September 16, 201115 yr Hey everyone, When we're building sites and the client wants the copyright we normally just assign them a worldwide license to use the site in whatever way they want with specified rights to change it in anyway they want in the future (with full copyright of any designs transferred to them obviously). We retain copyright so as to ensure we own and can reuse the source code as there are obviously many bits of this that are reused across different sites (eg form submission code, api calls, paypal/google checkout scripts, even base layouts excluding styling and designs etc). I have a client that wants full copyright of everything assigned to them with no reuse rights for me. If I do this then I won't legally be able to use the code snippets in other sites, even ones that were written previous to this project by me. I can't work out how to deal with this so they're happy (they're just trying to protect themselves and are obviously paranoid which is fair enough but I'm not trying to copy anything they're doing, just need to ensure I don't end up illegally using my own code or prevent myself using common features/functionality on other sites i build!) I'd be very interested to hear how you all deal with this, I suggested assigning copyright to them and giving me reuse rights of the code but they weren't happy with this. Thanks very much everyone, i'd really appreciate your thoughts. Dave
September 16, 201115 yr Do not give away any copyrights that might affect your ability to perform work in the future or might render you liable for any work you have done or will do in the future. You have a responsibility to your past clients for whom you've implemented similar functionality, and to your business' continued survival. If they can't handle standard terms, walk away.
September 17, 201115 yr Seek advice from a lawyer but as I understand it you can't actually give away complete rights at this stage easily. Selling complete rights puts your previous clients at risk of getting theirs revoked surely? Can you even do that. If I buy complete rights to something can I legally go back and revoke deals from people the previous owner has made? I assume I can. It would give your previous clients grounds to sue, you are putting their business at risk by selling something without ensuring your previous contracts are honoured. I'm going to need to add something to my contract about this.. Edited September 17, 201115 yr by Glowbridge
September 17, 201115 yr The other thing to bear in mind is that many web designers use third party code (either in whole or in part) that is already subject copyright and terms of use. Such as the ever popular jQuery slideshows and animated menu systems to name but a few and these cannot be signed over to any client.
September 17, 201115 yr My understanding : If its in the public domain already or you are using bits of code gathered from here there and everywhere you can not hold a copyright notice over it. It would become such a legal mine field and everyone would be in this situation now it would be the same as paying a royalty every time a website used <body></body> for example! I'm not 100% if coding can be copyrighted or not but the methods used to create an element which maybe unique to you can. The problem here is that we have no idea what the client wants off you in terms of services (what does he want you to make) if its a bespoke shopping cart software or anything else like that or along them lines then I would create it all from scratch and provide the copyright of that product and the method that was used to create it to him. As mentioned above I'm not 100% but I think code is a bit of a gray area. Now as someone mentioned above you can not give away copyright rights that have been used else where, one would assume depending on your contract that you may have in-invariantly given thoughts rights away to the previous customer or your snippets your using over and over could be a bit of a google API script. Its simply not possible. One thing I would advice you to do is to create a water tight contract explaining what you do own the rights to and what the client is buying, in terms of packages, copyright and images. In my contract if I provide a CMS 9/10 its my own CMS so I own the rights to it and I'm simply providing the client with a license to it for either a fixed fee per annum under no circumstances do they own it. The content images and everything else belong to them, the CMS however is mine. Bit old this now but : if you have hired an independent contractor to design the site, then there must be a valid, written agreement, signed by the parties. But note that it must be both valid and written. To be a valid work made for hire agreement you must have "specially ordered or commissioned" the work (which presumably you did) and the written agreement must state that it is a work made for hire agreement. There is also a significant question as to when this agreement must be executed – either before the work actually is commenced or afterwards. You cannot acquire rights to the site by an after-the-fact attempt at a work made for hire agreement. There is no such thing. The Website design work also must belong to one of the statutory categories in order to qualify as a work made for hire. I am assuming for the sake of this article that hiring the designer is a "contribution to a collective work," one of the statutory categories of permissible work made for hire agreements. In this regard, it may be a collective work, I am assuming, because you have created certain of the elements – the text for example – and the designer is contributing the design elements. It also may, under certain circumstances, be an audio visual work or a compilation. There may be other circumstances in which the work does not fall into any of these categories nor any other of the statutory categories of permissible work made for hire agreements. In this event you cannot rely on the work made for hire contract, and you must turn to the copyright assignment to transfer the rights. So let’s assume that there is no writing between the parties that satisfies the work made for hire requirements. You may perhaps acquire all the rights of the designer in the site by having the designer execute a written assignment of copyright that transfers all those rights from the designer to you. Note however, that to the extent the designer did not create the material (as in the form of gifs etc. sourced from the public domain outlined above), you do not acquire any rights therein. You would want to acquire all rights in the site, not merely the rights to use it as your site. As a result, if you have no written, valid agreement conveying to you all these rights, you may end up with at best merely a license to use your own site. This is not particularly satisfying since you may be losing valuable rights. This is after all, you, your expression of yourself, and you should be free to use your expression of your heart freely. You must remain constantly aware that this area of electronic issues is constantly evolving and what appears to be a Website today can be a video game or a feature length motion-picture tomorrow. However, please note that this is not unfair to the designer, as the designer can build into his or her fee what he or she feels is appropriate for a total "buy out". Thus both sides can win. There may be other issues involved beyond the basic copyright ones. These other issues might address whether the designer can put his or her logo on the site or whether the designer can use a copy of the site as part of his or her portfolio. These are more contract questions than copyright questions, although they may flow from the answers to the copyright questions. As you can see, there are no simple answers in this new area. And it is the wisest advice to enter into a written agreement that deals with these – as well as other – issues that may arise. However ring up a solicitor speak over the phone first 15-30min is normally free Your bank may have given you free business banking check the package there is normally a legal phone number you can ring X amount of times for advice on things like this
Create an account or sign in to comment