September 13, 201214 yr Author Would've just come to me anyway Having real bad eye site (One eye and even that needs glasses) i can tell you that the minute a site has poor contrast i'm outta there. Black text on white is just as bad to be honest. Obviously i can't see the site we're talking about but it does seem the general feel is to darken the text a bit. Well in that case Mike, I think you're in trouble...prepare to see a blank page
September 13, 201214 yr No, it doesn't. It tells me that you 'say' that is it difficult to read. Not that it 'is' difficult to read. What? Why would anyone here 'say' it was difficult to read if it was not, in fact, difficult to read? I'm starting to wonder if this is a wind up or something.
September 13, 201214 yr Author What? Why would anyone here 'say' it was difficult to read if it was not, in fact, difficult to read? I'm starting to wonder if this is a wind up or something. Think about it - just because someone says something IS a fact, does it really make it a fact. With development yes. But the current topic is obviously debatable, and I'm debating it.
September 13, 201214 yr Sorry I didn't get back to you earlier on this, I didn't get an email through. I think, yeah if it was for everyone then it would be styled differently, but all the people using the site, or most of them, will be going on to work for banks, so it's focussed on capturing their attention really. Just looking at your site and the CTA you mention above, is it the 'create free websites click here' circles that go to Wix? Edit: and when you say the CTA is intimidating, do you mean the 'Practice Tests' button on the home page? No worries, I cant believe I have not responded sooner, just noticed this thread now. No, thats a google adsense banner...I would never knowingly encourage wix websites! haha. No, my CTA is "wanna see something sexy? [yes i do!]"<-- button. Surely you can tell the difference between a CTA and a Banner...after all you do use a CTA yourself. When I said the CTA is intimidating, i meant from a general user point of view. Generally speaking nobody likes to click something that feels they must commit. This is why many sites use things like "browse" over "buy" because it does not make the user feel obliged, yet easily leads them to the next 'step'. Think about it - just because someone says something IS a fact, does it really make it a fact. With development yes. But the current topic is obviously debatable, and I'm debating it. You're the only one tbh. Edited September 13, 201214 yr by jamesosix
September 13, 201214 yr Author No worries, I cant believe I have not responded sooner, just noticed this thread now. No, thats a google adsense banner...I would never knowingly encourage wix websites! haha. No, my CTA is "wanna see something sexy? [yes i do!]"<-- button. Surely you can tell the difference between a CTA and a Banner...after all you do use a CTA yourself. When I said the CTA is intimidating, i meant from a general user point of view. Generally speaking nobody likes to click something that feels they must commit. This is why many sites use things like "browse" over "buy" because it does not make the user feel obliged, yet easily leads them to the next 'step'. You're the only one tbh. Ar no worries man. Well to be fair I only use 'Buy' when they are about to buy something, and the only reason users come to the site is to practice tests, so I couldn't think of any better CTA really than 'Practice Tests'.
September 13, 201214 yr Yeah, thats why I said for general users (opposed to your target market). Good luck anyway
September 13, 201214 yr Think about it - just because someone says something IS a fact, does it really make it a fact. With development yes. But the current topic is obviously debatable, and I'm debating it. That is a good approach to have but you must be able to justify your decision over any established practices. Otherwise you're working on a very dodgy basis. If I created a site with 4pt text, you would say it was bad design, I could say otherwise but I wouldn't have any justification for it so you'd most likely be correct.
September 13, 201214 yr Author That is a good approach to have but you must be able to justify your decision over any established practices. Otherwise you're working on a very dodgy basis. If I created a site with 4pt text, you would say it was bad design, I could say otherwise but I wouldn't have any justification for it so you'd most likely be correct. This is exactly my point - but the burden of proof lies with the accuser (I'm not the accuser here in case you are wondering). I honestly cannot find anyone who cannot easily read everything. Apart from the people on this post who 'know' it's not good practice. With your point about the 4pt text - that's a bit of an extreme example but until you have tested it how will you know? Split testing is fascinating, what you think will work actually doesn't.
September 13, 201214 yr This is exactly my point - but the burden of proof lies with the accuser (I'm not the accuser here in case you are wondering). I honestly cannot find anyone who cannot easily read everything. Apart from the people on this post who 'know' it's not good practice. With your point about the 4pt text - that's a bit of an extreme example but until you have tested it how will you know? Split testing is fascinating, what you think will work actually doesn't. The accepted theory is that text with low contrast is bad practice and hard to read, this is supported by the likes of Jeffrey Zeldman and Jeremy Keith. You are the accuser, you are going against the accepted theory, that is true regardless of the people you know who can read it. I can read it, that isn't the point. If a scientist comes along and says, "gravity doesn't exist" you'd say ok, provide justification for your theory and why we should accept it over the current one. My point about the 4pt text was extreme intentionally to highlight my overall point. If I was to do that, the above would apply to me, I would or should have to justify why I would make such a decision.
September 13, 201214 yr Author The accepted theory is that text with low contrast is bad practice and hard to read, this is supported by the likes of Jeffrey Zeldman and Jeremy Keith. You are the accuser, you are going against the accepted theory, that is true regardless of the people you know who can read it. I can read it, that isn't the point. If a scientist comes along and says, "gravity doesn't exist" you'd say ok, provide justification for your theory and why we should accept it over the current one. My point about the 4pt text was extreme intentionally to highlight my overall point. If I was to do that, the above would apply to me, I would or should have to justify why I would make such a decision. You're not quite right actually - as I have proven that people can read it. It doesn't matter who has said what. Just because the pope says there is an afterlife it doesn't mean there is one - show me some evidence that people can't read the text, and I'll change the font colour.
September 13, 201214 yr You're not quite right actually - as I have proven that people can read it. It doesn't matter who has said what. Just because the pope says there is an afterlife it doesn't mean there is one - show me some evidence that people can't read the text, and I'll change the font colour. You're not grasping the point. I've explained my opinion, I won't try to persuade you any further, it's up to you at the end of day. Just think about this, I could prove people can read 4pt text if I asked the right people, does that mean I should use 4pt text from now on?
September 13, 201214 yr Finally got to see the site and... I don't see the issue! I've tried it on my work machine and on an iPad and I have no problems reading it. If it was me I'd make it a tiny tiny little bit darker but the way everyone was talking I wasn't expecting to able to read any thing!
September 13, 201214 yr Author Finally got to see the site and... I don't see the issue! I've tried it on my work machine and on an iPad and I have no problems reading it. If it was me I'd make it a tiny tiny little bit darker but the way everyone was talking I wasn't expecting to able to read any thing! Brilliant
September 14, 201214 yr Finally got to see the site and... I don't see the issue! I've tried it on my work machine and on an iPad and I have no problems reading it. If it was me I'd make it a tiny tiny little bit darker but the way everyone was talking I wasn't expecting to able to read any thing! I don't think anyone said it was impossible to read or anything that extreme....but #8 88 (god damn emoticons!) for body copy just isn't generally advisable. On some devices, it will be more of an issue than on others. On the crappy screen I have at work it's quite light, on the good screen it's a bit darker so less of a problem. Dropping it to something like #444 is not going to ruin the site but it will improve accessibility. To me that's a win win, a no-brainer. As somebody else pointed out, worth thinking about mobiles too. In outdoor conditions the screens are hard enough to see as it is. Aside from the contrast issue, I think the other points raised regarding the navigation and usability of the site were fair enough. At the end of the day, if you post for feedback, people will offer their criticisms. If you don't take them on board that's fine but the way I've always looked at it is if a lot of people all say something similar about my design than it's probably because they're right. Edited September 14, 201214 yr by brightonmike
September 14, 201214 yr Author I don't think anyone said it was impossible to read or anything that extreme....but #8 88 (god damn emoticons!) for body copy just isn't generally advisable. On some devices, it will be more of an issue than on others. On the crappy screen I have at work it's quite light, on the good screen it's a bit darker so less of a problem. Dropping it to something like #444 is not going to ruin the site but it will improve accessibility. To me that's a win win, a no-brainer. As somebody else pointed out, worth thinking about mobiles too. In outdoor conditions the screens are hard enough to see as it is. Aside from the contrast issue, I think the other points raised regarding the navigation and usability of the site were fair enough. At the end of the day, if you post for feedback, people will offer their criticisms. If you don't take them on board that's fine but the way I've always looked at it is if a lot of people all say something similar about my design than it's probably because they're right. *probably I'm not going against the grain for the sake of it, I really can't find a situation where it's a problem in the real world, other than what I've read 'they' say you shouldn't do. On a mobile in the sun is fine for me, my eyes aren't 100%. The site is not responsive, so this is the only issue when it comes to mobile users. The next site I do though will take into account the contrast more though and it will be fully responsive. Edited September 14, 201214 yr by WDF
September 14, 201214 yr Why did you even bother asking for help if you don't want to change it anyway? I presume you posted this so that people would go 'Oh wow your site is great I love it keep it exactly as it is!' I find it hard to read, yes I can read it, but I have to squint and it hurts my eyes. (On my iMac and on my home computer Dell monitors it's even worse.) It makes me not want to look at the site. I have to highlight the text to make it easier to read and more comfortable. A change to # doesn't distract from the design at all and makes it less difficult for any of those who might suffer, without spoiling the site look for those who can read best. It's a great compromise. Also, if the site is 'finally finished!' why did you post it up for feedback? Surely it's sensible to ask for feedback BEFORE the site goes live so that changes are made and ready for the golive. Seems illogical to me. Edited September 14, 201214 yr by Fran Haselden
September 14, 201214 yr Now I've had a chance to look at it: Some of your text is #888888 on white (contrast 3.54:1), some is #7D7D7D on white (contrast 4.12:1). You'd only have to amend those to #767676 to pass WCAG contrast guidelines of 4.5:1, and it's not a big enough change to compromise your visual design. Edit: Just spotted that the footer's even worse, at #A6A6A6, or 2.43:1. All these figures assume a calibrated monitor with bright, even backlighting, on a worse screen they'll appear to have even less contrast. The three bullet points under "Aptitude Test Practice" at the top were much less comfortable to read due to the fact that the background is both darker and textured (both on my uncalibrated cheap monitor and my good quality one) and required noticeably more cognitive effort. My personal recommendation there would be some combination of increasing the white text-shadow, making them #444444 like the headline (not sure why you have the colours this way around; larger text requires less contrast) and emboldening them. Also, if the site is 'finally finished!' why did you post it up for feedback? Surely it's sensible to ask for feedback BEFORE the site goes live so that changes are made and ready for the golive. Seems illogical to me. QFTW. Edited September 14, 201214 yr by Renaissance-Design
September 14, 201214 yr Author Why did you even bother asking for help if you don't want to change it anyway? I presume you posted this so that people would go 'Oh wow your site is great I love it keep it exactly as it is!' I find it hard to read, yes I can read it, but I have to squint and it hurts my eyes. (On my iMac and on my home computer Dell monitors it's even worse.) It makes me not want to look at the site. I have to highlight the text to make it easier to read and more comfortable. A change to # doesn't distract from the design at all and makes it less difficult for any of those who might suffer, without spoiling the site look for those who can read best. It's a great compromise. Also, if the site is 'finally finished!' why did you post it up for feedback? Surely it's sensible to ask for feedback BEFORE the site goes live so that changes are made and ready for the golive. Seems illogical to me. Fran you're like Inspector Morse. Jamie pointed out that my logo is blurred, which is now on my list of things to do. Someone might have mentioned something else. But the thing people have mostly said is to change the top nav and text colour - neither of these changes I agree with. But it's still been good feedback. As you know, even after a site has gone live, it still needs many more changes. Edited September 14, 201214 yr by WDF
September 14, 201214 yr I really can't find a situation where it's a problem in the real world I find it hard to read, yes I can read it, but I have to squint and it hurts my eyes. (On my iMac and on my home computer Dell monitors it's even worse.) It makes me not want to look at the site. I have to highlight the text to make it easier to read and more comfortable.
September 14, 201214 yr Author Now I've had a chance to look at it: Some of your text is #888888 on white (contrast 3.54:1), some is #7D7D7D on white (contrast 4.12:1). You'd only have to amend those to #767676 to pass WCAG contrast guidelines of 4.5:1, and it's not a big enough change to compromise your visual design. Edit: Just spotted that the footer's even worse, at #A6A6A6, or 2.43:1. All these figures assume a calibrated monitor with bright, even backlighting, on a worse screen they'll appear to have even less contrast. The three bullet points under "Aptitude Test Practice" at the top were much less comfortable to read due to the fact that the background is both darker and textured (both on my uncalibrated cheap monitor and my good quality one) and required noticeably more cognitive effort. My personal recommendation there would be some combination of increasing the white text-shadow, making them #444444 like the headline (not sure why you have the colours this way around; larger text requires less contrast) and emboldening them. QFTW. 'Quote for the Win' - Jesus...come on guys, I've disagreed with two points here. The mildly condescending 'QFTW' from Fran though I could see coming, but it doesn't make her right - I've not worked with one designer ever that didn't ask 'What do you think' even years after a product was launched, let alone the day after.
September 14, 201214 yr 'Quote for the Win' - Jesus...come on guys, I've disagreed with two points here. The mildly condescending 'QFTW' from Fran though I could see coming, but it doesn't make her right - I've not worked with one designer ever that didn't ask 'What do you think' even years after a product was launched, let alone the day after. Sorry, I was in a hurry and that seemed the quickest way of agreeing that earlier in the process would have been a better time to seek feedback.
September 14, 201214 yr Author jtuds - I said - 'I really can't find a situation where it's a problem in the real world' >> 'I'<<
September 14, 201214 yr Chill out. Nobody is attacking you, nothing about this is personal. You posted your work up for critique, people did so, you disagreed, the world continues to spin. But, I do agree with Fran and RD. Posting for feedback when as far as your concerned the project is finished is the wrong time, to be honest. In your mind, it's done, and you're not gonna wanna change anything. The whole point of feedback is it results in changes - otherwise there's no point. Just maybe, next time, either be open minded that it's not finished, or post the work up at an earlier stage Anyway, that's my two cents. Edited September 14, 201214 yr by brightonmike
September 14, 201214 yr Author Chill out. Nobody is attacking you, nothing about this is personal. You posted your work up for critique, people did so, you disagreed, the world continues to spin. But, I do agree with Fran and RD. Posting for feedback when as far as your concerned the project is finished is the wrong time, to be honest. In your mind, it's done, and you're not gonna wanna change anything. The whole point of feedback is it results in changes - otherwise there's no point. Just maybe, next time, either be open minded that it's not finished, or post the work up at an earlier stage Anyway, that's my two cents. Mike, no one is attacking me here, it's just feedback, though mild hostility from a few of you is starting to creep in unfortunately. I used to be a car designer trust me - even after something is 'finished' it will always need further development and input, I can't believe I'm hearing this from web developers! It's not as black and white as you say Mike. Edit: and I could just point out something, which you could call selective hearing from a few of you - I am making a change. There's been 3 things that I've been told I should change, the nav, the font colour, and the blurry logo. I am changing the blurry logo - that's 1/3 of all changes proposed to me - 33%. So, Mike, where do I even begin with your above post? Edited September 14, 201214 yr by WDF
September 14, 201214 yr Okay I think everyone is saying the same - though, this might not be a bad thing you know - McDonalds design their seating so they become uncomfortable after 4 minutes, maybe people won't forget they are on there to get hold of a test, and buy one sooner rather than later? Er.... wut? Even if that is true, you're missing the most important element of this kind of business decision. People use the seats in unethical and frankly revolting fast food restaurants after they've parted with their money. Making people uncomfortable as an incentive to buy ain't going to work - unless your product is some kind of discomfort abolishing widget. Also, the copy-google-cos-they're-successful line of thinking doesn't work for me at all. Yes, Google spend a lot of time and money getting their products right, but you seem to be forgetting about context. The research goes into how people interact with google's products, not yours. Personally I think your nav looks out of place and almost detached from the site. Not what I'd be looking to achieve if I was designing a site. I also think you need to make it clear exactly what you're offering. Because 'practice tests' as the main call to action could be construed as a little misleading. To me it sounds like 'try before you buy' but it takes me to a page asking for my money. I also don't get why I need to practice a psychometric test? What's the benefit for your customers? I don't think you make this nearly obvious enough. If it was my site I'd pimp the hell out of the benefits. Also, why is the nav-bar falling out of the grid?
September 14, 201214 yr Author Mike, no one is attacking me here, it's just feedback, though mild hostility from a few of you is starting to creep in unfortunately. I used to be a car designer trust me - even after something is 'finished' it will always need further development and input, I can't believe I'm hearing this from web developers! It's not as black and white as you say Mike. Edit: and I could just point out something, which you could call selective hearing, from the same few - I am making a change. There's been 3 things that I've been told I should change, the nav, the font colour, and the blurry logo. I am changing the blurry logo - that's 1/3 of all changes proposed to me - 33%. So, Mike, where do I even begin with your above post?
September 14, 201214 yr Even if that is true, you're missing the most important element of this kind of business decision. People use the seats in unethical and frankly revolting fast food restaurants after they've parted with their money. Making people uncomfortable as an incentive to buy ain't going to work - unless your product is some kind of discomfort abolishing widget. The McDonalds seats thing is to increase throughput - shift people out of the restaurant after they've parted with the readies.
September 14, 201214 yr Mike, no one is attacking me here, it's just feedback, though mild hostility from a few of you is starting to creep in unfortunately. I used to be a car designer trust me - even after something is 'finished' it will always need further development and input, I can't believe I'm hearing this from web developers! It's not as black and white as you say Mike. Edit: and I could just point out something, which you could call selective hearing from a few of you - I am making a change. There's been 3 things that I've been told I should change, the nav, the font colour, and the blurry logo. I am changing the blurry logo - that's 1/3 of all changes proposed to me - 33%. So, Mike, where do I even begin with your above post? I was also talking in general, not specific to you. There does come a point where a project is signed off to completion and generally speaking that is not the time developers and designers ask for feedback. We generally ask for feedback throughout the project, not at the end, as throughout the project is when it's easier to make changes. It's harder to make changes when something has been completed. And if something has been signed off, you can't really make changes afterwards unless the client has asked you to and you're getting paid for it. I would certainly never make alterations to websites I've finished for clients unless they asked me to, even if it's something I think would make it better.
September 14, 201214 yr jtuds - I said - 'I really can't find a situation where it's a problem in the real world' >> 'I'<< You have found one. It's on this website. If Fran knocked on your door and told you would it be different? For you to take on board any issues do they have to come from people you know or people you've personally asked face to face? You're making little sense, it seems to me like you're doing whatever you can to justify your decision because you don't want to change it. If you don't want to change the colour that's ok, but you have in no way justified it so there's no point in trying to persuade us you have. I'm sorry for how this thread has turned out but it's frustrating to be asked for feedback only for it to be ignored with no justification.
September 14, 201214 yr Author Er.... wut? Even if that is true, you're missing the most important element of this kind of business decision. People use the seats in unethical and frankly revolting fast food restaurants after they've parted with their money. Making people uncomfortable as an incentive to buy ain't going to work - unless your product is some kind of discomfort abolishing widget. Also, the copy-google-cos-they're-successful line of thinking doesn't work for me at all. Yes, Google spend a lot of time and money getting their products right, but you seem to be forgetting about context. The research goes into how people interact with google's products, not yours. Personally I think your nav looks out of place and almost detached from the site. Not what I'd be looking to achieve if I was designing a site. I also think you need to make it clear exactly what you're offering. Because 'practice tests' as the main call to action could be construed as a little misleading. To me it sounds like 'try before you buy' but it takes me to a page asking for my money. I also don't get why I need to practice a psychometric test? What's the benefit for your customers? I don't think you make this nearly obvious enough. If it was my site I'd pimp the hell out of the benefits. Also, why is the nav-bar falling out of the grid? All this is going over things that have been brought up before, and have all been answered...
September 14, 201214 yr Author I was also talking in general, not specific to you. There does come a point where a project is signed off to completion and generally speaking that is not the time developers and designers ask for feedback. We generally ask for feedback throughout the project, not at the end, as throughout the project is when it's easier to make changes. It's harder to make changes when something has been completed. And if something has been signed off, you can't really make changes afterwards unless the client has asked you to and you're getting paid for it. I would certainly never make alterations to websites I've finished for clients unless they asked me to, even if it's something I think would make it better. But this forum is not my first point of call for feedback, the constant feedback throughout the build has come from the designers, developers and colleagues that I work with. So, to correct your above statement - I have been asking for feedback throughout the project, not just as the end.
September 14, 201214 yr But this forum is not my first point of call for feedback, the constant feedback throughout the build has come from the designers, developers and colleagues that I work with. So, to correct your above statement - I have been asking for feedback throughout the project, not just as the end. You just don't get it, do you? "I was also talking in general, not specific to you." In other words, I was trying to explain the reasoning behind other people thinking it is not the right time for you to ask for feedback.
September 14, 201214 yr Author You have found one. It's on this website. If Fran knocked on your door and told you would it be different? For you to take on board any issues do they have to come from people you know or people you've personally asked face to face? You're making little sense, it seems to me like you're doing whatever you can to justify your decision because you don't want to change it. If you don't want to change the colour that's ok, but you have in no way justified it so there's no point in trying to persuade us you have. I'm sorry for how this thread has turned out but it's frustrating to be asked for feedback only for it to be ignored with no justification. The feedback hasn't been ignored - I'm changing my logo so it's sharper. It's equally frustrating for me to be told that I'm 'ignoring the feedback without justification' when I have justified it and am not ignoring it - I've asked every designer and developer I know, they all say it's fine - this thread is the only place where the font colour is an issue, and I have considered it but have decided not to go with a darker colour.
September 14, 201214 yr Author http://contrastrebellion.com/ I've been labelled a rebellion, now this is more familiar.
September 14, 201214 yr Author You just don't get it, do you? "I was also talking in general, not specific to you." In other words, I was trying to explain the reasoning behind other people thinking it is not the right time for you to ask for feedback. No, you said - "In your mind, it's done, and you're not gonna wanna change anything. The whole point of feedback is it results in changes - otherwise there's no point." You are contradicting yourself now Mike, and thanks but I'll decide when I want feedback, if it be after or during the project. Like I said before, lots of designers ask for feedback years after a project has been launched.
September 14, 201214 yr Author Anyone else want to contribute to my barrage of hate mail? Edit:...this is called humour by the way, guys... Edited September 14, 201214 yr by WDF
September 14, 201214 yr Anyone else want to contribute to my barrage of hate mail? There is no hate mail and that's a very immature response. You asked for feedback, you got it, you disagreed with the vast majority of people here and you keep trying to justify yourself. If you want people to stop replying then stop replying yourself.
Create an account or sign in to comment