January 21, 201214 yr I for one am the person who likes w3schools and I'm ready to get flamed on yeah. It's the start where I learn html-css-javascript-xml-php and mysql. w3schools give you the basic info like on the php manual page. Note; PHP manual I even find sometimes more confusing then w3schools. Yes there are some functions that they should had add before they moved on the next chapter. Namely the isset or empty functions. w3schools has a nice list of reference in html-css-javascript-php and mysql. Yes they might not teach you how everything works together that's something for you to solve, they just give you the basic information about the functions. So why all the flames? It all works so far I have been experienced and even cross browser wise. It's a little bit of solving how everything works but I for one like the website of w3schools and I was wondering. Why the hate as it's all explained?
January 21, 201214 yr I don't condemn w3schools for setting up a tutorial type site. How many other sites are out there doing this very thing? I also forgive them (a little) if they do make mistakes from time to time. I would imagine the same goes for the other tutorial sites? Can't imagine them all to be perfect? What is bad though is the name and how they seem to give the impression that they are somehow linked to W3C (intentionally or otherwise) as this is very misleading - especially for newbies. The certifications they offer also have very little merit in them at all. So I can see why certain people felt they needed to clear the air with the w3fools site, although I don't condone them totally either as the name they chose is a big strong and defamatory.
January 21, 201214 yr An oft-repeated mantra in OSS (and a critique we've already received) is that you shouldn't criticise something unless you're willing to put your money where your mouth is and build something better. It's an admirable ethos, but not really applicable here. W3Schools has put a lot of effort into positioning itself at the top of search results and, despite our efforts (such as the PromoteJS initiative), appears to be there to stay. Other, better resources already exist, but none of them are capable of overcoming the inertia that W3Schools has built up over the years. We believe it is W3Schools's responsibility to disseminate accurate information—and if they refuse, we hope that this document will help dissuade others from promoting or linking to W3Schools as an authoritative source of information I could be wrong here but the way I read that quote from the w3fools website - the people behind w3fools are saying they could make a better resource themselves but won't because they can't get it to the top of Google? Sounds like a bit of a getout to me.
January 21, 201214 yr No what they are saying is that better resources do exist out there (some of which donw to the people behind W3Fools) but unfortunately it gets lost behind the sheer weight of W3Schools. HTML dog is far better but just doesn't have the money behind it.
January 21, 201214 yr No what they are saying is that better resources do exist out there (some of which donw to the people behind W3Fools) but unfortunately it gets lost behind the sheer weight of W3Schools. HTML dog is far better but just doesn't have the money behind it. Ah, that makes sense.
January 21, 201214 yr I think some criticisms have been justified but at the same time I think some people care a little too much.
January 21, 201214 yr I think some criticisms have been justified but at the same time I think some people care a little too much. Sometimes caring a lot is a good thing as it shows how truly passionate someone is about a subject In the case of w3schools I'm with oakleaves on this, the fact that in a way the name of the site can be misleading those just starting out and they try to sell certificates that have no real merit, if they make a mistake then people will come down on them hard...after all they are in a sense setting themselves up for the backlash.
January 21, 201214 yr , if they make a mistake then people will come down on them hard...after all they are in a sense setting themselves up for the backlash. Quite, people would certainly come down hard on a driving school that made basic mistakes like what colour of traffic light to stop on. No good saying, "Ooops, I made a boo-boo" when the fire service are hosing the body parts out of the wreckage. As it is a commercial venture they should get it right and update regularly when there are changes to coding and browsers.
January 22, 201214 yr As it is a commercial venture they should get it right and update regularly when there are changes to coding and browsers. Actually that's a very good point. Thinking about this further the w3schools site has a responsibility to make sure the information it is disseminating is accurate, especially in view of the fact they are making so much money out of it. It's not just discussing web matters it's set itself up as some sort of authority. Now, I don't use the site that much but if the errors are as many as I am led to believe I can see why the w3fools people feel so strongly. Perhaps there should be some sort of regulatory body for these types of sites.
January 22, 201214 yr As I've always understood it W3schools was project started by a group of enthusiasts many years ago, and was more of a labour of love rather than a profit making venture. Sure they do use advertising on site but with as much traffic as they get this would likely be mostly swallowed up in hosting bills. Yes there are some inaccuracies on the site, with as much information as they manage it's probably inevitable bearing in mind it started as a "hobby" site and as the site has grown they probably have little time to devote to it to correct things. As for the complainers, I say if you can do better get off your backsides and do it yourself and take the flack that others will aim in your general direction.
January 22, 201214 yr W3Schools.com is not affiliated with the W3C in any way. Members of the W3C have asked W3Schools to explicitly disavow any connection in the past, and they have refused to do so. That's a pretty damning indictment, and takes them out of the realm of harmless, misguided hobbyists into the realms of the malicious.
January 22, 201214 yr That's a pretty damning indictment, and takes them out of the realm of harmless, misguided hobbyists into the realms of the malicious. Precisely. They know full well what they are doing.
January 22, 201214 yr As I've always understood it W3schools was project started by a group of enthusiasts many years ago, and was more of a labour of love rather than a profit making venture. Sure they do use advertising on site but with as much traffic as they get this would likely be mostly swallowed up in hosting bills. Yes there are some inaccuracies on the site, with as much information as they manage it's probably inevitable bearing in mind it started as a "hobby" site and as the site has grown they probably have little time to devote to it to correct things. As for the complainers, I say if you can do better get off your backsides and do it yourself and take the flack that others will aim in your general direction. They're selling certificates/qualifications in web coding/design. A little more than a few Google ads to help with the bandwidth costs. They are essentially promoting themselves as an educational/qualifying body and if they didn't exist just in cyberspace would be subject to stringent regulations and regular audits. What if a builder built you an extension with a "few inaccuracies"? Would you laugh it off as you put another bucket under the leaking roof and signed the cheque because "he loved doing the job"? Not bloody likely.
January 22, 201214 yr W3Schools.com is not affiliated with the W3C in any way. Members of the W3C have asked W3Schools to explicitly disavow any connection in the past, and they have refused to do so. Have they ever said they were? They don't say they aren't, but they clearly don't say they are. Anyway, looking up various properties and attributes: they aren't wrong about those.
Create an account or sign in to comment