March 31, 200917 yr Ok, I'm a bit nervous about posting my web site here as a lot of time, love and attention has gone into it and I'm not sure I can take any negative comments . There used to be quite a bit of Flash on the site but I stripped most of this out as it didn't add anything to the site. I would genuinely love to here any feedback as I have no idea what direction to take the site in. http://www.retroedgewebdesign.co.uk/
March 31, 200917 yr Sorry this wont be all that positive. I see nothing retro about the site, and I just don't like it. Can't really put my finger on it, but it just doesn't work in my opinion. Sorry dude. You have a lot of content in there, which is great but the design itself just doesn't do it for me.
March 31, 200917 yr Personally i think the swirls and stuff are quite retro and i like the clearness of it. Very easy to read and understand.
March 31, 200917 yr The design is nice however I do agree with a.g.r.c this design is not really retro, its sort of a toned down style from maybe last year when swirls were all the rage...but last year wouldn't really make retro. The only really retro part I see in this website is your coding style, as your using a lot of nested tables for your layout, and this is something that you shouldn't really do. No offence but its the sort of coding example that I give to show that just because a site validates to w3c standards doesn't mean that it is coded well. Remember that a website should look just as nice on the inside as it does on the outside. Looking at the way your portfolio is presented you could do so much more with it, you have some nice work but you aren't really presenting it to its full potential. My advice would be to have fun with your design, as yes what you have is ok, but its a little on the boring corporate side, and your name is anything but corporate. So personally I would want to see a site that really lives up to the name and plays on the retro, there must be a reason why you chose that name, think of colours that are associated with a retro feel as really blue isn't really one of them, oranges, reds, browns, yellows they are...also if you can change the logo that would help a lot as at the moment the shiny web 2.0 style, that really really doesn't help promote your company name.
March 31, 200917 yr It looks retro... It also has retro code tables for layout javascript rollovers etc.. I'm not keen.
March 31, 200917 yr Sorry this wont be all that positive. I see nothing [insert "tastefully" here] retro about the site, and I just don't like it. Can't really put my finger on it, but it just doesn't work in my opinion. Sorry dude. You have a lot of content in there, which is great but the design itself just doesn't do it for me.
March 31, 200917 yr Author Wow... I wasn't expecting that level of criticism, I obviously have a lot of work to do. I have to admit I've never really intended the web site to look that Retro, I choose the name based on running searches on Google to try and find a company name that wasn't already taken. I wanted the design to be attractive whilst still retaining a corporate edge. I hate corporate looking web sites but feel the site needed to display content in an easy to read fashion that would appeal to local businesses. I'd love to splash some of my vector artwork all over the site but feel it would kill off what I was really trying to achieve, which is build simple yet attractive web site for small businesses. With regards to the nested tables, I agree this needs serious attention. I designed the site sometime ago whilst I was still learning the ropes and have never got around to redoing it in divs. I do have one question though, why are tables such a bad thing? I mean, they validate and 99% of users coming to your site aren't really going to give a monkeys. Is it purely to create nice looking code?
March 31, 200917 yr Hi Paul What is written is first class. Therefore, you have the vital area in the bag. The main font is perfect in every aspect, so stick with it throughout. I would widen the website to its maximum and get shot of those borders and their colour. Then you will be able to take advantage of the space and make the website roomier. Once you find a suitable colour to praise the word presentation the website will sparkle, and all the work behind it will shine. Good luck.
March 31, 200917 yr Tables are for tabular data simple as that. You were talking about being big in the search engines, tables will kill your seo aspirations. Think about it, how you would you prefer to find a needle in a haystack? By siffting through it all in one big pile? Or breaking into small piles and sifting through it from top to bottom. Not to mention the implications of seperating style from markup. Dear oh dear.
March 31, 200917 yr I find that a problem with some designers, they think that corporate means stripping a site of its personality. It really doesn't mean that, you can make sites that are corporate and still have fun and personality in them. I guess it is up to you how you design your site, embrace your company name or distance yourself from it, there is just so much you could of done, but didn't. So personally it just disappointing to me me that you decided that it was a good idea to have a company name and not reflect that name in your branding at all. I guess its just because of the floods of ideas the company name gives, and then to go to a site that is trying too hard to be corporate and is just a bit dull...when your name is so vibrant I guess I just see it as a wasted opportunity to do something that is fun but still corporate. Plus it is a shame to see a designer think that corporate means that a site must have no real personality and not have anything to do with the name of the company. As for the table thing, this is something that comes up so much so here are some links...I would advice you read up on current web practices as it will do you a lot of good in the long run, not only will you produce sites that are accessible to people but also be easier for you to edit...after all not 100% of web users use browsers the same way that you do to view a website. So here are some forum topics on the subject: http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.ph...opic=13163& http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=17801 Here are some good sites about it: http://www.hotdesign.com/seybold/ http://www.michaelthorn.co.uk/web-design-t...-versus-css.php http://www.shouldiusetablesforlayout.com/ Sorry if you find the comments harsh, a lot of designers here have a very honest approach to critiques of sites on here. If you take things on board that you agree with then it will help you, as you have to remember design is subjective and not everyone will like it. We will give opinions it is up to you what to do with them...one thing you can count on is the large majority of us are just here to help you better yourself and make a site that will knock the socks of your potential clients...We maybe harsh sometimes but it comes from a good place and lets face it its better to be told the truth so you can improve then it is to be told a bad design is good (not that your design is terrible, its just not right for this site)
March 31, 200917 yr Author Tables are for tabular data simple as that. You were talking about being big in the search engines, tables will kill your seo aspirations. Think about it, how you would you prefer to find a needle in a haystack? By siffting through it all in one big pile? Or breaking into small piles and sifting through it from top to bottom. Not to mention the implications of seperating style from markup. Dear oh dear. I've only been on this forum a day and have already learned more than in the last six months. "Think about it, how you would you prefer to find a needle in a haystack? By siffting through it all in one big pile? Or breaking into small piles and sifting through it from top to bottom." Makes perfect sense when you put it like that and I had no idea it had an affect on seo. I have taught myself web design from scratch and have never worked in the industry (I work in the boring side of IT) so your comments are much appreciated.
March 31, 200917 yr Author I find that a problem with some designers, they think that corporate means stripping a site of its personality. It really doesn't mean that, you can make sites that are corporate and still have fun and personality in them. I guess it is up to you how you design your site, embrace your company name or distance yourself from it, there is just so much you could of done, but didn't. So personally it just disappointing to me me that you decided that it was a good idea to have a company name and not reflect that name in your branding at all. I guess its just because of the floods of ideas the company name gives, and then to go to a site that is trying too hard to be corporate and is just a bit dull...when your name is so vibrant I guess I just see it as a wasted opportunity to do something that is fun but still corporate. Plus it is a shame to see a designer think that corporate means that a site must have no real personality and not have anything to do with the name of the company. As for the table thing, this is something that comes up so much so here are some links...I would advice you read up on current web practices as it will do you a lot of good in the long run, not only will you produce sites that are accessible to people but also be easier for you to edit...after all not 100% of web users use browsers the same way that you do to view a website. So here are some forum topics on the subject: http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.ph...opic=13163& http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=17801 Here are some good sites about it: http://www.hotdesign.com/seybold/ http://www.michaelthorn.co.uk/web-design-t...-versus-css.php http://www.shouldiusetablesforlayout.com/ Sorry if you find the comments harsh, a lot of designers here have a very honest approach to critiques of sites on here. If you take things on board that you agree with then it will help you, as you have to remember design is subjective and not everyone will like it. We will give opinions it is up to you what to do with them...one thing you can count on is the large majority of us are just here to help you better yourself and make a site that will knock the socks of your potential clients...We maybe harsh sometimes but it comes from a good place and lets face it its better to be told the truth so you can improve then it is to be told a bad design is good (not that your design is terrible, its just not right for this site) I have been designing sites for a couple of years now and have taught myself from the ground up. There are serious gaps in my knowledge (which I realised at a recent job interview) but I get by nicely on what I know. As I don't work in the industry and don't really know anyone who does I decided to join this forum to help rectify the gaps in my knowledge. Although the comments are harsh they are exactly what I am after as you can't get better criticism than people that work in the industry. I only joined yesterday and have already received some excellent feedback and I've learned a few new tricks. Thank you very much for your comments and thanks for taking the time to be so informative, it is very much appreciated.
March 31, 200917 yr In regards to the harsh criticism comment made by Dizi. I never took the feedback at all well way back when, I considered my self to be good in design and thinking about usability. With alot of persevering from the community, the new design soon to go live is ten fold better. It's hard taking it on the chin, but if you can listen to others you will do sooo much better. I see no problems with the way you are taking criticism, keep working hard. Alistair http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=17767 http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=17859
March 31, 200917 yr Author In regards to the harsh criticism comment made by Dizi. I never took the feedback at all well way back when, I considered my self to be good in design and thinking about usability. With alot of persevering from the community, the new design soon to go live is ten fold better. It's hard taking it on the chin, but if you can listen to others you will do sooo much better. I see no problems with the way you are taking criticism, keep working hard. Alistair http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=17767 http://www.webdesignerforum.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=17859 At the end of the day, you and Dizi clearly know a damn site more than I do, so I will listen and learn, that's the whole point of joining the forum after all. It is now my mission to get some positive comments from you though. I'm going to work on a new (table free) design and hopefully get some more positive reactions
March 31, 200917 yr At the end of the day, you and Dizi clearly know a damn site more than I do, so I will listen and learn, that's the whole point of joining the forum after all. It is now my mission to get some positive comments from you though. I'm going to work on a new (table free) design and hopefully get some more positive reactions Hey man that's exactly how I saw it. It was my quest to get some positive feedback on the design. I think our ego sometimes stops us listening to what others say, but it's all good for the gander. Any questions just post them all up. Good luck in your journey, and on that note http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ip1zsUIosoA
Create an account or sign in to comment