July 19, 201214 yr Good morning all, I have just put up a first draft for my Freelance Web Design / Visualisation website. Anthony Goodier Any and all critiscisms are welcome. Please note that I have not debugged it for any version of explorer yet! Thank you!
July 19, 201214 yr Author 'Univeristy' Thank you, I also forgot to add that a lot of the text is still being used as a placeholder and nothing has been spell checked im afraid. Just wanted to get some thoughts on design, sorry for missing that out
July 19, 201214 yr I think it has the potential to look very nice, a few little things I have noticed though. The "Designer" text at the top under your name looks out of place This could be because the whole site seems aligned towards the left, maybe add some padding to move everything in a little bit. Your footer also doesn't cover the whole width of the site, i get up to "anthon" and the blue stops as does the rest of the footer. In the work section, at least half of the pictures when you open up the project appear out of proportion, either stretched or squashed. The others don't quite spam the whole width of the site, sitting tight against the left hand side with no padding but then appearing to have padding on the right. I like the Services page, and this is also the only one where the footer appears correctly. Contact pages is ok, I'm not sure if I like the underlined words for the contact form though, other than that the only other thing is the footer not displaying properly. I am viewing this on an iPad but it should still display the site correctly.
July 19, 201214 yr Author I think it has the potential to look very nice, a few little things I have noticed though. The "Designer" text at the top under your name looks out of place This could be because the whole site seems aligned towards the left, maybe add some padding to move everything in a little bit. Your footer also doesn't cover the whole width of the site, i get up to "anthon" and the blue stops as does the rest of the footer. In the work section, at least half of the pictures when you open up the project appear out of proportion, either stretched or squashed. The others don't quite spam the whole width of the site, sitting tight against the left hand side with no padding but then appearing to have padding on the right. I like the Services page, and this is also the only one where the footer appears correctly. Contact pages is ok, I'm not sure if I like the underlined words for the contact form though, other than that the only other thing is the footer not displaying properly. I am viewing this on an iPad but it should still display the site correctly. Thanks a lot for the great feedback. Using Firefox and chrome the footer displays perfectly on all of the pages for me. I will have a look into why this is not the case on the ipad. Again the designer header and images are all fine as well so I will borrow works ipad to check these. Thank you
July 19, 201214 yr Oh, i like you website. It looks very stylish and minimalist. I like used fonts and colors. Very good work.
July 19, 201214 yr Thanks a lot for the great feedback. Using Firefox and chrome the footer displays perfectly on all of the pages for me. I will have a look into why this is not the case on the ipad. Again the designer header and images are all fine as well so I will borrow works ipad to check these. Thank you It's the same on safari and chrome so must just be an iPad issue if those browsers are fine on a standard pc.
July 19, 201214 yr Small border comes up. Maybe from the banner underneath the slideshow? Just thought I'd let you know. Oh and the sevices page has a title of 'flexslider 2'. I'd categorise your work on your portfolio page. Someone who is looking for a web designer doesn't want to have to sift through work irrelevent to them. On the services page I believe the heading on the right is a subheading to the one on the left? Maybe make that more obvious. I thought they had no connection because they both are at the same level of hierarchy. On the services page since you display the steps you take, maybe you could show something from that step, rather than the finished images? Like for planning, have a sketch wireframe or whatever image instead of the final product? That's an idea more than anything, but yeah. This may be a preference as well but I prefer the logo of a website to be a link to the homepage rather than having a homepage link in the navigation. Doing that might add a little bit of nice white space too. I find it odd that you ask for the budget on your contact form..? I do like it though. It's simple and looking at your work you seem to like the colour blue. I like that the text selection colour has been changed too lol...I honestly didn't know you could do that, never came to mind.
July 19, 201214 yr Services page (sort the title) - arial works fine. Contact page - quicksand light is hard to read and has some odd spacing going on. Personally I'd drop it and use arial like you've done for the services page.
July 19, 201214 yr Yeh Quicksand isn't very readable at all, Arial looks OK. You could do with 2 basic little white arrows on either side of your slider. On your services page it would make sense to me to make those images the other colour on hover so the blue ones go to red and vice versa, just to keep with your navigation style. You have a couple of links on your contact page, the colour is really faint, I'd just give these a blue underline and red underline on hover. It would be good if you implemented Google Maps instead of an image. Overall though, nice design, just needs ironing out.
July 19, 201214 yr Off to a great start, I think it just needs some typography and spacing tweaks and it should be good to go. The bigger headlines in Quicksand need to be tracked looser (-2px looks MUCH better than -3px) and the font size needs to go up a bit. With hairline width fonts the font size needs to be large otherwise the legibility is shot. Also, Quicksand is a display face, not a body copy face, so find something more legible at small sizes. Color scheme is fantastic, can't go wrong with blue and pink/red. Centered text for body copy is the devil's work. When in doubt, go left-aligned. For headlines centered is fine. The majority of the page elements are oddly spaced. Some things are spaced widely horizontally but narrowly vertically. The two paragraphs on the homepage, for example, are too close together, but you have ample space beneath and above (though more couldn't hurt). Try to be a little more consistent when you space things out. Same thing for the Work page, the vertical rhythm is different than the horizontal, and since you're using very square, geometric elements it looks like a mistake. If they need to be different, they should at least make sense with everything else proportionally. Also, the overlays when you hover over a piece of work should either be consistent or alternate. It's a bit weird seeing two reds then a blue. The images on the Services page aren't doing anything for me. The flat color icons are great, though. I'd love to see something more cohesive there. Having some things slide is weird, and doesn't fit with the rest of the page. The aesthetic design of the contact form doesn't really feel like it belongs with the rest of the page: Labels are hard to read Inset shadow is way too strong. I like the flat style you've been working with, try to figure out how to build on that here. The red hover on the submit button is really ugly. I'd play with the background color of the button a bit on hover. A darker or lighter blue, or a pink or some other complementary color would work wonders here. The blue you are using on the submit button blends in with the footer. For a call to action like that you want it to 'pop' off the page, since it's the primary action you want your visitors to take and will directly correlate to more money in the future. Map isn't very useful. It would be more helpful to link that image to Google Maps in a new tab so the user can get the full functionality. Spacing needs to be tweaked. Things are too tight. Line height in the line above the form ("Want to work with me...") is way too high. Tighten that up a bit, it feels like two separate phrases. You need a hover state on your footer social media icons. The quicksand in the footer is impossible to read without hurting one's brain. All in all, great work. With minimalism the little things bring the whole design system together, so I'd visit some of the above areas and you'll be good to go. Great job!
July 20, 201214 yr Author Small border comes up. Maybe from the banner underneath the slideshow? Just thought I'd let you know. Oh and the sevices page has a title of 'flexslider 2'. I'd categorise your work on your portfolio page. Someone who is looking for a web designer doesn't want to have to sift through work irrelevent to them. On the services page I believe the heading on the right is a subheading to the one on the left? Maybe make that more obvious. I thought they had no connection because they both are at the same level of hierarchy. On the services page since you display the steps you take, maybe you could show something from that step, rather than the finished images? Like for planning, have a sketch wireframe or whatever image instead of the final product? That's an idea more than anything, but yeah. This may be a preference as well but I prefer the logo of a website to be a link to the homepage rather than having a homepage link in the navigation. Doing that might add a little bit of nice white space too. I find it odd that you ask for the budget on your contact form..? I do like it though. It's simple and looking at your work you seem to like the colour blue. I like that the text selection colour has been changed too lol...I honestly didn't know you could do that, never came to mind. Thanks a lot, some great feedback! will look into that border on the main slider and change the flexslider title. My friend suggested the same thing and I will be looking into getting probably a single image to transition along with the description. I also agree with your point on the sub heading, need to make it more obvious. I was also thinking of splitting it into two columns to have web on the left and visualisation on the right. Will also remove the homepage link and use the logo a link now. thank again.
July 20, 201214 yr Author Services page (sort the title) - arial works fine. Contact page - quicksand light is hard to read and has some odd spacing going on. Personally I'd drop it and use arial like you've done for the services page. I have dropped quicksand and used arial for everything. I am finding that at the larger font sizes it is just too thick. Will search for a cleaner font next week. thank you
July 20, 201214 yr Author Yeh Quicksand isn't very readable at all, Arial looks OK. You could do with 2 basic little white arrows on either side of your slider. On your services page it would make sense to me to make those images the other colour on hover so the blue ones go to red and vice versa, just to keep with your navigation style. You have a couple of links on your contact page, the colour is really faint, I'd just give these a blue underline and red underline on hover. It would be good if you implemented Google Maps instead of an image. Overall though, nice design, just needs ironing out. That's an interesting thought and I will give it a go to see what that hover state looks like. Currently I have divided it into two columns to differentiate between types of work. thanks fore the heads up on the links and with the map I was just being lazy, will implement google at some point. thank you.
July 20, 201214 yr Author Off to a great start, I think it just needs some typography and spacing tweaks and it should be good to go. The bigger headlines in Quicksand need to be tracked looser (-2px looks MUCH better than -3px) and the font size needs to go up a bit. With hairline width fonts the font size needs to be large otherwise the legibility is shot. Also, Quicksand is a display face, not a body copy face, so find something more legible at small sizes. Color scheme is fantastic, can't go wrong with blue and pink/red. Centered text for body copy is the devil's work. When in doubt, go left-aligned. For headlines centered is fine. The majority of the page elements are oddly spaced. Some things are spaced widely horizontally but narrowly vertically. The two paragraphs on the homepage, for example, are too close together, but you have ample space beneath and above (though more couldn't hurt). Try to be a little more consistent when you space things out. Same thing for the Work page, the vertical rhythm is different than the horizontal, and since you're using very square, geometric elements it looks like a mistake. If they need to be different, they should at least make sense with everything else proportionally. Also, the overlays when you hover over a piece of work should either be consistent or alternate. It's a bit weird seeing two reds then a blue. The images on the Services page aren't doing anything for me. The flat color icons are great, though. I'd love to see something more cohesive there. Having some things slide is weird, and doesn't fit with the rest of the page. The aesthetic design of the contact form doesn't really feel like it belongs with the rest of the page: Labels are hard to read Inset shadow is way too strong. I like the flat style you've been working with, try to figure out how to build on that here. The red hover on the submit button is really ugly. I'd play with the background color of the button a bit on hover. A darker or lighter blue, or a pink or some other complementary color would work wonders here. The blue you are using on the submit button blends in with the footer. For a call to action like that you want it to 'pop' off the page, since it's the primary action you want your visitors to take and will directly correlate to more money in the future. Map isn't very useful. It would be more helpful to link that image to Google Maps in a new tab so the user can get the full functionality. Spacing needs to be tweaked. Things are too tight. Line height in the line above the form ("Want to work with me...") is way too high. Tighten that up a bit, it feels like two separate phrases. You need a hover state on your footer social media icons. The quicksand in the footer is impossible to read without hurting one's brain. All in all, great work. With minimalism the little things bring the whole design system together, so I'd visit some of the above areas and you'll be good to go. Great job! Some great feedback porkchop, thank you. re-starting with typography and will change the centered alignment. I will also go over my spacing again once I have finalised the font. service page will get re-done and am looking at changing the images. Will tighten up the footer and contact page with your input as well. Thank you for all the feedback, will hopefully have a re-design up some time next week. Thank you all!
July 23, 201214 yr awesome! I really like how simple and unique it is. As other users have mentioned there are a few things to fix here and there, but overall it looks good!
August 4, 201214 yr I have dropped quicksand and used arial for everything. I am finding that at the larger font sizes it is just too thick. Will search for a cleaner font next week. thank you Try Karla (google fonts), it's lighter than Arial but similar in style, reads well and suits a slightly larger font size.
Create an account or sign in to comment