Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Comments/Feedback/Critique on my logo please

Featured Replies

Hey guys, can you please provide comments/feedback/critique on my logo.

 

post-60037-0-39309700-1401803356_thumb.png

Some preliminary info:
1. Please note that the logo I have posted has the name changed to avoid any possible unforseen issues.
2. I work for a medium sized printing company as a 'mid-weight' graphic designer.
3. My design 'style' is quite abstract but structered - in other words, don't ask me to design anything that looks like 'fun'.
4. I like cats.
(3 out of the 4 above is true :p)

This is the general design brief from the client:

 

A logo for a small digital printing start up.


Full colour. The ability to translate in to monochrome is not really relevant to us.

The name of the business is Noname Digital Printing, We're open to including the text of the name within the design, or not, depending on the design. We're more than happy to place it above or beside the logo as required for the right design, however in this case we would ask that you recommend an open source font for that purpose.

A big part of our business plan is aimed at providing value for community groups and not for profits. We'd like to reflect that local, community element without coming across as amateur. We're a small crew aiming to belie that fact to the casual observer.

It would be nice if it could be used partially transparent, say in the background of a flyer or website.

The rationale behind my logo design:

 

The tree symbol represents growth and community connections. The trunk of the tree symbolises a 'helping hand' reaching out and supportive - therefore community oriented. The foliage is comprised of cyan, magenta and yellow dots which represents digital (or offset) process printing.

I used a more casual font which I think looks more welcoming and friendly and also suits the organic nature of the tree symbol. Some of the other fonts that I tested looked too clinical and digital but I'm happy to forward some of those versions if requested.

 

The font is 'Freehand 521'. It isn't an open source font as far as I'm aware but its usage in a logo will not cause a licensing problem because the text has been converted to a graphic element - which is the case for most logo's using single license typefaces. I'm happy to discuss other options.

The logo can easily be scaled up as it has been produced in vector format. It can also be washed back for a watermark effect (on a light background) as requested.

 

Please give your comments in this context.

 

1. Weather you think the logo meets the design brief and why/why not.

2. Do you like the design for it's overall appeal (or not) regardless of 1. above.

 

Earlier I referenced in a critique on someone else's logo design about the importance of being satisfied with your own design. I'm absolutely satisfied that I came up with the best I could, although perhaps a more technical looking font would suit? - but I'm always willing to learn.

 

Anyway, sorry about the long winded post - just say what you think - be honest.

 

Cheers, Steve

 

[EDIT] bloody hell, the formatting screwed up. fixing it now.

Edited by stixstudios

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

Ok, obviously the 'tone' of this post came across completely different than what I would have thought, or liked. I was wanting to provoke a thoughtful discussion.

 

There is a point to what I posted, and it has nothing (well almost) to do with my own ego. Although 1 1/2 cups of validation wouldn't go astray.

 

After seeing a few too many posts on this graphic design forum of "what do you think of my logo" and the poster not giving much detail - I decided to provide a template or guide as to how one could post their logo on this forum - including a reasonable explanation of how and why they made their creation. Therefore they can receive "meaningful" critique. Dunno, perhaps I failed, but at least I tried.

 

But, and that's a 'Big But' (no offence to anyone) the main reason for posting that logo on this forum was it's one of my submissions to a 'crowd sourcing logo design contest' website . . . has anyone else gone down that path?. . . it can be quite a soul destroying experience.

 

btw. That particular logo did not win the contest!! - although I have been lucky enough to win one contest out of about 30 or so entered.

 

It seems to me that 'design' is becoming an 'off the shelf' product.

 

This phenomenon (which has been around for a while) also includes web design.

 

Anyway, I'm starting up a blog dedicated to discuss such matters:

http://www.mummymummyithinkijustpoopedmypants.com

 

Also you can view my latest failed attempts via:

http://www.crowdspring.com/portfolio/ConnectGraphix/all/

 

[EDIT] Obviously without you knowing the client brief and my rationale behind my logo creations, I can't expect a proper critique of my work, but a simple "yeah, they look reasonable" would at the least validate my hard work.

 

Steve.

Edited by stixstudios

I would say the logo fits the brief. I quite like the tree / hand symbol and for me the meaning behind the logo is clear. I think it should be perceived without any difficulties by the end user.

 

You mentioned you have used a few different fonts, could you show them here? I am not too keen on the font you used, as it is too "organic" and too casual in my opinion. I would have gone with more "standard" font, as I would prefer to have the logo symbol stand out and not be overpowered by the font.

 

Hope that makes sense :)

Ooos, I should have read your second post...

 

I would say don't give up, there will always be a demand for design, which is not off the shelf and you'll find the right clients / people to work with :)

I first saw your post now and I realize that comments on your work at this point is not very useful. But I want to applaud how structured and well thought out your post is. Many of logos posted on this forum is imposible to judge because the posters does not provide any info about the context, the identity of the brand or the wanted message/values that the logo should signal.

Had I seen your post in time I would have said that the shape (the tree) works very well but that the logo type is a bit to complex (the shadow effect adds even more complexity to it) One of the main purposes of a logo is that it should be quick to interpret so a complex shape with many colors combined with a complex font might be to cluttered.

The color scheme works very well and represents the properties of the actual product and I also think the aesthetic values is expressed very well with the tree.

  • Author

I would say the logo fits the brief. I quite like the tree / hand symbol and for me the meaning behind the logo is clear. I think it should be perceived without any difficulties by the end user.

 

You mentioned you have used a few different fonts, could you show them here? I am not too keen on the font you used, as it is too "organic" and too casual in my opinion. I would have gone with more "standard" font, as I would prefer to have the logo symbol stand out and not be overpowered by the font.

 

Hope that makes sense :)

 

 

I first saw your post now and I realize that comments on your work at this point is not very useful. But I want to applaud how structured and well thought out your post is. Many of logos posted on this forum is imposible to judge because the posters does not provide any info about the context, the identity of the brand or the wanted message/values that the logo should signal.

Had I seen your post in time I would have said that the shape (the tree) works very well but that the logo type is a bit to complex (the shadow effect adds even more complexity to it) One of the main purposes of a logo is that it should be quick to interpret so a complex shape with many colors combined with a complex font might be to cluttered.

The color scheme works very well and represents the properties of the actual product and I also think the aesthetic values is expressed very well with the tree.

 

Thanks teodora and Nillervision, very much appreciated. Both critiques are thoughtful and offer constructive ideas with 'real' possible alternatives that I could explore - what more could I ask. Well done (that's my critique on your critiques :))

 

Certainly much much much better that this alternative that I received from the Client. (please note I have highlighted the text that really peeved me off!).

 

 

Thanks for your submission but this is not what I'm after. Please don't submit anymore designs.

 

Cheers mate...

 

One of half a dozen that would've been perfectly well received in a weaker field. There's really nothing much wrong with it. The hand reaching up is a nice touch.

 

Thanks for your time.

 

In my view that part was completely thoughtless, unnecessary and without any regard to etiquette. So, in my mildly enraged state I replied in kind:

 

 

No problems. However:

 

"One of half a dozen that would've been perfectly well received in a weaker field. There's really nothing much wrong with it. The hand reaching up is a nice touch."

 

Doesn't make a lot of sense, although it would be perfectly well received in a weaker field of critiques.

 

Mate, you might want to look at refining your critique skills a bit.

 

Cheers, Steve :)

 

Touche. I'm usually pretty thick skinned but this one was sort of like a 'compliment sandwich' soaked in 'bin juice'.

 

I think this post has served it's purpose in that:

 

  • It shows a good example of an important aspect of the design process, ie. client brief, concept, rationale and critique (positive and negative) with perhaps a final re-worked version?
  • The critiques were meaningul and positive and now feel I've had the recommended dose of 1 1/2 cups of validation. :)

I'll try to post up here as a final entry (hooray) a re-worked version with a less complicated sans serif font.

 

Thanks, Steve.

  • 1 month later...

i think its an awesome logo. Would be better on a white background

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.