March 12, 201214 yr Hello, So was browsing the BBC this morning when i found this "Could tablet computers replace PCs?" Are you f**king kidding me! A tablet will NOT EVER replace a PC! The idiot half way through then has the cheak to say "A tablet will replace expensive PC's" - then get a cheap one!!! Idiot!!! http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-17284622 There are some real tw*ts out there! I hate it when people start playing with the geek stuff and have no idea about the tech world and suddenly they know everything!
March 12, 201214 yr Author Wow someones a bit angry today! Aha, I just wokeup, Its people like me that brings other people back to reality..
March 12, 201214 yr Hello, So was browsing the BBC this morning when i found this "Could tablet computers replace PCs?" Are you f**king kidding me! A tablet will NOT EVER replace a PC! The idiot half way through then has the cheak to say "A tablet will replace expensive PC's" - then get a cheap one!!! Idiot!!! http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-17284622 There are some real tw*ts out there! I hate it when people start playing with the geek stuff and have no idea about the tech world and suddenly they know everything! Well to be fair.....we are also quite naive about the use of tech, for instance our job requires us to own a PC or a laptop, we need it, then you have the 30+ or 40+ people that are not as tech wise as we are, they don't need a platform to design/program on or to play the newest games on, they need a platform for Facebook, Gmail and all the Facebook games, so yes tablets may replace PC's in that group, but out generation that grew up with gaming will still prefer PC's over tablets any day. EDIT: tablet sales topping PC sales in 2013 is a tough one tho. also since this report is about able estimations you shouldn't take it to serious. Edited March 12, 201214 yr by D.Schuster
March 12, 201214 yr *Journalists* I could pick fault with at least 2 erroneous arguments on that video
March 12, 201214 yr have no idea about the tech world and suddenly they know everything! is this irony? So why won't tablets replace PCs? I suspect most home users just want to access the internet in the easiest way possible.
March 12, 201214 yr The 99% of tasks somebody like my Mum performs on a computer could just as well be performed on a Tablet. But I don't think iPads are the answer, and I also think people are not ready to leave their desks yet. I think the Transformer Prime is actually more towards what we will end up with then the iPad. I also think Windows 8 gives us the potential to have one device that can function as a tablet as well as a PC. Edited March 12, 201214 yr by brightonmike
March 12, 201214 yr then you have the 30+ or 40+ people that are not as tech wise as we are Dont assume everybody over 30 is not "tech wise". I actually fall outside both categories but manage very well thank you Just firing up the BBC Micro!!
March 12, 201214 yr If i had to use a tablet instead of a PC i'd end up killing myself but only after a i rampage down the street striking people with the tablet. Tablets are great for looking something up or casual browsing but for anything else they're close to useless. If they do take over from PC's then i'm going to get qualified as a physiotherapist as the ceses of RSI will go shooting up! I'd pay no attention to this piece of rubbish media bias, let's not forget it was only a couple of years ago when they were claiming smartphones would kill the PC.
March 12, 201214 yr So was browsing the BBC this morning when i found this "Could tablet computers replace PCs?" Are you f**king kidding me! A tablet will NOT EVER replace a PC! Come on now, it's just a journalist bashing out some nonsense to get paid -and who can blame them? Besides, this kind of drivel has been going around for ages now...a bit like how Google+ was going to obliterate Facebook, Twitter and Linkedin. It's just something for a journo to write about.
March 12, 201214 yr Author If i had to use a tablet instead of a PC i'd end up killing myself but only after a i rampage down the street striking people with the tablet. Tablets are great for looking something up or casual browsing but for anything else they're close to useless. If they do take over from PC's then i'm going to get qualified as a physiotherapist as the ceses of RSI will go shooting up! I'd pay no attention to this piece of rubbish media bias, let's not forget it was only a couple of years ago when they were claiming smartphones would kill the PC. Damn right, a company who i repair computers for had a batch of IPad's now i also set-up 8 CCTV cams which are accessible from a local IP which requires Java to watch the live feed... and was slightly p*ssed to find that the tablets didnt support Java... So let me get this right, You cut the keyboard of a laptop, degrade the software and tell us its an Ipad at £400... fine, its portable but come on ffs, Its 2012.. what can they do that a laptop can not if not better! Good post mike, I 100% agree, There good for browsing on the move unless you get mugged, but other than that useless... Ohh just to add the point.. you can play games... but cant run Java.. Thats like saying, You can have a laptop BUT you carnt have the keyboard...
March 12, 201214 yr People don't always want PCs or Laptops. A lot of the time, all somebody wants to do, is check their email, read the news, and browse Facebook. All tasks that a tablet such as the Prime or iPad will perform perfectly adequately. You can dislike a device on a personal level, I myself am no fan of the iPad, but whilst I don't think they will replace desktops, there is certainly a market for them.
March 12, 201214 yr which is what the guy says in the video.....for most people, for most of the time and for most of their needs, a tablet will do and in that context will replace an expensive PC.
March 12, 201214 yr People don't always want PCs or Laptops. A lot of the time, all somebody wants to do, is check their email, read the news, and browse Facebook. All tasks that a tablet such as the Prime or iPad will perform perfectly adequately. You can dislike a device on a personal level, I myself am no fan of the iPad, but whilst I don't think they will replace desktops, there is certainly a market for them. ...so not really 'Replacing the PC' then. Well not on the level that journalist fails at. which is what the guy says in the video.....for most people, for most of the time and for most of their needs, a tablet will do and in that context will replace an expensive PC. If that's all the user is needing to do then they shouldn't have an expensive PC. Possible a budget £400 model. How much is an iPad... oh wait... I'm all for the average user having an iPad but fot the rest of us, it's pretty useless. Edited March 12, 201214 yr by MikeChipshop
March 12, 201214 yr Dont assume everybody over 30 is not "tech wise". I actually fall outside both categories but manage very well thank you Just firing up the BBC Micro!! And just when did I say EVERYONE that falls into the 30+ or 40+ category is not tech wise? To every majority there are a few exceptions.
March 12, 201214 yr ...so not really 'Replacing the PC' then. Well not on the level that journalist fails at. No, definitely not. I think this whole notion of "replacement" is ridiculous from the off. Different devices perform different tasks to a different level. There will always, always be the need for desktop PCs. But, the tablet does offer a different way of doing more basic tasks that appeals to a lot of normal users. I still maintain W8 could change the game. Imagine a Tablet, with Metro UI, yet with a docking station (keyboard, mouse, monitor etc) that turns it into a desktop PC with the normal Windows interface. Now imagine you also have a docking station at work. You'd never need to transfer a file again, you'd never have compatibility problems again, and you get the best of both worlds in a single device... Edited March 12, 201214 yr by brightonmike
March 12, 201214 yr Author ...so not really 'Replacing the PC' then. Well not on the level that journalist fails at. If that's all the user is needing to do then they shouldn't have an expensive PC. Possible a budget £400 model. How much is an iPad... oh wait... I'm all for the average user having an iPad but fot the rest of us, it's pretty useless. Yh simply email checking is good, but when he mentions about the user not needing to buy an expensive pc, is an ipad not expensive then? LOL
March 12, 201214 yr I'm all for the average user having an iPad but fot the rest of us, it's pretty useless. exactly, which is what the guy said in the video. Just some people didn't hear it in their blind 'knowledge'.
March 12, 201214 yr Snip Yup, exactly. The media seems excited to 'replace' stuff at the drop of a hat. I don't think they've ever heard of the word 'Compliment'. In my world, all my different devices 'compliment' each other rather than replace each other. As for Windows 8, i totally agree but i do think MS is quite there yet. Saying that, it is a long time till it gets to RTM.
March 12, 201214 yr Author exactly, which is what the guy said in the video. Just some people didn't hear it in their blind 'knowledge'. Like i said, £400 is pretty expensive to, Point being why would you even want to spend anymore than £150 just to check your emails.. your phone can do this on the move just as easy.
March 12, 201214 yr Author Yup, exactly. The media seems excited to 'replace' stuff at the drop of a hat. I don't think they've ever heard of the word 'Compliment'. In my world, all my different devices 'compliment' each other rather than replace each other. As for Windows 8, i totally agree but i do think MS is quite there yet. Saying that, it is a long time till it gets to RTM. Windows 8 is more for tablet users and does things well, but thats another story
March 12, 201214 yr But it's not marketed to folk like us, it's marketed to the mindless masses as a status symbol/must have tech accessory.
March 12, 201214 yr £400 isn't expensive for the iPad. It's when you start looking at the models with the greater storage that the pricing starts to get silly. It can do a hell of a lot more then check emails. David Hockney, arguably the greatest artists alive, uses his iPad to capture colour and even draw some full pictures. And they are stunning, and only possible with the iPad.
March 12, 201214 yr And just when did I say EVERYONE that falls into the 30+ or 40+ category is not tech wise? To every majority there are a few exceptions. Everyone or Everybody same thing. And of course you are correct in saying that there are exceptions but of course that would then make your original statement incorrect LOL
March 12, 201214 yr exactly, which is what the guy said in the video. Just some people didn't hear it in their blind 'knowledge'. I can't actually get the video to load (maybe i should try it on the iPad eh?), so i'm going on the general consensus here. Forgive me if i'm wrong. Windows 8 is more for tablet users and does things well, but thats another story hahaha let's not open that can of worms. I do disagree though. Having used it as my main work station since the developer preview and on the the consumer preview, i honestly think it's got a lot of intelligent design in there and quite a lot of improvements. I now prefer the metro start screen to ye olde start menu and everything is a lot easier to navigate too. MS just need to work out a few of the more schizophrenia ideas.
March 12, 201214 yr Author £400 isn't expensive for the iPad. It's when you start looking at the models with the greater storage that the pricing starts to get silly. It can do a hell of a lot more then check emails. David Hockney, arguably the greatest artists alive, uses his iPad to capture colour and even draw some full pictures. And they are stunning, and only possible with the iPad. for that price you could go and buy a decent nikon DSLR camera
March 12, 201214 yr Author I can't actually get the video to load (maybe i should try it on the iPad eh?), so i'm going on the general consensus here. Forgive me if i'm wrong. hahaha let's not open that can of worms. I do disagree though. Having used it as my main work station since the developer preview and on the the consumer preview, i honestly think it's got a lot of intelligent design in there and quite a lot of improvements. I now prefer the metro start screen to ye olde start menu and everything is a lot easier to navigate too. MS just need to work out a few of the more schizophrenia ideas. Agreed
March 12, 201214 yr for that price you could go and buy a decent nikon DSLR camera Well you could also buy 800 tins of baked beans. What's your point?
March 12, 201214 yr I detect thinly-veiled Apple hate. Regardless, I agree with BrightonMike. There is a huge potential for tablets to overtake PCs for casual users, and I think he's onto something with the concept of a single device that docks to transform it into a desktop solution. I also agree that the slew of tablet devices we've had forced upon us lately aren't the final answer. I'd say a huge portion computer users only use them to do basic web browsing and communication functions, all of which can already be done comfortably on a tablet. Tablets and netbooks have proved that you don't need copious amounts of power to perform casual home user tasks. You even see them cropping in business, too. Obviously this forum isn't going to be very receptive to the idea of tablets replacing PCs, we are all designers or developers ("Power Users") that require absurd amounts of power to run the apps we use to do our jobs. We should remember that we aren't the majority of computer users.
March 12, 201214 yr Author Well you could also buy 800 tins of baked beans. What's your point? You had mentioned the artist with the ipad cam and only the ipad can achieve the standards.. your wrong lol
March 12, 201214 yr probably more useful than a Nikon ...i've been trying to browse the net with my Nikon camera for ages. Wondered why it wasn't working
March 12, 201214 yr Author ...i've been trying to browse the net with my Nikon camera for ages. Wondered why it wasn't working The artist was using the ipad for a cam not the web at the time.
March 12, 201214 yr You had mentioned the artist with the ipad cam and only the ipad can achieve the standards.. your wrong lol Who said he was using the camera on the iPad? I never said such a thing. He uses the iPad to create colour from scenes he observes in real life. He looks at a tree, then uses his app on his iPad to choose a colour he likes which he feels reflects the colour he sees in the tree. Doesn't necessarily mean it is the colour of the tree, but his artistic representation of it. lol
March 12, 201214 yr Author Who said he was using the camera on the iPad? I never said such a thing. He uses the iPad to create colour from scenes he observes in real life. He looks at a tree, then uses his app on his iPad to choose a colour he likes which he feels reflects the colour he sees in the tree. Doesn't necessarily mean it is the colour of the tree, but his artistic representation of it. lol My bad
March 12, 201214 yr For anyone interested: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-11666162 It's fair to say, the artwork he creates using them is stunning.
March 12, 201214 yr then you have the 30+ or 40+ people that are not as tech wise as we are A lot of those guys are far more tech than any of the young 'uns on here, having seen the advancements of hardware and software throught the years. I dunno - a lot of young people seem to know a lot of jargon and what's coming out in 6 months and what the latest scripting language is etc. etc. but I can think of two people I know off the top of my head, both are about 70 years old whose micro electronics and programming language would fry most of our minds. Not so much the latest IPad and html5 as building oscilloscopes from scratch and programming in assembly language. Just saying... appearances can be deceptive.
March 12, 201214 yr then you have the 30+ or 40+ people that are not as tech wise as we are, Linus Torvalds is 42. Tim Berners-Lee is 56. David Braben's 48. John Carmack's 41. Hell, I'm 32. Young people today have no respect.
March 12, 201214 yr Linus Torvalds is 42. Tim Berners-Lee is 56. David Braben's 48. John Carmack's 41. Hell, I'm 32. Young people today have no respect. Exactly. I find that tech knowledge is very age independent. I know some great developers/programmers who range in age from single digits up to their 70's. The great thing is you can stick even the youngest and oldest in the same room and they'll chat as if they are the same age. Brilliant.
Create an account or sign in to comment