Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SEO Tools : Uber Suggest vs SEMrush

Featured Replies

Hi all,

Just a quick one. I use SEMrush for all my seo work. However for clients they can't see the results. With Ubersuggest they can for free. However, they are both giving different results. 

 

Example1:

One client of mine has juts had their website re-designed and it has killed their SEO. They have gone from page 1 with 118 keywords to page 100 and only 6 keywords. 

 

When you look on Ubesuggest it tells a different story and says they have 100's of keywords and rank well and the designer is saying there you go, no need to worry. Since I can't share my SEMrush account with them it has left me in a bit of a pickle. 

 

Example2:

My website ranks well with SEMrush, run it through Ubersuggest and I am lucky to be in business. 

 

So my question is how legitimate are the results? Is SEMrush right or is Ubersuggest right? 

 

Can provide proof if required. 

I generally find SEMrush to be accurate, but don't have much experience with Ubersuggest.

You can test to see if keyword rankings are accurate by doing searches yourself. Of course, rankings are affected by a lot of things - like history and location - so to get more 'generic' results I'd recommend using a different browser to your daily driver, such as Firefox, with all the privacy settings on full. You could also use a VPN to hide/change your location if that's important. From that, while you might not get results exactly the same as SEMrush, you'll get a good idea of how close they are to 'real' searches, not ones tailored to yourself. Then you can compare them with Ubersuggest.

SEMrush does allow you to create keyword reports that you give to clients, but perhaps that isn't available on all plans.

I find with all of these tools you need to take their reports with a pinch of salt, one SEO I know calls SEMrush "finger in the air" SEO, it's great for roughly telling which way the wind blows. It really depends what sorts of terms / niche you're trying to report on and how the tool gets / uses / weights their data.

An example, SEMrush actually report their location as simply "England" with their positions, not so bad for "UK charities" but when it comes to "plumber near me" that's when it starts to fall apart as what's "near me" to "England"? This gives us very odd positions and pages, and yes they do have a 'track by location' but it's limited to I think 20 terms per location for 5 locations (e.g. Liverpool). With these sorts of thing however I tend to use the MobileMoxie SERPerator (https://mobilemoxie.com/) for spot checking.

As to which report is "right", I don't think either is 100%. Best bet would be pull the terms and positions from each, then compare and show the discrepancies, investigating the ones that show a huge difference. Then compare with GSC data to see if the traffic is close or represents what the tools are saying.

 

Edited by BrowserBugs
Ok maybe no links anymore?

None of these tools will ever be accurate. They are a best guess for the more generic keywords and usually wildly inaccurate for anything more granular.

Use them as a comparison tool if you must. But don’t rely on the details.

If you are optimising for anything local or niche, don’t use them at all.

What I find with local is the keyword tool with volumes in SEMrush is pretty cool for things like do more people want a 'car key replacement' than 'car key cutting', also good for questions around the topic. However when it location based it's ok to some degree, e.g. 'car key replacement birmingham' would be in there, but then you really need to use extrapolation to fill in the blanks.

All too often an SEO will say no one looks for 'car key replacement reigate' simply because their tools don't refine to that level, it's not in their dataset. But if people in Birmingham wants keys replacing I'm pretty sure the good folk of Reigate might need one replacing as well.

Most of SEO is long tail optimisation. Unless you have big marketing budgets it’s not even worth trying to rank for the big keywords. But rank for 100 long tails and you will get very targeted traffic. All you then need to is convert. It’s really not that difficult.

Relying on a tool to plan your SEO strategy is flawed. Get your marketing plan sorted first and use the tools if you must to do some comparison work.

On 2/3/2021 at 12:05 PM, Damo said:

One client of mine has juts had their website re-designed and it has killed their SEO. They have gone from page 1 with 118 keywords to page 100 and only 6 keywords.

So what changed? That might offer a clue:

  • Are redirects in place for old > new URL's?
  • Did content (text) change dramatically?
  • How well does the site perform compared to the old site? In terms of page load speed etc.

Apart from SEO are the sites visitors still able to complete their tasks easily? I've seen some redesigns that make usability/accessibility far worse that the original. Are the sites goals still being met?

6 hours ago, fisicx said:

None of these tools will ever be accurate.

Exactly this. No two tools will ever tell the same story. Any tool that provides any sort of analysis will only give you a broad/general picture.

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 months later...
  • 3 months later...

I used SEMrush. SEMrush is much better tool than Uber Suggest.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.