Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Pencil or Pixel?

Pencil or Pixel? 16 members have voted

  1. 1. Pencil, Pixel or Outsource your designs?

    • Pencil
      47%
      8
    • Pixel
      35%
      6
    • Outsource
      0%
      0
    • 'Wing it'
      17%
      3

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Practice what you preach is something I've been abusing lately and it's only been recently that I've picked up the sketchbook and been doodling more.

 

It's so easy to jump straight in, what with all the software and plugins out there, but it's a schoolboy error not to prep. What I wanted to ask, out of curiosity and to start a little discussion is what method do you (usually) apply for designing a site? Do you sketch it out on a pad, napkin etc, go straight to your graphic program such as PS or go head first and decide in the browser?

 

Of course there is a mixture of designers and developers on here so I appreciate graphic design is not everyone's cup o' tea but perhaps you jot down your infrastructure on a whiteboard or from experience, code straight away - visualising in your head along the way.

 

Other options are outsourcing to a designer or someone in your office or, like me on occasion (though quite ashamedly) winging it and working it out as you go along. Not for clients of course!

 

I also wanted to toy with a poll to see if anyone fills it in :D

Straight to AI and PS for me, sometimes I do basic wireframes in AI first, then take it from there.

Obviously research and planning, too, but I don't sketch (as you know :))

 

I have outsourced, too, when I have too much going on or if there is something I can't do, I outsource to one designer who I know will do a great job and on time.

For me it's pencil. I always have a crusty old A3 pad kicking about as I find it faster for initial stuff before taking on pixels. I'm not drawing the whole thing but normally finish with a few overall ideas and some example buttons, page curls, motion notes etc. I find without this I suffer from Blank Canvas Syndrome which can last for hours.

Yeah, pencil is great :) I get so much more done and have focus that way. Paper quality is great and all, but when I'm in town I usually stock up on those pound shop sketchbooks going through about 4 or 5 a month at times :) Drawing with biro is also quite fun too. Currently sprawled out on the floor with a sketchbook and handwriting pen (it feels nice ok!) doing some logo designs and, dare I say, some hand drawn lettering :wacko: Hard work. Anyone have any experience with that?

 

 

Straight to AI and PS for me, sometimes I do basic wireframes in AI first, then take it from there.

 

Interesting that you do wireframes in AI. Have you tried anything like Balsamiq? Quite intuitive but I seldom do wireframes now (other than sketching). Would like to have experimented with InDesign and wireframing as a handful of people have recommended it.

It depends on me, if it's a personal project or a client.

 

For personal I tend to jump straight into code, and this is mainly because I all ready have a clear Idea in my head of how I would like it etc.

 

For clients, I normally start on Paper in my dot grid book (Check dotgrid.co they are awesome!), and do a few ideas (very rough sketches!) then straight into Photoshop to mock it up properly to show the client. I've never gone straight into coding when doing a piece of client work, far too much hassle.

Hell yeah! We have a 'The Works' shop in town pretty much giving them away :D

 

The Works are excellent! Aside from art supplies (The Range is quite good too), I get quite a few books for my daughter there. Good prices indeedy :D

 

For clients, I normally start on Paper in my dot grid book (Check dotgrid.co they are awesome!)

 

I remember seeing something like this before but was always put off by the price. The prices on here are great! I was quoted for a custom notebook/sketchbook combo something like £18. While it would look good in front of clients, the gsm was pants. Besides - get the same results from el cheapo notebooks and a good Bic biro ;) Tempted to buy some from this site though - thanks for the share :D

If your going to get a custom cover from them...

 

 

 

Between the dates of the 17th to the 23rd of June 2013 our Custom Cover books will be on sale!

 

I've got a few. An A4 which sets on my Desk, then an A5 which comes to client meetings, and then a pack of the Mini pack, which come everyone with me!

This has really boosted my day (sad, I know!). Love stationary and a bit of a brand whore. Not snobby branding, just like things to match up with an identity :D

 

 

reebok-garth.png

I prefer to go straight into the code, mainly because i hate the way PS renders type - its too blurry for me. Im also not that skilled in PS and am more of a coder. I have been trying to get better over this last month though forcing my self to use PS.

 

Sketching really does help me though. Its great to be able to see what will work and what wont early on. it really does save headaches later.

Depends on the idea I have, and whether it's clear and I'm certain it will work straight away.

 

If I have difficulties getting a solid idea, or I want to look at variations quickly, I always start from the beginning with pencil (or pen) drawings. Then it's to Photoshop/Illustrator, and then if it's a website I'll code it.

 

However, I might skip drawings and photoshop when it comes to websites, if I have clear and minimal idea that doesn't need graphics and can be done with nothing but code.

I usually start in PSD, but if i need to get the idea and features on the table i create a mindmap with little doodles that roughly visualise how i see features etc. being used on the web.

 

Then when i have a basic layout, i start coding and continue adding/modifying certain things from there.

  • 1 month later...

its kinda strange for me... but depending on what im doing i sometimes use pencils or my wacom.... so i guess they are generaly the same concept,

but every now and then i prefer to use my paper :) im just old school like that :p

Using pencil outside, and wacom tablet when sitting in front of pc monitor. Recently I thinking of buying wacom inkling, little gadget allowing to store your pencil drawing in digital form.

This would be great, no more scanning.

Using pencil outside, and wacom tablet when sitting in front of pc monitor. Recently I thinking of buying wacom inkling, little gadget allowing to store your pencil drawing in digital form.

This would be great, no more scanning.

 

Good call on the Inkling. I trialled one and while the concept is fantastic, I don't see it replacing scanning your ink anytime soon. As an on the go sketch it's ok, but I don't see the point making a digital version - I'd rather scan it. Pretty cheap now though. Stick to the Intuos for now ;)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.