May 20, 201214 yr As i say, this is not my own work but would like some constructive criticism from a neutral source if you can spare 2 minutes please! Is the site ready for SEO? Is the coding up to scratch? Is this site of a good enough quality to pass on to clients? Thank you for your time!
May 20, 201214 yr Author Hi greyhat, you got a link? Or are you talking about your footer signature link? D'oh! http://www.makeithappenagency.com/ Thanks!
May 20, 201214 yr No, no and no, in that order. Every bit of text on the homepage is an image, the layout is done with tables - it looks to have been put together in Dreamweaver's Design View by someone who doesn't get HTML, SEO, accessibility, usability... Edited May 20, 201214 yr by Renaissance-Design
May 20, 201214 yr I like the header Well I don't like the triancles on your about us page Because all the images the website loads sometimes a bit slow, you can make all your text you used with CSS, give that a try Cheer
May 20, 201214 yr Author No, no and no, in that order. Every bit of text on the homepage is an image, the layout is done with tables - it looks to have been put together in Dreamweaver's Design View by someone who doesn't get HTML, SEO, accessibility, usability... Thanks. I like the header Well I don't like the triancles on your about us page Because all the images the website loads sometimes a bit slow, you can make all your text you used with CSS, give that a try Cheer Thanks for the feedback! Any more for any more?
May 20, 201214 yr Don't use Dreamweaver design view. Or Dreamweaver, at that. Edit: Just realised it's not your work - but still, it could've been put together by someone's grandmother. Edited May 20, 201214 yr by andyl
May 21, 201214 yr Author Don't use Dreamweaver design view. Or Dreamweaver, at that. Edit: Just realised it's not your work - but still, it could've been put together by someone's grandmother. Thanks for your kind words!
May 21, 201214 yr I feel there is nothing really wrong with the design, it's just how it is made! Try and make that design in photoshop and slice it up, use HTML and CSS to get text, links etc in there! Also on the main-images, you can see distortion, so try and make it web optimized! Btw. really like the social media icons popping up! Great idea Edited May 21, 201214 yr by Trustworthy3
May 21, 201214 yr Author I feel there is nothing really wrong with the design, it's just how it is made! Try and make that design in photoshop and slice it up, use HTML and CSS to get text, links etc in there! Also on the main-images, you can see distortion, so try and make it web optimized! Btw. really like the social media icons popping up! Great idea Thanks!
May 21, 201214 yr The design had potential, it looked fairly original. It's the execution that's the problem.
May 21, 201214 yr It took absolutely ages to load. The SEO - There isn't really any SEO going on. No text for a start, no good usage of title tags, poor coding etc Why have you used all images? Or was it created in photoshop then sliced up? The design if you presented it as a jpg and not a "functional" website then it would be an okay design. But it doesn't tick any of the boxes you have asked to review it against
May 21, 201214 yr Just out of interest, are you using our comments to justify a redesign to the client?
May 24, 201214 yr Author It took absolutely ages to load. The SEO - There isn't really any SEO going on. No text for a start, no good usage of title tags, poor coding etc Why have you used all images? Or was it created in photoshop then sliced up? The design if you presented it as a jpg and not a "functional" website then it would be an okay design. But it doesn't tick any of the boxes you have asked to review it against Thanks. And like i say not my own work. Just out of interest, are you using our comments to justify a redesign to the client? yes i am trying to prove a point. Flash for a simple fade in and out banner? Come on lol Actually, just read their web design page at http://www.makeithappenagency.com/webdesign.html - kind of ironic when you look at how poorly it's been made Thanks . . . Edited May 24, 201214 yr by greyhat
May 24, 201214 yr Flash for a simple fade in and out banner? Come on lol Actually, just read their web design page at http://www.makeithappenagency.com/webdesign.html - kind of ironic when you look at how poorly it's been made Yeah a bit embarrassing. Images for text is awful on every level, it does you no favours and is just sloppy work. Shame really, it's not a bad looking site but the coding is none existent and/or lazy.
Create an account or sign in to comment