January 18, 201313 yr Hi, I'm basically a self taught hobbyist designer who found himself in the retouching business and took on the challenge of designing and developing my own website to bring in new business. (Challenge accepted.) I've been teaching myself development as I go, basically I'll hit a problem and scour the internet for ways around it while tweaking and testing to get it working so don't be expecting clean and organised coding or even the best practices, if anything sticks out though I'd obviously love to hear where I'm going wrong So far this is just the homepage: http://leebuckle.co.uk/newsite/test/index.html'>http://leebuckle.co.uk/newsite/test/index.html Also the full site doesn't work yet, this is just the home page and the idea is that it's pretty simple and clean not to take away from the subject which will be the retouching work or maybe design at some point when I've got more to show. Some of my own critiques which I've noted and not too sure on: Might move the baseline of all the top links down a bit, it was originally all centered vertically like this: http://leebuckle.co.uk and when I changed it I went with the baseline of the logo. Have the slider fade or at least not rewind after the last one (will be worse when there's more slides), I'm just finding it tricky to implement that though as I'm no jquery whiz and the jflow plugin doesn't have simple options. Not too sure about the contact icons at the top right, bit too bulky and takes away from the elegance maybe? Lastly adding maybe a bit more info for each slide such as a bit more detail on techniques or a 'View More' link to view to the portfolio or Services. Thanks, Lee
January 18, 201313 yr Author Not sure if something's wrong with this post or if I need to approve anything to have my posts appear for other people since it still says 0 views and posts even after I've tried viewing it myself.
January 18, 201313 yr Hi Lee. Nice introduction! I too sparked an interest in design from creating game/forum related graphics and coincidentally, one of my signatures that I first made used the same Vivi render which I can no longer find :/ I'll stop over to your critique thread later and leave some feedback for you! Enjoy your stay mate.
January 18, 201313 yr Author Thanks mate, I think I went a bit too over the top to be honest! Thats awesome, it was probably flying around the 'graphic design' forums back then. I kinda feel like the skills were lost on me, I couldn't imagine how a sig would turn out now if I tried, without one of those long jpeg tutorials too haha, I guess that kind of 'art' can only really be done in such a small canvas anyway and looking back, what I've probably gotten from it would be the transferable skills and understanding of certain things or how to use certain programs. Ah nostalgia, well I guess it's the real world now, where would a beautiful 'sig' get me? Thanks for responding anyway, I was thinking my post was gonna skink to the depths of the interner for a second, looking forward to the feedback! I have just realised though that there's not really much to go on since it is pretty simple :/
January 18, 201313 yr I don't really think you need any pointers on the design, it's absolutely brilliant. It's clean, it's simple and it's well laid out. The only thing I'd say about the design is that the logo doesn't really do it for me, but it's not the worst I've seen (by a long stretch) and will work for now. Oh and also I'd make the site fill the width of the screen completely. Also the bottom border on the header seems a little redundant! As for the coding, I would make a few recommendations. Firstly, it seems like the animations are pretty slow; are you using .animate() for these? It might be worth looking into CSS transitions if you can as these are hardware accelerated (or so I'm told, they certainly work a lot better). Never come across jFlow before, you might want to look into NivoSlider or bxSlider as replacements to get the functionality you want. I think it would be better to add some change to the cursor on hover with the slider (maybe have cursor:pointer on the left and right arrows). I'm looking forward to seeing the rest of it as it comes along. So far much better than 80% of the sites "professional web designers/developers" seem to throw up on here for criticism. Great job.
January 18, 201313 yr Also high five on the use of media queries, gotta love 'em. And, if your Twitter handle is anything to go by, being the same age as me. Top lad.
January 18, 201313 yr I definitely agree that making signatures is a great first step as it provides a foundation of knowledge regarding design and an introduction to the software. I enjoyed making them and when I find myself on gaming forums (which I do from time to time), I still make them and usually get paid in-game currency to make them for other players as well! A nice little skill to have The forum has been a little more inactive lately and posts in certain forums are more likely to be ignored because of the amount of spam brewing in them but there is still a future so hopefully it will be repaired and improved. As for your portfolio, I agree with everything that hodephdesign noted. The slider is quite slow and could be improved with different technology. The logo isn't great but it still has professional presence and it fits well with the simple design. I like the way that your name is spread across the initial slide as it fades out before introducing the rest of your work - it grabbed my attention. A good attempt at using media queries as well but there's still some overlap on the bottom header at smaller sizes and you could try and cater for mobiles using the same method. Oh, and of course, the woman on the first slide is a great attention-grabber! good job!
January 18, 201313 yr Slider arrows need pointer cursor on hover. #justsaying I think it would be better to add some change to the cursor on hover with the slider (maybe have cursor:pointer on the left and right arrows).
January 18, 201313 yr Not much to add here, but I'd just agree that the logo needs work (maybe worth hiring someone to do this?) as the logo really "sets off" the page and the slider issues you have. One thing I did notice in your code is that the code for the menu could be better. I'd recommend looking into using the <ul> <li> (lists) for this. Other than that, not a bad job.
January 18, 201313 yr Didn't even look at the code! I'd move all the JS from the head to just before the closing body tag...
January 18, 201313 yr Author Wow, some really nice feedback, it's nice to see that people actually take the time to help and go out of their way, really appreciate it! hodephdesign - I'm glad you like it, I was hoping to go quite simplistic without it being too boring and nobody has used that word yet so that's good haha. I do understand what you're saying about the logo which realistically isn't even really my logo, I tried a few times to design one but I hate designing for myself, in the end I just went for the Georgia typeface which I felt fit well with the feel of the site but this was just through trial and error, trying out different typefaces. You might have seen I have a different logo on Twitter and Facebook, same typeface throughout but they were just more like placeholders as I've not really worked on the social pages properly yet. This should be more for the Graphic Design part of the forum but I might as well show it here; I was trying to incorporate the L, B and R for Lee Buckle Retouching but in the end it seemed confusing as realistically the first thing you should notice is it standing out at the letter L rather than an R or B, I guess the R would have been better if site was Retouching by Lee Buckle or something, plus even if I did use either of those, they would be hard to fit into a design like this. I'll try taking the 1px borders away but I liked the idea of it separating content from the header and footer. I'm not gonna lie, I don't really understand Jquery much and most of it was copy and pasted with me tweaking the code to get it to work okay but I understand it could be done much better, I've not looked into CSS transitions although I was thinking about possibly doing something where clicking the next/back arrows (or when it does it it's self automatically) would cause it to change the CSS so that it would just change the content, would that not be slow also though since it wouldn't be pre loading the other slides? To be fair, I should look into sliders with CSS transitions before I say any more because I'm just going on guesswork. The speed of the slider is probably also down to the image sizer, being retouching work detail is obviously key and right now theres about an average size of 240k per image but 1 more down on the 'quality' in photoshop seem to go a bit too far for my liking. Would there be a way to use CSS transitions to create a slider like how it is now, as in scalable, changes the text also and animate, fading or sliding on a cycle? I will have a look at those sliders too, thanks As for the cursor over the arrows I'll look into it right away! I keep hearing 'media queries' but I'm not sure what it means haha, is it the links out to my social sites or interactive buttons like the google plus on I'm using? I can't seem to get the facebook one to work on my site and I've tried loads of different ways, even if I did get it working though, I can't imagine it looking good with the design, it doesn't fit nicely next to the google one. Thanks for all of the great feedback, I'll definitely take everything into consideration! Alluziion - If if was a teacher teaching photoshop I'd definitely tell my students to make a couple Not sure if it would be the same though as when I was doing it because when I used Gamerenders forums it was huge with loads of people making tutorials, renders and the critique section was buzzing, I miss those days. I guess most of your points I've already addressed in my reply to hodephdesign but thanks for backing things up I agree, I need a proper logo, something of my own to represent me but in the meantime I'll stick to this. By the overlap do you mean the second line of text at the bottom of the slider or are you talking about the media queries section? If you do mean the text I'm gonna get on that I set the font size to change under a certain page width but I wrote that line a bit too long (the one on the second slider I guess you're referring to?), I'll fix that tonight though, or make it so that it's able to go down to 2 lines and not overlap, it will be because the header is a seperate div and positioned absolute I guess. I'm happy you like the fading out intro and the woman on the front, as they say, sex sells kree8or - Yeah I need to start using lists, I seem to always forget about them, I tent to change things pixel by pixel though to get it how I like and I used separate divs for each menu item as to give each div 1px right borders and also to give each div it's own padding and background colour change when the links were hovered, I guess I could have done this with a line height the same as the header height and changing the background of the text but since I moved te baseline down from the centre I'm not too sure if that would have worked, I will definitely try to tidy it up though! As the for the logo I will work on it at some point, I trust that I could do it pretty well myself although at this point I think I'll try finish the website before swapping that for a new one Thank's for all the great feedback! Edited January 18, 201313 yr by Lee Buckle
January 18, 201313 yr Wow, some really nice feedback, it's nice to see that people actually take the time to help and go out of their way, really appreciate it! kree8or - Yeah I need to start using lists, I seem to always forget about them, I tent to change things pixel by pixel though to get it how I like and I used separate divs for each menu item as to give each div 1px right borders and also to give each div it's own padding and background colour change when the links were hovered, I guess I could have done this with a line height the same as the header height and changing the background of the text but since I moved te baseline down from the centre I'm not too sure if that would have worked, I will definitely try to tidy it up though! As the for the logo I will work on it at some point, I trust that I could do it pretty well myself although at this point I think I'll try finish the website before swapping that for a new one Thank's for all the great feedback! You can do all this with a list to be honest. Each menu item would have its own <li>, so you can style the <li>'s with css including borders, padding , nice transition effects, gradiated backgrounds etc, all without needing Jquery or images. The advantage of this is that your menu will have a nice uniform look. Good luck with all this! Edited January 18, 201313 yr by kree8or
January 18, 201313 yr Media queries are where your CSS looks at the size of the browser window and adjusts the styles accordingly. I guess you threw it in by accident! Yours go something like this: @media screen and (max-width: 1125px) Edited January 18, 201313 yr by hodephdesign
January 18, 201313 yr Author You can do all this with a list to be honest. Each menu item would have its own <li>, so you can style the <li>'s with css including borders, padding , nice transition effects, gradiated backgrounds etc, all without needing Jquery or images. The advantage of this is that your menu will have a nice uniform look. Good luck with all this! Oh I'll definitely have to check this out, to be fair I've not really looked much into CSS3 and HTML5, you can probably tell by my code, I definitely need to brush up on my coding knowledge and practices. Media queries are where your CSS looks at the size of the browser window and adjusts the styles accordingly. I guess you threw it in by accident! Yours go something like this: @media screen and (max-width: 1125px) I didn't really know what they were called haha, I do know about them as you can obviously see, I just wasn't sure of the name, learn something new every day. I've actually just gave a max width to the main containing div and everything else scales with that, for example my header and footer and stuck to the top and bottom and width's of 100%. Maybe doing this through a media query would be better practice? I did use media queries to change the CSS, making the content text smaller at a certain width as to stop it going onto 2 lines but I stupidly overlooked the 2nd slide. Edited January 18, 201313 yr by Lee Buckle
January 18, 201313 yr Hi, Lee. I read your introduction but felt it was better to reply here seeing as that is where the feedback is. I really like your site. It comes across as very professional and, no doubt you took into consideration when designing the site, the lack of any conflicting colours compliment the site perfectly. That way our eye is drawn to the service you're providing rather than being distracted by some over ambitious font or logo. I like how you have included the 'L, B and R' into your logo, but, for what it's worth, I think it detracts from the overall design of the site. In having a neutral aesthetic, you can really showcase your versatility. For example, if you wanted to include your personality into the logo and say your interests were wizards, broadswords and dragons, having a flaming LBR leaning on a blade would tie you to a particular market. Whereas keeping it simple allows for you to build upon. Taking into account the great advice from the above posts, you have the ingredients of a great site! Edited January 18, 201313 yr by 4li4s
January 18, 201313 yr Author Hi 4li4s, glad you took the time, I know it's rather long so no doubt you took a long time to get to this point and I really appreciate it! Thankyou I'm glad you like it and you're right, I did think about different coloured rollovers or maybe even the email link to be a bit more stand out but I decided to just go very neutral and simplistic although a part of me thinks that maybe the email and phone icons are a bit too quirky for the site and would fit more on a designers website and right now there's not really any getting away from the fact that my content and target audience will be mainly retouching based. As for the logo it's not really my logo I guess, more of a first attempt that went in the wrong direction although I don't mind it too much and think it would work well with a different layout on this site, well, if it didn't cause confusion by looking like an R or B.
January 19, 201313 yr Hi, Lee. I tend to be a little verbose with my posts and tend not to re-edit them. Must get in the habit of shortening them! I did however have a good look at your site. As mentioned, the advice the other forum members gave was great. I'm a little out of my depth in terms of jQuery and my workflow (like my posts) tends to be longwinded. I don't think that your logo has gone in the wrong direction. For a first attempt, it's excellent. The way you included both the 'R' and the 'B' works really well in my eyes. You could certainly use this within your existing design or within a different layout in the site - my earlier comment was my preference, so take that with a pinch of salt - please don't be discouraged!
January 20, 201313 yr Author Thanks but to be honest I think I dislike the logo more than you so I'm kinda discouraging myself haha, I like the style of it but that's probably because I've recently had a thing for stylish serif fonts. Like I said though, it's more that it gives the wrong message (the letter that stands out isn't the first letter of the name of my site), I'll eventually get round to getting a new one done though.
Create an account or sign in to comment