November 16, 200917 yr Hello, Started web designing roughly six weeks ago, getting to grips with XHTML, CSS PHP etc. My head has been stuck in tutorials and books, I would like some reviews on my DEBUT design!! Let me know what you think!!! My link
November 17, 200917 yr hmm, on your graphic design page your big buttons expand out of the confines of your main content box. Why is your graphic box at the bottom partly faded out? Having it faded out like that makes it look like it should do something *checks* Oh right they're links. Well they don't seem to go anywhere. That whole part of interaction doesn't really serve any valuable purpose to your website really other than to show you can write a bit of jquery (which your average customer won't really think/care about). Which is all well and good but would perhaps be better placed on a samples page with an explanation? Then maybe put other samples of your coding work in there? Your photography link on your portfolio page doesn't work. Having a portfolio is kind of a requirement of all designers even if your clients are made up. I'd rewrite your cv. The first thing I would not want to read as a potential customer is about you being in a stable relationship with the girl of your dreams, and having a 2 year old kid. Clients won't give a fig about you. Keep it professional. Once you build up a bit or rapport with clients you can then talk to them about stuff like that. You need more actual experience written in you cv. You'll find that most web designers have a working, some even exceptional, knowledge of the skills and attributes you have mentioned. You need to dig deep and give the skills that raise you above your competitors. You don't need me to tell you that the competition is ridiculous and you really need to get your **** together when writing this stuff. Take out things that aren't relevant. GCSE grades, qualifications in English etc. You seem to mention a fair bit about photography and this is diluting your skill set a bit. Decide on what you do and stick to it. You'll find that most web designers stick to web designing. And Photographers specialise in Photography. You seem to be leaning more towards photographer rather than graphic/web designer on some pages eg portfolio. Your 4 links at the top, well actually yeh there are just three. I thought your freelance text was a link. Your site map is a little untidy, I'd tidy it up a bit. I'd also have more images or something on your pages, its all very texty at the moment.
November 17, 200917 yr Author cheers for the feedback JMC note..I've been learnign six weeks??!! lol.. what browser did you view the site with?? as the box is meant to light up on hover. thanks for the advice though it is duly noted and I will rethink the scheme!
November 17, 200917 yr Author well maxson, have you anything to show that can spark my imagination?? I was thinking six weeks=website=quite good.... how long you been designing?
November 17, 200917 yr Hi shaunbaker, This might just be a personal preference, but you thought about making your "ready set go" image stand out a bit more when arriving at your site? I know you've got the hovering effect going on, but I think maybe, with the dark background, that bringing some bright imagery into the site may help a little without ruining the effect you've created. For six weeks from scratch is good work. Valid site too!
November 17, 200917 yr well maxson, have you anything to show that can spark my imagination?? I was thinking six weeks=website=quite good.... how long you been designing? From the day I discovered paper and pen. This is what I'm talking about, ffffound here, my main source for inspiration.
November 17, 200917 yr Started web designing roughly six weeks ago, getting to grips with XHTML, CSS PHP etc. An experienced freelance web and graphics designer hmmmmm.... maybe your very first website shouldn't be a portfolio site for work you haven't yet done. Just a thought
November 19, 200917 yr Hi Shaun. It seems to me that you would need to gain alot more experience before offering freelance design work, you have however got off to a good start and come to a great place for feedback. just understand that there are people here that have been on this forum for longer than you have been designing as such they may take offense when you refer to yourself as an experienced professional so take it from where it comes. the site is okay but there are many quirks and you should do thorough testing on it. If I may offer a suggestion, do what I am currently doing and offer free designs for a while so that you can build up a portfolio and experience.
November 19, 200917 yr Author I'm not pretending to be 'experienced' etc. but you would agree everyone started somewhere! Therefore I don't mean any offence to any of you professionals that are kind enough to release pearls of wisdom once in a while. I didn't see the point of plastering the facts that I am learning, training etc. onto the site. I do have plans to design a few sites for free, currently working a site for a church and a friend who models part time. I am deadly serious with designing, it has really caught my imagination and my girlfriend even comments of the new woman in my life!! LOL! Thankyou for all feedback and your time taken to have a look, it is very much appreciated.
November 20, 200917 yr black is a bit dated now. the light bar is a bit brown looking? like it would be ok on white but it looks faded against black. the blue nav links have far too little contrast against that light background your body text is all bold - bold should be used only for emphasis/impact in small doses. contrast again that's one of the problems with using light text against dark background - though at least you used off-white. blue links difficult to read in places e.g. recent projects what's this for? "ready set go design.net" what does it mean? also the spheres are distorted and look like a mistake ... text breaks out the boxes when increase font size... consider using divs with no height set (so they expand) and possibly css3 rounded corners (you just get square corners in non-supporting browsers) sort out your headings - one h1 for the page and then heirarchy thereafter. also h4-h6 shouldn't be the same size "grapic design" sounds better than "graphics design"' fully justied text rarely works on the net - at least it's open to looking clumsy and prone to rivers running through it. left aligned is easier to read and has much better word spacing/kerning (look at the word "producing" on the first page - it almost looks 2-3 words the ready set go should just go! it doesn't do anything and it detracts from the more sophisticated cleaner look of the rest of the site why 2 sets of navigation? just use the lower of the 2. there's no clear heirarchy between the 2, and the second contains some elements of the first, but named slightly differently. put proper alt text in *all* your images - i.e. the text equivalent your high design skillset isn't so high if you can only code to a transitional doctype to me this site still feels unfinished - as though you're still feeling way from the print to the web world of design. naturally it takes some time and you have have something to build on but it still has too many rough edges
November 20, 200917 yr Author Thanks for your time in your detailed response, Davep. Very much appreciated! Like I posted at the beginning of the thread I have been learning the web side of design, now in my 7th week! There are a few quirks I have discovered! and others! and you! so thanks everyone for your time! I am currently working on an alternative, so when that is done I'll come back to the guillotine again!!
November 20, 200917 yr My advice would be try not to make it too big. Keep it small and simple - perfect that as much as you can and build up from there as your skills grow. At the moment there is so much information splashed around on different pages that it creates a rather vague and garbled message. I'm very new to web design also - my portfolio site is just one page to succinctly describe what I can do. I feel this is the best option until I have more skills and more work to showcase.
November 21, 200917 yr Navbar is REALLY 1.0. As is your big table layout. I'm a huge fan of simplicity but this would make an Amish blush.
November 21, 200917 yr Navbar is REALLY 1.0. As is your big table layout. I'm a huge fan of simplicity but this would make an Amish blush. the navbar is pretty similar to - though not as pretty as - Apple's site. i wouldn't say it was so derogatoryily web 1.0 there are no tables!
November 21, 200917 yr Are you designing this on a laptop? Everything is just so big for me ... It's almost intrusive ... Not a big fan of the colour scheme either... You might want to go for light or even pastel colours.
November 21, 200917 yr The h1 is puzzling me, firstly it is far too long but more importantly just where is it on the page? The words I see in the h1 in the source code are not on the page I just can't find them.
November 21, 200917 yr Author I would like again to thank everyone for there time commenting on my work. I would now ask you all, if I can: When you first started out, after looking at your first website how did you feel? What did you do to reflect upon your design? and how does my design/ code compare to your virgin design? Maybe you still have them lurking around somewhere? share if you can! I just want to gauge where I am at, as I have been designing for the web for 7 weeks? obviously I have asked friends and family, but believe perhaps they was sparing feelings? maybe trying not to discourage me? And if you could change 3 things in the design, what would they be? Again thanks for your time! p.s the link bar was practice using the sprite technique!
November 21, 200917 yr I think everyone's being a bit negative. Design is a personal thing - the only things I would address are the usability issues ie text needs to stand out better from the background and any coding issues ie that h1... I wouldn't make the home page so long only because I didn't realise there was more because the traffic light looked like the end of the page but then again I do work on a very diddy laptop! I think its excellent considering it's your first. As I said design is such a personal thing. I quite like the look of your site. Sometimes especially when your starting out you can get beset with doubt. Why not get another domain do a completely different design then come back to this one, your current site, and see what you think.
November 21, 200917 yr I would like again to thank everyone for there time commenting on my work. I would now ask you all, if I can: When you first started out, after looking at your first website how did you feel? * i thought it was pretty cool that i could publish something that i had made! What did you do to reflect upon your design? * i asked colleagues and friends and users what they thought of it and how does my design/ code compare to your virgin design? can't compare because it was 1996 so almost anything was great then and i was only a very amateur designer with no training or qualifications. Maybe you still have them lurking around somewhere? share if you can! I just want to gauge where I am at, as I have been designing for the web for 7 weeks? obviously I have asked friends and family, but believe perhaps they was sparing feelings? maybe trying not to discourage me? * as a designer - and you've been a designer for print for a while i guess - you need to take criticism and use it, especially from other designers, as long as that criticism is useful and encourages you to be better: i'm quite happy to rip something apart if i can suggest how it could be rebuilt in a better way And if you could change 3 things in the design, what would they be? *1. change the colour scheme to something lighter even pretty much the same colours but charcoal text on white background (and a navbar with more contrast) *2. lose the boxes or make them a lot more subtle! and use what you know as as designer about typography: use bold/italics sparingly for emphasis, use the classical scale and real headings so using something like an equivalent 14px for body text and corresponding sizes for headings from 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 14 18 21 24 36 48 60 72. also not many have myriad pro font so specify some other in the list heirarchy like verdana... "myriad pro", verdana, helvetica, arial, sans-serif; *3. organise the info better - you have a navbar to sections so put the relevant info in those sections (instead of trying to cram everything in detail on the frontpage) and keep things in small digestible chunks, defined by headings/subheadings i feel like on one hand we should cut you more slack because you are so new, but a) you are a designer with a print and photography background it doesn't help you progress if we're too soft on you you have done pretty well for a beginner and hopefully if you can learn from us and other web resources you can do even better! Again thanks for your time! p.s the link bar was practice using the sprite technique!
November 22, 200916 yr "Make your fonts and backgrounds work so that people with colour blindness can read your text and use your navigation." smoothonline, what issues can you see with colour blindness with the site?
November 22, 200916 yr Here is an article about accessibility on the web accessibility. I don't think the issue here is colour blindness well not the common red-green, I think the problem would be for people who have poor eyesight and therefore may not be able to distinguish between the darker blue text and the background.
November 22, 200916 yr well no, that's what i thought (read: knew) and that's why in my critique i mentioned the blue links "blue links difficult to read in places e.g. recent projects " ...
November 22, 200916 yr It's great when you know everything isn't it? Charlotte blimey there are a lot of lions around here sorry if i upset you for mentioning that i had already mentioned this.
November 22, 200916 yr I think that's pretty damn good for 6 weeks! The only thing I would suggest is to make everything a tad smaller and change up the color scheme. Blue on gray never looks good IMO. Besides that, you should add a hand cursor to the 3 buttons under your main content on the home page "Brochure Style Design, etc..." Because its a little misleading, I had no clue it was a button until I clicked on it. Overall, you need to work more on your layout presentation however I think this was a great effort 6 weeks in.
Create an account or sign in to comment