Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Client logo feedback

Featured Replies

  • Author

Apologies if I appear contradictory. Graphic design and design aren't the same thing (one is a subset of the other) and my posts probably got a mixed up.

 

Good design is part of building an effective website. That design may requires some graphical components. I'm rubbish at anything graphical which is why I'm in awe of those who have the skill to create great imagery. But a plumber promoting a local service may not need any graphical elements - for him a logo is probably unimportant. If you are a global brand then a logo may be important. But even then is the general structure of the logo that matters as most of the detail will get missed. For example, how many feathers does the twitter bird have? Is the beak curved or straight?

 

But i do agree with almost everything you have posted. It just doesn't necessarily apply in every case. As you say, they are guidelines not rules. If we followed the rules we wouldn't have red and green together at Christmas.

All businesses, from the smallest to the largest need a logo, here is a good article on branding but touches on logo too, it also touches on small business and logo/branding https://www.fatrabbitcreative.com/blog/why-you-need-a-brand-not-just-a-logo

 

santas outfit and that saying, it is completely wrong, look at the colour wheel, they are acually complimentary colours in the way they actually work together, I am sure this phrase is referring to specifically fashon and not colour although obviously musused as the latter

  • Author

I quite like it. It has a feel of a seal or stamp.

 

My question is what is it like when it is small, which might be the case on the website. I presume you would have to change the site and make the header quite large for the logo to be big enough to read.

 

Also I'm not so sure the green works as that shade suggests environment or recycle. The grey does though!

Cheers, as already discussed above, you are right about the size issue, but again, it is discussed above so I wont repeat, the 'green' is not showing very well, it is actually a gold colour, I have adjusted it to look better since posting this

 

As for the stamp idea, I had the same thorght, in fact we are discussing whether to use it for this anyway and keep on trying new logo designs

 

Thanks

All businesses, from the smallest to the largest need a logo

The local butcher has his name above the door. It's tells me who they are and what they do. They don't need a logo: http://markturnerbutchers.co.uk/home/p1010519-800x600/.

 

A business may benefit from a logo but that's not the same as saying they need a logo.

  • Author

The local butcher has his name above the door. It's tells me who they are and what they do. They don't need a logo: http://markturnerbutchers.co.uk/home/p1010519-800x600/.

 

A business may benefit from a logo but that's not the same as saying they need a logo.

 

But when they walk away, why would they choose that butcher over another? What is different? not usually price, sometimes convenience but most the time because there is something you can't quite put your finger on that makes you prefer that one over another, that is the branding

  • Author

Made another set of logos, I think the other one is more suited as a stamp so we have discussed this with the client and that is what we will do with it

 

Don't blame me for the colours, the client is being "insistant"

 

 

But when they walk away, why would they choose that butcher over another? What is different? not usually price, sometimes convenience but most the time because there is something you can't quite put your finger on that makes you prefer that one over another, that is the branding

I disagree. People go to McDonalds because of marketing and hype not because the burger is better than the competition. They don't go their because of the Golden Arches or to KFC because of the Colonel.

 

People buy their meat from Mark because of the quality of the product and the service his team provides. Adding a logo above the door wouldn't make any difference to this. It's their brand not branding that matters.

 

I like the colours of the new logo but the details are still way too small to see clearly. I zoomed out to see how it would look in a website header and it's just a blur. I couldn't even read the words 'Chandelier Services' let alone the dates underneath. But they are much much better the the circular leaf one.

Edited by fisicx

  • Author

I disagree. People go to McDonalds because of marketing and hype not because the burger is better than the competition. They don't go their because of the Golden Arches or to KFC because of the Colonel.

 

People buy their meat from Mark because of the quality of the product and the service his team provides. Adding a logo above the door wouldn't make any difference to this. It's their brand not branding that matters.

 

I like the colours of the new logo but the details are still way too small to see clearly. I zoomed out to see how it would look in a website header and it's just a blur. I couldn't even read the words 'Chandelier Services' let alone the dates underneath. But they are much much better the the circular leaf one.

Your assessment of branding is wrong, there was a point these compnies started with nothing and still had a logo, I won't post any more after this to explain but here is another page, you are obviously having trouble accepting or understanding the facts https://www.qualitylogoproducts.com/blog/25-posts-on-why-a-good-logo-is-essential/

Its a shame because I really like the stamp, and I can also imagine it on one of those signs that hangs outside of a shop. But I can understand the logic of needing something where the name is larger and clearer to read.

 

Out of the new stuff I like the very first logo (but in white), however I think I would use the same font on the stamp to be consistent.

 

There are no rules in design except the golden rule, It needs to fulfil its function.

 

 

"Form follows function" was the mantra of modern design schools (Constructivism, Bauhaus etc:)

But to achieve this you need to learn and understand the design elements as well as the design principles.

 

Even the Avantgarde and Postmodern design movements, which rejected the stirict rules of the modern schools, had to consider the rules in order to redefine them.

 

IMO the main function of graphic design is to capture the viewers attention and make the message/content easy to read and interpret.

 

This is done by using the general principles:

  • Hierarchy,
  • Rhythm,
  • Balance,
  • Connection (grouping / separation of content),
  • Contrast,
  • Movement (leading the viewers eye towards important content)

 

The tools for the design principles are the elements:

  • Shapes,
  • Lines,
  • Colours,
  • Value,
  • Proportion,
  • Texture
  • Space (negative and positive)

 

Sometimes you can achive the same principle with different tools: eg. contrast can be created by using different proportions or different colours or value.

 

Design is not art, instinct or intuition. It is a craft, and like other crafts you need to understand the principles and learn to use the tools to create quality solutions.

Edited by Nillervision

  • Author

"Form follows function" was the mantra of modern design schools (Constructivism, Bauhaus etc:)

But to achieve this you need to learn and understand the design elements as well as the design principles.

 

Even the Avantgarde and Postmodern design movements, which rejected the stirict rules of the modern schools, had to consider the rules in order to redefine them.

 

IMO the main function of graphic design is to capture the viewers attention and make the message/content easy to read and interpret.

 

This is done by using the general principles:

 

  • Hierarchy,
  • Rhythm,
  • Balance,
  • Connection (grouping / separation of content),
  • Contrast,
  • Movement (leading the viewers eye towards important content)

The tools for the design principles are the elements:

  • Shapes,
  • Lines,
  • Colours,
  • Value,
  • Proportion,
  • Texture
  • Space (negative and positive)

Sometimes you can achive the same principle with different tools: eg. contrast can be created by using different proportions or different colours or value.

 

Design is not art, instinct or intuition. It is a craft, and like other crafts you need to understand the principles and learn to use the tools to create quality solutions.

Once again, far better explained than myself.

The local butcher has his name above the door. It's tells me who they are and what they do. They don't need a logo: http://markturnerbutchers.co.uk/home/p1010519-800x600/.

 

A business may benefit from a logo but that's not the same as saying they need a logo.

If you want to make money you need to sell an experience and not just a commodity or service. Thats why Starbucks can charge 20 times what their raw product actually costs.

It is a well known fact that people subconsciously stores sensory inputs along with the memory of an experience. And the visual sense is by far the strongest. That is why a visual identity for a brand matters,

This is not just my opinion. It is the conclusions of Joseph Pine and James Gilmore who first defined the concept: The Experience Economy back in the 90's

For me branding elements such as a logo are very important and can make a huge difference. If you have a company with a amateurish logo most people would have very little trust in that companies ability and quality. Whereas if you see a company that has taken the time and care over something which is the main symbol of their company then I personally would feel a lot happier using them.

If you want to make money you need to sell an experience and not just a commodity or service.

And that's exactly what this butcher does. If you go into his shop it looks stunning - the black and chrome is his branding - it is a fantastic visual experience coupled with his products and service. Having a logo won't change anything.

 

Logos are subliminal, we recall general shapes and structures but we don't absorb the detail (as in most things we see). This is why simpler logos are more easily remembered. Can you for example describe in the starbucks logo? I know it's a mermaid and it's green but that about it. If I looked at it I would see more detail but the brain won't bother to save the detail - it doesn't need to as it has enough in long term memory to know when it sees the logo to associate that pattern with the business name and the brand.

 

Consider also that many people still think of McDonalds as being yellow and red. But their outlets are greens and browns: http://i.imgur.com/tJ3MT6q.jpg. It's this memory thing we have, the stronger the memory the harder it is to replace it with a new pattern. This is especially true with colours (which require a lot of processing and will get dumped if the brain already has a previous pattern it can use).

  • Author

The branding is coming along, through I would show it, or what we are looking at right now, hopefully the client would be happy with it

 

 

  • Guest locked this topic
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.