPBBMQ_AUIBigB

Edited by fisicx

When I think of a chandelier the first thing that comes to mind is symmetry around a perpendicular and that makes the asymmetry of the rotated text out of kilter.

  • Author

The problem will always be the amount of detail you put in the logo. The more details there is the less scaleable the logo. So you may need a range of logos, with and without the words and borders.

 

You can have a really modern looking logo with lots of old world charm. Loads of ideas here: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=chandelier+logo&biw=1350&bih=711&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&sqi=2&ved=0ahUKEwjGq5aUgavOAhVcOMAKHaCPBBMQ_AUIBigB

I realise that scaleablity is important but you can create multiple styles for different occasions, I think it is nessersary in this case to do that because it has to be complex.

 

I have seen all those logos, some of them are really great, but they all follow the same type of styling, the circular outside etc is something that may help this business be memorable.

 

When I think of a chandelier the first thing that comes to mind is symmetry around a perpendicular and that makes the asymmetry of the rotated text out of kilter.

Sometimes the first thing is a good starting point but never a good finishing point, although I never dismiss an idea before I tested it ;-)

Sometimes the first thing is a good starting point but never a good finishing point ;-)

 

If the finishing point is perpendicular to the starting point it'll always be good. :)

  • Author

If the finishing point is perpendicular to the starting point it'll always be good. :)

Lol, I don't remember that one being a design rule at uni

I think it is nessersary in this case to do that because it has to be complex.

Why does it have to be complex?

 

...the circular outside etc is something that may help this business be memorable.

I'm not sure this will be the case. They are a niche business, one of only a handful around the world. It's their reputation that makes them memorable not a logo. You are a designer so imagery is important to you, people who need their chandelier serviced and cleaned are less likely to look at or even recall the logo. There was some testing done on this a while back and most people couldn't describe the logo on a website after a single visit. This will be the case for Elite. People may remember the logo of a website they visit often but even then they rarely recall the details, for example, the order of the 4 colours on the ebay logo or the number of points on the star of the starbucks logo.

  • Author

Why does it have to be complex?

 

 

I'm not sure this will be the case. They are a niche business, one of only a handful around the world. It's their reputation that makes them memorable not a logo. You are a designer so imagery is important to you, people who need their chandelier serviced and cleaned are less likely to look at or even recall the logo. There was some testing done on this a while back and most people couldn't describe the logo on a website after a single visit. This will be the case for Elite. People may remember the logo of a website they visit often but even then they rarely recall the details, for example, the order of the 4 colours on the ebay logo or the number of points on the star of the starbucks logo.

Firstly, it needs to be complex because chandlliers are complex, to keep the the historic roots, that is how it is, you can simplify an image of a chandelier but then it will look too modern and will not give the regal, vintage modern feel we are looking for.

 

One of his biggest concerns is his competition, he expressly wants to stad out from them, he has vwry good reasons for doing so, so wr can't just create stuff that all the others have done (to be quite frank, I think that it would br stupid to use what others have done as it will not help him stand out - a big part of the brief).

 

I have to beg to differ, logos need to be be memorable, but not always for how they look, sometimes how they feel, getting an immediate idea on the experience a business wants to take you through.

I've just been reminded (by an advertising agency MD) that marketing needs repetition to stick. It's the name that people remember not the branding or logo, that comes later and only if the branding is prominent on the product. He suggests that the company focus more on the brand not the branding.

 

Most clients will only ever see the Elite logo once - when they visit the website. If they convert they will never visit the website again. They may see the branding a second time on the uniform but that's about it. The logo you have designed won't work well as an embroidered pattern on a polo shirt. So rather than a range of logos (which confuses clients) it needs to be one simple recognizable logo and the business name.

 

I like the logo idea you have come up with but it isn't practical: it's not scaleable or easily replicated on media such as fabrics.

 

And while the chandelier part may need to be complex it's adding all the chrome round the outside that makes it overly complex.

Edited by fisicx

  • Author

I've just been reminded (by an advertising agency MD) that marketing needs repetition to stick. It's the name that people remember not the branding or logo, that comes later and only if the branding is prominent on the product. He suggests that the company focus more on the brand not the branding.

 

Most clients will only ever see the Elite logo once - when they visit the website. If they convert they will never visit the website again. They may see the branding a second time on the uniform but that's about it. The logo you have designed won't work well as an embroidered pattern on a polo shirt. So rather than a range of logos (which confuses clients) it needs to be one simple recognizable logo and the business name.

 

I like the logo idea you have come up with but it isn't practical: it's not scaleable or easily replicated on media such as fabrics.

That is where you are wrong I am sorry to say, marketing companies know a lot about content and promotion but they know sod all about design

Maybe, but they know what works and what doesn't. Elite is looking for a makeover - is it because they want more business or just because the want a change? If it's the former then the logo is the least important part of mix.

 

We obviously aren't going to agree on this logo and that's fine. But whatever you do end up with needs to be something that scales from 64px high all the way up to the side of a van and works on all media including uniforms. Apologies if this an egg sucking post.

 

PS: most of my last post was the result of years of testing and experience, nothing to do with the advertisers comment.

Edited by fisicx

Lol, I don't remember that one being a design rule at uni

 

There are no rules in design except the golden rule, It needs to fulfil its function.

 

To me the rotation around the vertical chandelier just looks odd. If the view of the chandelier was from directly below forming a more circular feature then it might work.

 

Perhaps if the ELITE was at the top in a horizontal plane with the chandelier descending from the base of the T and the other text as it is it might work for me as well.

  • Author

Maybe, but they know what works and what doesn't. Elite is looking for a makeover - is it because they want more business or just because the want a change? If it's the former then the logo is the least important part of mix.

 

We obviously aren't going to agree on this logo and that's fine. But whatever you do end up with needs to be something that scales from 64px high all the way up to the side of a van and works on all media including uniforms. Apologies if this an egg sucking post.

 

PS: most of my last post was the result of years of testing and experience, nothing to do with the advertisers comment.

 

Yes they do know what works and what doesn't, except when it comes to design.

OK, what rules govern design?

 

I don't mean statutory legal requirements for the purposes of safety here. You need twenty years of research and an act of parliament to change those. The only short cut is a horrific accident claiming the lives of lots of middle class white people. :)

 

There are also rules for manufacturing purposes. If it's too expensive to make you'll likely never sell it.

 

If we mean the rules of design for aesthetics please explain them because one person's aesthetic is another person's dog's dinner.

  • Author

OK, what rules govern design?

 

I don't mean statutory legal requirements for the purposes of safety here. You need twenty years of research and an act of parliament to change those. The only short cut is a horrific accident claiming the lives of lots of middle class white people. :)

 

There are also rules for manufacturing purposes. If it's too expensive to make you'll likely never sell it.

 

If we mean the rules of design for aesthetics please explain them because one person's aesthetic is another person's dog's dinner.

Wow, ok, here is a quick rundown, in no way even a partial description or list

 

There are two sides of graphic design, design being a form of communication being one, for example we use colour and form to convey a message, idea or emotion to our intended audience. the theory, based on how someone thinks, their culture, the persona etc, this way we can target individual types of person within those messages.

 

The second set of tools are the acutal 'manipulative' rules, these rules use visual pleasure in order to entice a user to perform an action or have an emotional responce, these rules are thibgs like 'the golden ratio' 'the rule of thirds' and 'colour theory'. These 'rules' can be bent or broken depending on the work being created and the circumstances of the creation, of course though, if you step outside the box, you have to be sure of what you are doing because you can very easily ruin the message or destroy the work.

 

As you have probebly read above, there are even more rules which involve seperate things like logo's, for example, the need to have a logo that can be any size and still be recognisable, but again, in the right circumstances, this can be bent or broken too, for example if your client will only ever use the logo on the side of a van (not the usual case of course) then that can be considered in the design, so knowing where it will be placed is also important.

 

Too many things to list really because there are even more things you could say about physical products vs digital.

 

Lastly you talk about manufacturing, this is industrial design and as I found out at uni through my study for my dissertation, industrial design is a slightly different monster as it is a physical product and cost, sale etc are the most important things, but you still have ux designers within that industry testing products before they are sold.. The biggest problem with design is that there are too many job titles that use the word 'design' but they all have their own rules, graphic design is no different that it has its own rules.

Yes they do know what works and what doesn't, except when it comes to design.

Some of them maybe but many people who work in marketing have a background in design. There are many companies that combine marketing and design - one could even argue that this is what you are doing, re-branding a company is a marketing activity.

 

One more thought on the non-importance of a logo. I was at Heathrow dropping off my son and his girlfriend. There is a huge poster promoting the Hilton hotel chain. They have the encircled H as a logo but it was the name of the company I related to not the logo. In fact I've just had to Google the logo to remind me of what it looked like. It's not that it's not memorable, it's just that I didn't remember the details. Most people won't (it's called gist memory) as the brain doesn't bother with details, it builds composite images from recalled components. Which is why when sketching the apple logo from memory many people add a stem because apples with leaves have stems. The more complex the logo the fewer components will be recalled.

Edited by fisicx

  • Author

Some of them maybe but many people who work in marketing have a background in design. There are many companies that combine marketing and design - one could even argue that this is what you are doing, re-branding a company is a marketing activity.

 

One more thought on the non-importance of a logo. I was at Heathrow dropping off my son and his girlfriend. There is a huge poster promoting the Hilton hotel chain. They have the encircled H as a logo but it was the name of the company I related to not the logo. In fact I've just had to Google the logo to remind me of what it looked like. It's not that it's not memorable, it's just that I didn't remember the details. Most people won't (it's called gist memory) as the brain doesn't bother with details, it builds composite images from recalled components. Which is why when sketching the apple logo from memory many people add a stem because apples with leaves have stems. The more complex the logo the fewer components will be recalled.

Tell me, what is Nike's logo? What is mc Donnalds logo? Apple? Twitter? You remember those logos don't you?

 

Businesses can set themselves apart from the competition with a logo. A logo can be especially effective for a company with a common name or a name that can be confused with another company. Investing resources in a professional logo design shows customers that you care about the image you are projecting. It can help set you apart in a crowded field of competing businesses with no logos or unmemorable logos. The design process for your company's logo should take into account the logos of your competition to avoid similarities.

 

A logo provides cohesiveness across a variety of advertising mediums. Place your logo on all advertising, marketing materials, email communications, websites, business cards, letterhead, brochures, uniforms and signs. This helps to build up the correlation between your company and your logo in the minds of customers. For example, a logo incorporating a hammer and saw on the side of a van for a construction business shows anyone who sees it exactly what your business is about.

 

A company's logo is one of the first things that a customer notices about a business, whether they are receiving a marketing mailing, visiting a website or approaching a physical store. A professional logo encourages a customer to do business with a new company. A logo can also make a good impression on potential partners, other businesses and colleagues that you are networking with. For small businesses, a good logo makes you look bigger than you actually are. When you are competing with larger companies, you need to look just as professional as they do.

 

Source: http://smallbusiness.chron.com/logo-can-make-remember-company-3231.html

 

Gestalt theory

look up the Gestalt theories of German psychologists from the 1920s. They say that the human brain unifies the visual elements it sees to form a whole that carries significantly more meaning. People form patterns out of similarly shaped objects, while objects that differ from the group become a focal point of the image.

 

Another Gestalt principle, closure, is often used in logo design; this is when an object is incomplete but there is enough detail for the human eye to make the whole picture. A good example of this is the panda logo used by the WWF. (In design this is known as figure/ground)

 

The logo shapes you incorporate into your designs become an intrinsic element in the message they will convey to the company's customers and the wider public. Once you understand the psychology behind logo shapes you will be able to use this knowledge to create powerful brands for your clients.

 

Source: http://www.creativebloq.com/logo-design/psychology-logo-shapes-8133918

 

There is much more to design than you know ( like a crossover with psychology ) marketing companies do not understand design ( although you are right there is a crossover, but when it comes to design, it crosses over many different types of business, more than any other title I think), they may employ people they call 'designers' but what most really are, are people who know how to use design software, like photoshop so they can mindlessly create something the marketing company says to create how they say to create it, like a puppet on a string, I have said it time and again, been ripped by this very forum many times but just because you know how to open up photoshop and create something pretty, that does not make you a designer, design is about the message, not how pretty it is (although obviously for something to appeal and work it still has to look good)

 

If logos were that unimportant, why do businesses continue to spend thousands, even millions sometimes to have them created and if they are so useless why are they still around? when cd's come out, videos disappeared, is this not a sign that they are doing something important?

Thanks for that a good, quick précis.

 

I fully understand the significance of colour, shapes and form to convey messages. As I come from the mechanical/construction engineering industry they all play a very important part in ensuring safety and efficiency. All those pipes you see in a factory aren't painted different colours out of any sense of interior décor they are those colours as they indicate the contents of the pipe. In this case the colours need to comply with BS1710 and BS4800 in the UK and with ISO14726 in other countries. You have little to no choice in the matter they're going to be those colours or you'll be facing the consequences.

 

The significance of colour is something I think that has been lost in Western culture but still plays great significance to many from other parts of the world. There is a very good starter article here for anyone interested in the subject.

 

http://www.designyourway.net/drb/colors-in-web-design-and-why-to-choose-them/

 

In the UK we only retain the association of black with death and mourning. Of a point of side interest, metal gates and railings in the UK were traditionally painted red or green with some grander houses using gilding as well. The 'traditional' black came about on the death of Prince Albert in 1861 when a period of national mourning was declared.

 

In the past colours, flowers and precious stones and metals all had a significance and carried specific meanings. Gold doesn't corrode or tarnish in normal usage so it is associated with being incorruptible, everlasting and eternal for instance.

 

The various 'golden ratios' and the rule of thirds work well because they are in tune with the way human eyes work and transmit the received data back to the brain.

 

Perhaps there should be a section or a thread here purely for design and how people view it. As such it is very much something that is subjective and depends on the cultural background and personal taste of the person viewing it. Which is why I find it peculiar to try to apply any hard and fast rules to design.

  • Author

Thanks for that a good, quick précis.

 

I fully understand the significance of colour, shapes and form to convey messages. As I come from the mechanical/construction engineering industry they all play a very important part in ensuring safety and efficiency. All those pipes you see in a factory aren't painted different colours out of any sense of interior décor they are those colours as they indicate the contents of the pipe. In this case the colours need to comply with BS1710 and BS4800 in the UK and with ISO14726 in other countries. You have little to no choice in the matter they're going to be those colours or you'll be facing the consequences.

 

The significance of colour is something I think that has been lost in Western culture but still plays great significance to many from other parts of the world. There is a very good starter article here for anyone interested in the subject.

 

http://www.designyourway.net/drb/colors-in-web-design-and-why-to-choose-them/

 

In the UK we only retain the association of black with death and mourning. Of a point of side interest, metal gates and railings in the UK were traditionally painted red or green with some grander houses using gilding as well. The 'traditional' black came about on the death of Prince Albert in 1861 when a period of national mourning was declared.

 

In the past colours, flowers and precious stones and metals all had a significance and carried specific meanings. Gold doesn't corrode or tarnish in normal usage so it is associated with being incorruptible, everlasting and eternal for instance.

 

The various 'golden ratios' and the rule of thirds work well because they are in tune with the way human eyes work and transmit the received data back to the brain.

 

Perhaps there should be a section or a thread here purely for design and how people view it. As such it is very much something that is subjective and depends on the cultural background and personal taste of the person viewing it. Which is why I find it peculiar to try to apply any hard and fast rules to design.

Ahh, now we are into something even designers debate, is design subjective or objective, I tried to answer this question once the answer I come up with was that it would depend on your training, A designer for example would look at it very objectively drawing from what he knows about design to determine whether something is good or bad, obviously anyone else has not had that type of training so is unaware of the 'rules' and would therefore be judging it on pure feeling, this is the reason for audience research.

Perhaps a better term would be 'guidelines' rather than 'rules'.

 

I associate a rule with something that is proscribed and unequivocal and must be adhered to with no flexibility allowed. Which is probably the result of spending forty years in an industry that is awash with rules that are proscribed and inflexible. However a guideline says to me, if you follow this and put it somewhere within the ballpark it should work OK, please most people and you shouldn't go far wrong.

  • Author

Perhaps a better term would be 'guidelines' rather than 'rules'.

 

I associate a rule with something that is proscribed and unequivocal and must be adhered to with no flexibility allowed. Which is probably the result of spending forty years in an industry that is awash with rules that are proscribed and inflexible. However a guideline says to me, if you follow this and put it somewhere within the ballpark it should work OK, please most people and you shouldn't go far wrong.

Obviously in order to be fully creative you can't be restricted to rigid rules, I am just parroting how I was taught, and they were called 'rules', although guidelines would probably be a better fit.

Tell me, what is Nike's logo? What is mc Donnalds logo? Apple? Twitter? You remember those logos don't you?

Indeed, but I remember the general shape not the detail. I know for example that twitter is a bird but I can't recall if it faces left or right, the angle of wings, it it has a tail and so on. And all of these logos are simple. They may have a lot of design in them but the result is simple.

 

The Gestalt theory is connected to gist memory and deja vu. The brain only bothers to remember a few of the things it sees. If it receives a pattern that is similar to something already stored away it will often use the existing pattern. If there is a complex images it builds a new pattern using existing shapes. This is why when you see something new you think you have seen it before - deja vu.

 

And the sources you cite are all about marketing. Design and marketing are interwoven and often indistinguishable form one another. For you to suggest marketing professional know nothing about design in wrong.

 

I don't think I have said logos are worthless, they have their place and can provide a visual indicator amongst all the other marketing signals, but this thread was about Elite and your design for their logo. They aren't Twitter, B&Q or any other major brand. They are a specialist company providing a very niche product. Changing their logo won't the slightest difference to their business. not one iota. What will make a difference is a new website and better marketing.

  • Author

Indeed, but I remember the general shape not the detail. I know for example that twitter is a bird but I can't recall if it faces left or right, the angle of wings, it it has a tail and so on. And all of these logos are simple. They may have a lot of design in them but the result is simple.

 

This is the reason logos should be kept simple, but design is not a rigid process.

 

The Gestalt theory is connected to gist memory and deja vu. The brain only bothers to remember a few of the things it sees. If it receives a pattern that is similar to something already stored away it will often use the existing pattern. If there is a complex images it builds a new pattern using existing shapes. This is why when you see something new you think you have seen it before - deja vu.

 

Precisely, so what does this mean for a logo? Familiarity with a brand due to recognition and connection, thereby instigating instant trust if the logo is right.

 

And the sources you cite are all about marketing. Design and marketing are interwoven and often indistinguishable form one another. For you to suggest marketing professional know nothing about design in wrong.

 

The sources I cite are one is about design, the other marketing, it does show a crossover, I have explicitly said there is a crossover but that still does not mean that most marketing companies know anything about design.

 

I don't think I have said logos are worthless, they have their place and can provide a visual indicator amongst all the other marketing signals, but this thread was about Elite and your design for their logo. They aren't Twitter, B&Q or any other major brand. They are a specialist company providing a very niche product. Changing their logo won't the slightest difference to their business. not one iota. What will make a difference is a new website and better marketing.

 

 

One more thought on the non-importance of a logo

 

I know Elite are not a huge corporation but you don't seriously think these businesses started out as huge corporations do you? You don't think they spent years building a brand and business with no logo? I am not changing their logo at all, the thing you think is a logo is actually a family crest, not a logo, what I am doing is bringing back their old logo and refreshing it to modern standards.

 

You seem to hold graphic design in some kind of contempt, I have seen this many times before, usually by those who have either worked in marketing or those who have studied/look up marketing and because of some of their misinformation neglected to actually look at graphic design specifically . I have explained everything quite clearly above.

 

The first form of 'written' communication was imagery, hieroglyphics on cave walls, we used them for everything we needed from JUST these images, words did not exist in the very beginning, yet they managed to convey feeling, thought, stories and learning through pictures, if they did that then, imagine what a simple image does for your business.

 

Mc Donald's first building, as an example of the reason and meaning behind logos and how branding evolves. and apples first logo drastically changed since, but the meaning is still the same although in apples case, the bite (contrary to myths Adam and Eve significance ) was only put there to make it look more like an apple and not a cherry.

Obviously in order to be fully creative you can't be restricted to rigid rules, I am just parroting how I was taught, and they were called 'rules', although guidelines would probably be a better fit.

 

 

Perhaps it was how the course was designed. :)

 

OK got you now, I took rules to mean rules in a literal sense. So it's more 'rule of thumb' than 'rule of statute'.

 

The Nike 'tick' logo is a very good one IMO. It's simple, easy to remember and identify, scaleable, can be translated into any colour on any ground all of which probably make it so appealing to younger people and teenagers in particular with their very short attention spans. If someone mentions Nike the tick is the first thing I think of. In truth I can't remember if the lettering is serif or sans-serif, normal case, all caps or small caps. None of which matters because the simple tick shape gets the job done.

  • Author

Perhaps it was how the course was designed. :)

 

OK got you now, I took rules to mean rules in a literal sense. So it's more 'rule of thumb' than 'rule of statute'.

 

The Nike 'tick' logo is a very good one IMO. It's simple, easy to remember and identify, scaleable, can be translated into any colour on any ground all of which probably make it so appealing to younger people and teenagers in particular with their very short attention spans. If someone mentions Nike the tick is the first thing I think of. In truth I can't remember if the lettering is serif or sans-serif, normal case, all caps or small caps. None of which matters because the simple tick shape gets the job done.

 

I think you got it ;-)

This is the reason logos should be kept simple, but design is not a rigid process.

So why are you making the elite logo so complicated?

 

You seem to hold graphic design in some kind of contempt, I have seen this many times before, usually by those who have either worked in marketing or those who have studied/look up marketing and because of some of their misinformation neglected to actually look at graphic design specifically .

Certainly not, it's a skill I will never have and I enjoy seeing excellent design (such as the latest PayPal homepage).

 

But I also think that graphic designers can forget that a company needs to ship product in order to survive. They can create beautiful and complex websites but in doing so lose sight of the bit that converts.

 

A really well build site will convert. Adding a bit of design to the site can make it convert even more. Add too much design and conversions can go down. Which is why the KISS principle works in nearly all cases.

  • Author

So why are you making the elite logo so complicated?

 

Certainly not, it's a skill I will never have and I enjoy seeing excellent design (such as the latest PayPal homepage).

 

But I also think that graphic designers can forget that a company needs to ship product in order to survive. They can create beautiful and complex websites but in doing so lose sight of the bit that converts.

 

A really well build site will convert. Adding a bit of design to the site can make it convert even more. Add too much design and conversions can go down. Which is why the KISS principle works in nearly all cases.

 

I told you before that design can be flexible, the rules are not rigid, this enables creative freedom when times call for it

 

You seem to contradict yourself, you say that you respect graphic design, yet you say it does nothing to get a conversion first then immediately after backtrack to say it depends if the design is simple.

 

Well actually when it comes to design, simplicity is a very good thing but so is the psychology of design, to persuade someone to click a link or follow a path to eventual conversion, that is the trick, to understand how someone thinks when they get on the site, to know the audience, that gets conversions too and keeps them coming back because they remember you, people do not remember an image, they remember a feeling, they remember how they felt when they purchased your product, how they were treated, was it an easy process, even the feeling they got from the website, whether spacious or crowded, vintage or modern, that is what they mostly remember and that is why branding is so important because it adds to the experience as the brand is part of the experience. But again, not a rigid process so sometimes things can be bent to adjust the experience to something more suitable

Apologies if I appear contradictory. Graphic design and design aren't the same thing (one is a subset of the other) and my posts probably got a mixed up.

 

Good design is part of building an effective website. That design may requires some graphical components. I'm rubbish at anything graphical which is why I'm in awe of those who have the skill to create great imagery. But a plumber promoting a local service may not need any graphical elements - for him a logo is probably unimportant. If you are a global brand then a logo may be important. But even then is the general structure of the logo that matters as most of the detail will get missed. For example, how many feathers does the twitter bird have? Is the beak curved or straight?

 

But i do agree with almost everything you have posted. It just doesn't necessarily apply in every case. As you say, they are guidelines not rules. If we followed the rules we wouldn't have red and green together at Christmas.

I quite like it. It has a feel of a seal or stamp.

 

My question is what is it like when it is small, which might be the case on the website. I presume you would have to change the site and make the header quite large for the logo to be big enough to read.

 

Also I'm not so sure the green works as that shade suggests environment or recycle. The grey does though!

Edited by neil0wen

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.