July 16, 201016 yr Hi all. I'm new here and relatively new to web design and am now looking to take my skills onto a new level. As a budding new web designer, I'm now considering which software is best. My assumption was that I'd have to go with Adobe. However, after reading a few comments on here, there are some who consider it to be too expensive given that there are other options out there which could also be better. I was hoping for advice from experienced people who could let me know if you think Adobe is the way to go or recommend any other software. Thank you and grateful in advance Simon
July 16, 201016 yr You've got a few choices, here's some I know of and would recommend: Designing: Windows & Mac OS X: Adobe Photoshop Adobe Illustrator GIMP Coding: Windows: Komodo Edit Notepad++ Mac OS X: Coda - the best web code editor in my opinion Komodo Edit
July 17, 201016 yr You've got a few choices, here's some I know of and would recommend: Designing: Windows & Mac OS X: Adobe Photoshop Adobe Illustrator GIMP Coding: Windows: Komodo Edit Notepad++ Mac OS X: Coda - the best web code editor in my opinion Komodo Edit If you can afford it get an Adobe suite(CS3, CS4 or CS5) There is a good reason why these are favored or recommended and i would question anyone's seriousness if they didn't at least consider Photoshop? Yes, not everyone can afford it but it's the industry's standard for a reason and you are just limiting your potential if you ignore it. Okay people will certainly disagree with me here and say use gimp instead. But if you really wanna get into the industry and start applying for junior positions...your application will only get binned if Gimp is favored over Photoshop and that's a fact! I would highly recommend downloading the 30 day FREE trial of CS5 and learn Photoshop and Dreamweaver and once you have the funds available, buy it! - Neil
July 17, 201016 yr If you can afford it get an Adobe suite(CS3, CS4 or CS5) There is a good reason why these are favored or recommended and i would question anyone's seriousness if they didn't at least consider Photoshop? Yes, not everyone can afford it but it's the industry's standard for a reason and you are just limiting your potential if you ignore it. Okay people will certainly disagree with me here and say use gimp instead. But if you really wanna get into the industry and start applying for junior positions...your application will only get binned if Gimp is favored over Photoshop and that's a fact! I would highly recommend downloading the 30 day FREE trial of CS5 and learn Photoshop and Dreamweaver and once you have the funds available, buy it! - Neil I did recommend Photoshop..?
July 17, 201016 yr I did recommend Photoshop..? Yeah sure...wasn't digging at you? I just hit reply after reading your post.
July 17, 201016 yr Yeah sure...wasn't digging at you? I just hit reply after reading your post. Ah, my bad
July 18, 201016 yr Author Hi guys. Thank you for your replies and suggestions I really appreciate it with all the choice that's out there! I've seen comments on the web suggesting Dreamweaver isn't always the ideal solution, as it finishes tags for you. Is this the only problem with DW? Is Adobe software basically one of the most used tools of web designers? Dreamweaver, Photoshop and so on? With their packages, the ability to create web content including video seems to be very useful. Thanks again
July 18, 201016 yr No, that's not the only problem with Dreamweaver. It bloats code and hides it from you. You will never learn anything using Dreamweaver and will find most of your sites are invalid. The Spry code it generates adds tens/hundreds of lines of impossible Javascript, which could be cut down to 5-10 jQuery lines. It also loves tables, you should learn table-less HTML. Adobe Photoshop - Yes Adobe Dreamweaver - No, use a real code editor.
July 18, 201016 yr No, that's not the only problem with Dreamweaver. It bloats code and hides it from you. You will never learn anything using Dreamweaver and will find most of your sites are invalid. The Spry code it generates adds tens/hundreds of lines of impossible Javascript, which could be cut down to 5-10 jQuery lines. It also loves tables, you should learn table-less HTML. Adobe Photoshop - Yes Adobe Dreamweaver - No, use a real code editor. Sorry Andy but gonna disagree with you this time....sorry dude! Dreamweaver does bloat your files with unnecessary code only if you let it. If you have DW opened up in code view...it's not much different than any other text editor. But using the css panel or have it in design view will cause you problems like Andy said and will just look unprofessional. But....Dreamweaver CS5 is sooooo much better and well worth the cost as it will allow you to work a lot quicker and efficient than most text editors will. DW5 enables you to develop with PHP-based content management systems such as WordPress, Joomla, or Drupal. Display's proper syntax for custom PHP functions to help you write code more accurately and if you download the adobe HTML5 extension pack, it will provide features to help users generate HTML5 and CSS3 code. Features include Multiscreen Preview, Media Query support, code hinting, starter layouts, and WebKit updates for rendering enhancements. DW5 is more of an IDE now than a WYSIWYG. You will never have to open up a web browser and flick to and throw as it has a webkit browser integrated inside of it and you will see your code working live(probably why it's called live view) Anyway...enough of that....do whatever feels best and what works for you?
July 18, 201016 yr Author Thanks for the further advice Can I just quickly ask Andy about invalid sites with regards to Dreamweaver? Just to expand what Neil says, one thing certainly stands out when looking around the internet.. web design tools are very much down to personal taste! Everyone has their own likes and dislikes about software. Thanks again
July 19, 201016 yr Can I just quickly ask Andy about invalid sites with regards to Dreamweaver? Some of the code Dreamweaver generates (from my experience and others) creates W3C validation errors on your page. They won't be too complicated to fix and are usually caused only if you use the 'Spry' feature, but it's an annoyance nonetheless. Give Dreamweaver a shot if you have the money to spare, I just think there's a reason behind the majority using the other available code editors.
July 20, 201016 yr Hi guys. Thank you for your replies and suggestions I really appreciate it with all the choice that's out there! I've seen comments on the web suggesting Dreamweaver isn't always the ideal solution, as it finishes tags for you. Is this the only problem with DW? Is Adobe software basically one of the most used tools of web designers? Dreamweaver, Photoshop and so on? With their packages, the ability to create web content including video seems to be very useful. Thanks again No...I used Dw, and a lot of my sites were displaying much different as they were in DW. Thanks to this forum, i now Code websites using notepad++ and the sites display fine. Like andyl said, it hides the code from you, unless you have it in split view. Thats really annoying as the screen is much smaller. Whereas when Coding, i can clearly see if there is a mistake that needs to be changed within the code. Hope that helped there mate, Ash
July 20, 201016 yr No...I used Dw, and a lot of my sites were displaying much different as they were in DW. Thanks to this forum, i now Code websites using notepad++ and the sites display fine. Like andyl said, it hides the code from you, unless you have it in split view. Thats really annoying as the screen is much smaller. Whereas when Coding, i can clearly see if there is a mistake that needs to be changed within the code. Hope that helped there mate, Ash Isn't that what code view does in DW??? Sorry, i am not normally an argumentative bloke and i can't believe that i am praising DW as i first learn't to code through basic text editors myself? But the point i am getting at here is that Dreamweaver can't and never has put unwanted code into your pages when YOU write the code using CODE view! It's no different than using notepad++ or any other text editor! Just DON'T use it in design view(WYSIWYG) And the fact that it comes with the Adobe suite(Photoshop was also mentioned)and CS5 has had a MAJOR overhaul...is in my eyes well worth using if you CAN afford the software. I have tested quite a few editors - Komodo, Aptana, Notepad++, Netbeans and since i have been using DWCS5, it has really helped with the workflow. Interrogated FTP client, Interrogated webkit browser, syntax highlighting, code completion - what more do you want? Unless it's a free text editor!. Doh!
July 20, 201016 yr It's the built-in features of DW that make it an awful application. If you just use it like Notepad++, to quote you, then why would you spend £300+ on it when you could get the same thing for free? Plus with a free code editor, you'd most likely be supporting open-source which is always nice to do.
July 20, 201016 yr It's the built-in features of DW that make it an awful application. If you just use it like Notepad++, to quote you, then why would you spend £300+ on it when you could get the same thing for free? Plus with a free code editor, you'd most likely be supporting open-source which is always nice to do. Not being funny but have you looked at CS5 yet? I must admit i do like using netbeans and eclipse and supporting open source is always nice like you say...but if he is going to buy the Adobe suite 5 and i would highly recommend using DW as it is completely different to the other versions and is getting recommended more and more by the so called guru's. That's all i am really getting at? If you have it then at least use it and don't worry about the old code bloating stories - even though they are true in older versions. But sod it!.....don't listen to me, just use all the open source ones until you find what works for you.....balls to it!
July 20, 201016 yr Not being funny but have you looked at CS5 yet? I must admit i do like using netbeans and eclipse and supporting open source is always nice like you say...but if he is going to buy the Adobe suite 5 and i would highly recommend using DW as it is completely different to the other versions and is getting recommended more and more by the so called guru's. That's all i am really getting at? If you have it then at least use it and don't worry about the old code bloating stories - even though they are true in older versions. Ok, I'll agree with you IF he/she is buying the full CS5 suite. Buying Dreamweaver CSx as a standalone app would be a mistake in my opinion. There's better, for free. But sod it!.....don't listen to me, just use all the open source ones until you find what works for you.....balls to it! No need for that - it's just a chilled debate. I use Coda which isn't free or open source either. You can't get Coda for Win, but if you could, I'd be recommending that above all others.
July 20, 201016 yr No need for that - it's just a chilled debate. I use Coda which isn't free or open source either. You can't get Coda for Win, but if you could, I'd be recommending that above all others. Was only joking. I like chilled debates it's healthy. I use a Mac at work and have used both textmate and coda. Superb ain't they. But i am hooked on DW5 now as i am really getting into PHP and it's really helpful on that. Like i said netbeans and eclipse are to! Nice debating with you Andy
July 20, 201016 yr Was only joking. I like chilled debates it's healthy. I use a Mac at work and have used both textmate and coda. Superb ain't they. But i am hooked on DW5 now as i am really getting into PHP and it's really helpful on that. Like i said netbeans and eclipse are to! Nice debating with you Andy Hmm, don't say that - you've half tempted me into trying Dreamweaver CS5 trial now to see what it's like with PHP Seemed sarcastic, but if not - nice debate PS. Might consider handing this thread back to its owner now...
July 20, 201016 yr Hmm, don't say that - you've half tempted me into trying Dreamweaver CS5 trial now to see what it's like with PHP Seemed sarcastic, but if not - nice debate It always does sound sarcy when read out. I don't know...perhaps i was? PS. Might consider handing this thread back to its owner now... Yeah might be a good idea....? haven't heard from him/her for ages? Hello....HELLO! Nope gone!
July 20, 201016 yr These debates never come to a conclusion; it's simply all about personal taste. Comparing DW to notepad++ is unfair as DW is an IDE, not just a text editor. The only decent alternatives (free) to DW (imo) are netbeans and eclipse. I haven't tried DW in a long time but I sincerely hope it has upped its game. For me, netbeans has the edge: great php support; namespaces for one! support for symfony and zend frameworks plugins for svn, mercury and git (interested to know if DW now supports any version control) However, in my experience, all of these IDEs fall down at the ftp client part. I would always recommend filezilla etc instead of the IDE implementation. Happy to hear that DW is improving though. But... unless bought as part of the suite, it is hard to justify the cost.
July 21, 201016 yr +1 @ElanMan Unless it incorporates unit testing, debugging, autocompletion on class libraries, it's just a text editor. There's a broad definition of "coding" here - as wide as the distance writing custom CSS and a full blown PHP MVC/ORM framework... If you're involved in the latter, then DW(and Coda IMO) aren't the right tools for the job. Oh, and Netbeans ftw - it's simply brilliant (if a little slow...)
July 21, 201016 yr DW CS5 is the best option for code and design along with photoshop you can make some amassing websites
July 21, 201016 yr Isn't that what code view does in DW??? Sorry, i am not normally an argumentative bloke and i can't believe that i am praising DW as i first learn't to code through basic text editors myself? But the point i am getting at here is that Dreamweaver can't and never has put unwanted code into your pages when YOU write the code using CODE view! It's no different than using notepad++ or any other text editor! Just DON'T use it in design view(WYSIWYG) And the fact that it comes with the Adobe suite(Photoshop was also mentioned)and CS5 has had a MAJOR overhaul...is in my eyes well worth using if you CAN afford the software. I have tested quite a few editors - Komodo, Aptana, Notepad++, Netbeans and since i have been using DWCS5, it has really helped with the workflow. Interrogated FTP client, Interrogated webkit browser, syntax highlighting, code completion - what more do you want? Unless it's a free text editor!. Doh! You can have it in split view but its really annoying as it makes things look smaller, budges things around to fit the screen, as well as you having to scroll around. What i mean is that instead of wasting money on Dw, for the code view...use something open source if u want a WYSIWYG editor
July 21, 201016 yr Author Hey all, I'm here! I see there's been some debating since I last checked! Good debate though as it gives good pros/cons to all software. It's good to see people being passionate about something they love too. I've seen there's another debate today on Dreaweaver. I guess everything has it's good points and not so good points and ultimately maybe it's like the Mac v PC debate. Mac lovers love their Macs and wouldn't swap for anything As you guys say, it's ultimately probably going to be down to having a good look round and personal taste and what works best for individuals. Thanks again for all of your help and getting involved. I'll be taking a look back over the posts before I spend any money so it has been a big help. Thanks all
July 21, 201016 yr I see there's been some debating since I last checked! What more can you expect from a (great) bunch of perfectionists? it's like the Mac v PC debate. Oh God, not here..! I'll be taking a look back over the posts before I spend any money so it has been a big help. Well, to be fair about everything, try out all the free ones suggested (including Dreamweaver free trial) - then make your decision
July 21, 201016 yr Just to throw another one into the mix but microsoft visual studio is also a good one!
August 5, 201016 yr I've been using Dreamweaver since I got rid of Frontpage 98 in 2000. I haven't used design view in about 8 years. With that said, I am also partial to a bit of standard Notepad when I need to make a quick change and don't want to load such a big app like Dreamweaver.
August 26, 201016 yr Hi, When I was younger I used frontpage then came Dreamweaver...I've never looked back since. I've been using Adobe package every since, I recommend you Adobe Dreamweaver for HTML and Photoshop or Fireworks for Graphic Design The CS5 package now has support for Content Management Systems like joomla, wordpress and it's brilliant, its much better than it used to be Thanks Darshan
August 26, 201016 yr The CS5 package now has support for Content Management Systems like joomla, wordpress and it's brilliant, its much better than it used to be I've been meaning to try and get into Dreamweaver, i just find it quite overwhelming
August 26, 201016 yr I found it a bit too much in the beginning then slowly you get into it, just concentrate on the parts you need to know forget the rest, as you need to use features learn about them....its the best way to do it :-)
August 26, 201016 yr i used Dw at first...liked it but my sites weren't displaying right, so i started coding
August 26, 201016 yr I found it a bit too much in the beginning then slowly you get into it, just concentrate on the parts you need to know forget the rest, as you need to use features learn about them....its the best way to do it :-) Yeah but i never get round to it, i can do things twice as fast in notepad++ than in DW, and it'll always be like that until i learn it ): I might just go back to aptana, i stopped using it because it was pretty clunky. I've been told the new one is alot better though :/
August 27, 201016 yr Another vote for Notepad++ here, have that on one monitor, Firefox with Firebug on the other, what more do you need! Unless developing a complex application for example I don't think an IDE is necessary
August 28, 201016 yr I'm a Adobe Veteran and Dreamweaver CS5 just hits the spot! lol, i may start using it again.....not too sure though :/
November 30, 201015 yr I should suggest Adobe Dreamweaver CS4. Its no need to expertise in HTML programming languages as its generate the HTML code.
November 30, 201015 yr I use Espresso and CSSEdit, both are slick, easy to adjust to, and strips out all the bloated fluff that you get with Dreamweaver. Every now and again use Coda, depends what mood i'm in!
Create an account or sign in to comment