February 4, 201115 yr I currently maintain a fairly basic web site for a large sports club - built using Dreamweaver 8 and Fireworks 8. I inherited the site in its infancy from someone else and at the time it consisted of a few very basic pages. My experience of actually constructing web sites is very limited - but I have a good grounding in HTML4 and can use Fireworks quite well. I suspect I build very functional rather than dynamic pages. My dilemma is this: I now have the opportunity to be provided with either a new laptop or a new Mac - with the intention of possibly producing a new web site based on the current information. What is the current consensus, based on your experiences as to which platform and which software work well together. I would probably hope to transfer quite a bit of my code from my current PC to the new platform - so I suspect there might be compatibility issues if we go down the Mac path??? As mentioned above - I have limited experience of construction - so anything too advanced will not be an option. I have no knowledge whatsoever of other software such as Flash. Thanks in advance and I look forward to hearing your opinions and experiences before making my decision on what to purchase. frankieirishman
February 4, 201115 yr We all use iMacs with CS4/5. I think quality of the screen render compared with many PCs is much clearer and the larger screens make designing a treat. Its all down to preference though to be honest. If you're used to using PCs and you feel confident using PCs to work on then I guess just buy a decent PC. Macs are a lot more expensive than equivalent PCs, so you may also be limited by budget! Whichever platform you choose, you really need to get hold of Adobe CS - if not the whole suite then just Photoshop, Dreamweaver and maybe Flash at the very least to get cracking. I suggest you learn how to use Photoshop as this is one of the key tools for designing websites. Hope this helps. Edited February 4, 201115 yr by jay pick
February 4, 201115 yr The PC v's Mac thing is an age old debate and really boils down to personal preference. For instance i would go PC over Mac every time because of the efficiency in price v's power (and the fact i like to play with the internals of Windows and make it do what i want). As far as compatibility goes, you won't have a problem. HTML files etc are non-platform specific. I often receive files from Mac using clients/friends without a problem.
February 4, 201115 yr I suggest you learn how to use Photoshop as this is the key tool really for designing websites. Not wishing to nit-pick here, I can help but step in here and say I totally disagree with this. I would say knowledge and experience are the keys to designing websites, and use of a graphics program can be useful at times. There are many sites on the web with excellent and balanced design that could quite easily have been designed in the browser (actually starting with a pen and some paper is a good first step.) Then there are the sites that include complex illustrations, for which photoshop is neither useful nor required. A decent vector image editor really helps here, and there's no reason why you can mock-up your layout using that, too. I just hate this idea that photoshop is a design tool. It's not. It's an image editor. By all means, use it for design work, even create all your web layouts using it if you like. But don't spread the myth that it's an essential piece of the web designer's toolkit, because it's not.
February 4, 201115 yr Not wishing to nit-pick here, I can help but step in here and say I totally disagree with this. I would say knowledge and experience are the keys to designing websites, and use of a graphics program can be useful at times. There are many sites on the web with excellent and balanced design that could quite easily have been designed in the browser (actually starting with a pen and some paper is a good first step.) Then there are the sites that include complex illustrations, for which photoshop is neither useful nor required. A decent vector image editor really helps here, and there's no reason why you can mock-up your layout using that, too. I just hate this idea that photoshop is a design tool. It's not. It's an image editor. By all means, use it for design work, even create all your web layouts using it if you like. But don't spread the myth that it's an essential piece of the web designer's toolkit, because it's not. Of course design is done using other graphics programs and of course elements of design are created through the browser with CSS, I completely agree. You are quite right. However, I am not not spreading a myth at all. If you ask most designers, the program that will say they use for the majority is Photoshop. I'm sure they will also say that it is an essential part of their design toolkit. Edited February 4, 201115 yr by jay pick
February 4, 201115 yr Where as i consider myself to be a designer through the browser, i wouldn't dream of not having Photoshop in my tool kit, so i can emphasise with both of you on this.
February 4, 201115 yr Photoshop over used and over rated. I’ll use it when I have a photo that needs to be “shoped”. Not when I have websites to be designed. Sure you might want to make a graphic mock up of the site but there are a hundred different ways of doing that. The browser is the canvas for the web.
February 4, 201115 yr However, I am not not spreading a myth at all. If you ask most designers, the program that will say they use for the majority is Photoshop. I'm sure they will also say that it is an essential part of their design toolkit. Respectfully, I would say you are Seriously, just because lots of web designers find it invaluable, and spend all day working with it, doesn't mean we should all tell new designers that they must have it. Face it - it's expensive as hell, and most web designers only use a fraction of what it's capable of, and would be able to create work that's just as good with any number of software packages.
February 4, 201115 yr In the 12 odd years I've been building sites I've never used any Adobe sofware, let alone Photoshop. In fact when I started Photoshop didn't even support the .jpg format without a plugin, and not even a whiff of image optimisation facilities. Only after Adobe copied features from other software did they get up to date and offer features for web developers.
February 5, 201115 yr The only time i'd get a MAC is if you are considering building iPhone apps. Corporate tape means you must have a MAC to do that. Otherwise, if you're on a limited budget right now. Get a PC. You have all the capabilities of a MAC, plus some great games if you fancy a break during the day. Not to say there isn't games on the MAC just more choice on PC. Also, repairs and upgrades far cheaper.
February 5, 201115 yr Honestly, whether you get a Mac or PC should be for reasons completely irrelevant to web design. Both the PC and Mac have an abundance of great tools for designing or coding websites. Choose what system you like the most. I use a combination of Dreamweaver and Photoshop and that works on both PC and Mac and even Ubuntu if you know how to get Wine up and running, heh heh.
February 5, 201115 yr Hi Frankie, I started a web developer job back in November 2010 and had the choice of getting either a MAC or PC. When I started the job, I used the MAC available in the office for about 2 weeks. At the end of that 2 weeks, my boss then asked me which I would prefer to have, and I chose the PC as this was what I was used to using in my freelancing years. Because I was used to designing and building on the PC, I found the MAC pretty awkward and it didn't have the software available that I was used to using on the PC. What I'm trying to get at is, use what you think will benefit you the most, only you will be able to decide this.
February 6, 201115 yr Like everyone says, YMMV. It's basically a matter of what you're more comfortable using, because that will have a direct effect on your productivity. Someone said something about screen quality and size above - that's bunk, of course. You can plug a screen of any size and quality into a PC, same as you can a Mac (at least a Mac Pro, not sure about the graphics outputs on an iMac). The important thing is the type of panel used (S-IPS for quality and colour reproduction vs TN or TN+ at the lower end of the spectrum) - although saying that, there are some TN panels that are acceptable for design work. Anyone who says an iMac has a wonderful screen has clearly never used a really good screen, like an Eizo ColorEdge (about £1200-1400 for a 24" or £2250 for a 30"). MacOS has slightly better text rendering than Windows, although with the percentage of your end-users who are going to be using Windows, it's best to see what they'll be seeing.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Thanks for the sound advice...this isn't going to be an easy decision to make methinks! Frankieirishman We all use iMacs with CS4/5. I think quality of the screen render compared with many PCs is much clearer and the larger screens make designing a treat. Its all down to preference though to be honest. If you're used to using PCs and you feel confident using PCs to work on then I guess just buy a decent PC. Macs are a lot more expensive than equivalent PCs, so you may also be limited by budget! Whichever platform you choose, you really need to get hold of Adobe CS - if not the whole suite then just Photoshop, Dreamweaver and maybe Flash at the very least to get cracking. I suggest you learn how to use Photoshop as this is one of the key tools for designing websites. Hope this helps.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Thanks for the reply....it is gratifying to know that html is non-platform specific...one less factor to consider in making my decision. Frankieirishman The PC v's Mac thing is an age old debate and really boils down to personal preference. For instance i would go PC over Mac every time because of the efficiency in price v's power (and the fact i like to play with the internals of Windows and make it do what i want). As far as compatibility goes, you won't have a problem. HTML files etc are non-platform specific. I often receive files from Mac using clients/friends without a problem.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Thanks for taking the time to reply. I will use your observations as part of my decision making process. Frankieirishman Not wishing to nit-pick here, I can help but step in here and say I totally disagree with this. I would say knowledge and experience are the keys to designing websites, and use of a graphics program can be useful at times. There are many sites on the web with excellent and balanced design that could quite easily have been designed in the browser (actually starting with a pen and some paper is a good first step.) Then there are the sites that include complex illustrations, for which photoshop is neither useful nor required. A decent vector image editor really helps here, and there's no reason why you can mock-up your layout using that, too. I just hate this idea that photoshop is a design tool. It's not. It's an image editor. By all means, use it for design work, even create all your web layouts using it if you like. But don't spread the myth that it's an essential piece of the web designer's toolkit, because it's not.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Thanks for taking the time to reply. I now have considerable food for thought and am really grateful that so many people have responded to my post. frankieirishman In the 12 odd years I've been building sites I've never used any Adobe sofware, let alone Photoshop. In fact when I started Photoshop didn't even support the .jpg format without a plugin, and not even a whiff of image optimisation facilities. Only after Adobe copied features from other software did they get up to date and offer features for web developers.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Many thanks for taking the time to reply and for the advice. Frankieirishman Honestly, whether you get a Mac or PC should be for reasons completely irrelevant to web design. Both the PC and Mac have an abundance of great tools for designing or coding websites. Choose what system you like the most. I use a combination of Dreamweaver and Photoshop and that works on both PC and Mac and even Ubuntu if you know how to get Wine up and running, heh heh.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Thanks a lot for replying and the sound advice. Frankieirishman Hi Frankie, I started a web developer job back in November 2010 and had the choice of getting either a MAC or PC. When I started the job, I used the MAC available in the office for about 2 weeks. At the end of that 2 weeks, my boss then asked me which I would prefer to have, and I chose the PC as this was what I was used to using in my freelancing years. Because I was used to designing and building on the PC, I found the MAC pretty awkward and it didn't have the software available that I was used to using on the PC. What I'm trying to get at is, use what you think will benefit you the most, only you will be able to decide this.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Many thanks for taking the time to reply and the advice and observations. Frankieirishman Like everyone says, YMMV. It's basically a matter of what you're more comfortable using, because that will have a direct effect on your productivity. Someone said something about screen quality and size above - that's bunk, of course. You can plug a screen of any size and quality into a PC, same as you can a Mac (at least a Mac Pro, not sure about the graphics outputs on an iMac). The important thing is the type of panel used (S-IPS for quality and colour reproduction vs TN or TN+ at the lower end of the spectrum) - although saying that, there are some TN panels that are acceptable for design work. Anyone who says an iMac has a wonderful screen has clearly never used a really good screen, like an Eizo ColorEdge (about £1200-1400 for a 24" or £2250 for a 30"). MacOS has slightly better text rendering than Windows, although with the percentage of your end-users who are going to be using Windows, it's best to see what they'll be seeing.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Many thanks for taking the time to reply and the sound advice. frankieirishman In the 12 odd years I've been building sites I've never used any Adobe sofware, let alone Photoshop. In fact when I started Photoshop didn't even support the .jpg format without a plugin, and not even a whiff of image optimisation facilities. Only after Adobe copied features from other software did they get up to date and offer features for web developers.
February 14, 201115 yr Author Thanks for taking the time to reply and the advice. frankieirishman The only time i'd get a MAC is if you are considering building iPhone apps. Corporate tape means you must have a MAC to do that. Otherwise, if you're on a limited budget right now. Get a PC. You have all the capabilities of a MAC, plus some great games if you fancy a break during the day. Not to say there isn't games on the MAC just more choice on PC. Also, repairs and upgrades far cheaper.
Create an account or sign in to comment