Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Web Designer Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Client chasing me for damages - help needed!

Featured Replies

Hey guys, looking for your opinions on something.

 

I created a small 5-page website for a client last November, charged him £228 for the design and £172pa for the hosting. He paid me £250 cash (I've received nothing since). As part of the hosting price I said I’d include all small changes to the site taking under 10 mins to complete for free, and any other changes I would charge an hourly rate for.

 

Anyway, got the site done pretty quickly (within 24 hours) and he was very happy with it. But he’s the sort of guy who seems to get confused easily and complained that he wasn’t receiving any POP3 emails. I phoned him up and talked him through the set up of his Outlook and we got there in the end - he successfully responded to a test message. But Outlook was too confusing for him so he decided he’d like all his website emails forwarded to his personal Gmail address. I set up a simple email forward via cPanel. I sent him a test email, he replied loud and clear and all was well.

 

A few months later he complains he hasn’t received any emails from his new website (I don't know if he was advertising it or not). He said he tried to email himself and received nothing. I sent another test message and it worked fine, so I contacted the hosting company to ask for advice and they told me it could be an issue with Gmail blocking emails when being forwarded via cPanel. So I went back to plan A and set him up with a new webmail account. By this time I was really tired of his constant requests for changes to the website (such as helping him set up facebook and twitter accounts - something he never paid me for) so I emailed him explaining I’d like to end our contract (which I’m allowed to do as per my T&Cs). I offered to send him all the files, copyright and keep the site online till he finds a new host & developer. He says the work I do is ‘amazing’ and pleads with me stay on as his developer.

 

I politely refuse blaming other commitments and next thing I know he’s sending me an invoice for some email campaign he independently organised in December 2009 (costing £1,000) and blaming me for not getting any email responses to it!

 

What do you think I should do? Surely I have behaved in a reasonable manner and done everything that could reasonably have been expected of me!

It might sound easy for me to say but i wouldn't lose any sleep over it if i were you.

 

On a few different occasions you have set up his email (without charging too by the sounds of it) and when you left it it was in working order. It is his responsibility to contact you if something is not right with his email/webmail service.

 

I think you have been more than fair with this client and tried to help him as much as you can. I very much doubt he will have a leg to stand on if he tries to chase the debt and chances are he wont anyway.

 

Good luck.

Did your original contract include you setting up an email account?

 

Does he have any proof that you had any involvement in the email account creations etc?

What? Total rubbish of the highest order!

I'm not a solicitor, but there is no way in hell, he can set something up independently without your prior knowledge, and then try and bill you for it because it hasn't worked! I'd tell him where to go. That's like me sending an invoice out of the blue to my host for £150 because no customers have bought anything from my site. As said, ignore it.

Can you post the terms of your contract here? I agree with the has been stated above, in no way are you liable for third party works, if this is mentioned in your contract then you are sorted. However, I would not dismiss this entirely, as you now may need to change your t+c's for future occassions

WOW! What a sore person! So let me get this right, he's blaming you for not having his emails sent to him, although he confirmed each solution to be a working one? I would talk with them further about how this has come about and get to the bottom of it. It seems like your client is being childish!

1/ Your client has actually been in breach of the contract since November not paying you the full amount agreed upon for your services. If you do not mind us saying, you should have addressed this issue much earlier and in fact used this breach as the reason for withdrawing your services.

 

2/ We have never heard of email redirects from cpanel causing such a problem with Gmail. We suggest you contact cpanel direct to hopefully reassure yourself that there are no grounds for the clients claim.

 

Best of luck.

 

  • Author

Thanks for all your replies. I have been getting really worked up about this but the more I think about it the more I know I really have nothing to worry about. But reading your replies has definitely helped.

 

I made an interesting discovery earlier - I checked AWSTATS for his website and there were only 145 unique visitors during December, 79 of these were on the day this mailshot was allegedly sent. Furthermore, 70% of visitors stayed for less than 30seconds. Visitor numbers were lower in Jan, Feb and March. So the fact of the matter is he wasn't getting emails because he's just not had any traffic to his site.

 

Now I hear he's found a new developer and I'm just hoping he can sort out the domain name transfer and set up a new hosting account. I've made the site available as a ZIP file download. Fingers crossed.

 

 

Can you post the terms of your contract here? I agree with the has been stated above, in no way are you liable for third party works, if this is mentioned in your contract then you are sorted. However, I would not dismiss this entirely, as you now may need to change your t+c's for future occassions

I've attached the original contract + my terms and conditions to this post. You'll notice lots of references to virtual tours as this is something else I do and use the same contracts for both. I'd been keen to hear your thoughts as there is probably lots I'm missing. I've hidden all personal details for me and the client, hope this is ok.

 

 

1/ Your client has actually been in breach of the contract since November not paying you the full amount agreed upon for your services. If you do not mind us saying, you should have addressed this issue much earlier and in fact used this breach as the reason for withdrawing your services.

You're right, I should have used this as the reason, but I didn't want him sending a cheque - I just want rid of him!

quote.pdf

  • 2 weeks later...

It's quite common that some companies blacklist hosting companies due to high levels of spam , I have seen Google blacklist a whole range of big hosting companies in Europe a few months ago which caused nobody to receive emails sent from a certain IP Address for a couple of days. The hosting companies will deny this but its true.

 

Legally if you have provided a service and he is paying for it and you have failed to deliver that service he could take you to court. Very complicated to prove and would cost him more to do so. I recommend getting some Terms and Conditions and adding a BCC on the mail scripts so you can monitor mail being sent to him.

For the price it has cost him for his web site and the cost it will be to take you to court I would simply reply with evidence that you got the e-mail working (if you have dates e-mails were sent/responded too) evidence of visits to his web site etc and tell him you have no intention for paying for anything.

 

if in doubt and in the uk visit the CAB.

Charlotte

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.