March 8, 201214 yr Edge & Muse as standalone programs are great experimental ideas but they won't be viable as professional-quality production tools. The perfect web design tool would probably include some conceptual ideas from Dreamweaver, Edge & Muse (as well as the actual ideas from Text Editors, Browsers, Photoshop, InDesign and Fireworks), but I don't see that becoming reality for many years. Edited March 8, 201214 yr by porkchops
March 8, 201214 yr Edge & Muse as standalone programs are great experimental ideas but they won't be viable as professional-quality production tools. The perfect web design tool would probably include some conceptual ideas from Dreamweaver, Edge & Muse (as well as the actual ideas from Text Editors, Browsers, Photoshop, InDesign and Fireworks), but I don't see that becoming reality for many years. oooh yeeees talk dirty to me
March 8, 201214 yr I still pose the question. If we move away from Flash, there has to be an alternative, and it has to involve a WYSIWYG editor. Edge is a step towards that. Maybe it is not good in itself - but the fact it exists at all shows a positive move away from dependency on Flash. But we will not ever have non-Flash games and interactive content if there is not a piece of software that performs identically to Adobe Flash. Also - why do people keep going off on a tangent about web development software? Edge is not DreamWeaver. It's for making animations, not websites. I feel a discussion about website WYSIWYG editors should be in another thread. Edited March 8, 201214 yr by brightonmike
March 8, 201214 yr I still pose the question. If we move away from Flash, there has to be an alternative, and it has to involve a WYSIWYG editor. Edge is a step towards that. Maybe it is not good in itself - but the fact it exists at all shows a positive move away from dependency on Flash. But we will not ever have non-Flash games and interactive content if there is not a piece of software that performs identically to Adobe Flash. I like the idea of a flash replacement, but with things like CSS3 and HTML5, arn't we moving in the right direction? And that direction is things workign nativly in the browser without having to rely on browser plug-ins?
March 8, 201214 yr I like the idea of a flash replacement, but with things like CSS3 and HTML5, arn't we moving in the right direction? And that direction is things workign nativly in the browser without having to rely on browser plug-ins? Of course. But if you're going to make browser games that don't use Flash or any other plugin, but HTML/CSS instead, then you cannot be coding that game entirely by hand. It's not logical, it's not quick enough and frankly, the more time spent coding and working out syntax, the less time you're spending being creative. Adobe Flash is great software because it allows you to create Flash games quickly, and see them work before your eyes as you work on them. If we are to move on from Flash, we need software that can do an identical job. Edge is the first iteration of exactly that type of software. Just the same as we cringe when someone uses Adobe Flash to make an entire website (except in exceptional cases), so should we if someone does the same with Edge, because they are both animation software - not web development tools. As a side note, I am aware Flash games still involve some coding, before anyone brings that up, but they are not (usually) coded by hand from scratch without using a WYSIWYG. Example: http://www.miniclip.com/games/goodgame-empire/en/ Was almost definitely made using Adobe Flash. Could, potentially, be made in Edge (putting aside Edge's limitations but just thinking about what it is intended to do, or could do in the future). Could almost definitely have not been coded by hand in Notepad++. That is my point. Edited March 8, 201214 yr by brightonmike
March 8, 201214 yr Of course. But if you're going to make browser games that don't use Flash or any other plugin, but HTML/CSS instead, then you cannot be coding that game entirely by hand. It's not logical, it's not quick enough and frankly, the more time spent coding and working out syntax, the less time you're spending being creative. Adobe Flash is great software because it allows you to create Flash games quickly, and see them work before your eyes as you work on them. If we are to move on from Flash, we need software that can do an identical job. Edge is the first iteration of exactly that type of software. Just the same as we cringe when someone uses Adobe Flash to make an entire website (except in exceptional cases), so should we if someone does the same with Edge, because they are both animation software - not web development tools. As a side note, I am aware Flash games still involve some coding, before anyone brings that up, but they are not (usually) coded by hand from scratch without using a WYSIWYG. Example: http://www.miniclip.com/games/goodgame-empire/en/ Was almost definitely made using Adobe Flash. Could, potentially, be made in Edge (putting aside Edge's limitations but just thinking about what it is intended to do, or could do in the future). Could almost definitely have not been coded by hand in Notepad++. That is my point. Adobe flash will eventually move away, patience is key we can't rush it, HTML5 is estimated to be ready by 2022 I'm sure 10 years is more then enough time for any software company to come up with an Adobe Flash like app that will provide the same thing. Adobe Edge is not Adobe's try at that at all it's a software developed for now, to create simple animations without touching code is what they promise, Adobe flash is not like that at all, it requires manual input of AS 3.0 Ofc. it's not in Adobe's interest to kill off their product when it's still being sold, once Adobe Flash sales drop drastically is when Adobe will start working on a CSS .js alternative to flash. so in conclusion Edge is software that generates code for you Flash is software that helps you code for flash. two different things really. Edited March 8, 201214 yr by D.Schuster
March 8, 201214 yr Phew, got 10 years to learn it... if you stay in web design and development for 10 years you'll learn HTML5 day by day, in 2022 you'll already know HTML5 isn't that cool.....
March 8, 201214 yr if you stay in web design and development for 10 years you'll learn HTML5 day by day, in 2022 you'll already know HTML5 isn't that cool..... Ah but in 10 years, the cutting edge guys will be talking about HTML6...
March 8, 201214 yr HTML5 is estimated to be ready by 2022 HTML5 is ready to use now. There are some features we cannot use yet, but it is ready to start using now. Adobe Edge is not Adobe's try at that at all it's a software developed for now, to create simple animations without touching code is what they promise, Adobe flash is not like that at all, it requires manual input of AS 3.0 Adobe Flash doesn't require manual input of code. I know, because I used to use it. In fact, I myself have built entire websites using Adobe Flash and not touched a line of ActionScript. And you're wrong on the first point too. Edge is developmental software, it is experimental, hence it's in the "Labs" section of the Adobe website. You think it would be free if Adobe felt it was ready for full release and use? It's still being developed, which is pretty much Adobe's way of saying "it isn't ready yet". That is another fair reason to be cautious with being so critical. Yes the output code may be lacking now, but the finished software may well output decent code. You cannot say it won't, because it hasn't happened yet. so in conclusion Edge is software that generates code for you Flash is software that helps you code for flash. two different things really. Adobe Flash generates code too, so I wouldn't say they are two different things. Yes, Edge currently lacks the ability for you to tinker with the code yourself, but that doesn't mean it won't be a future feature. Edited March 8, 201214 yr by brightonmike
March 8, 201214 yr HTML5 is ready to use now. There are some features we cannot use yet, but it is ready to start using now. Adobe Flash doesn't require manual input of code. I know, because I used to use it. In fact, I myself have built entire websites using Adobe Flash and not touched a line of ActionScript. And you're wrong on the first point too. Edge is developmental software. You think it would be free if Adobe felt it was ready for full release and use? It's still being developed, which is pretty much Adobe's way of saying "it isn't ready yet". That is another fair reason to be cautious with being so critical. Yes the output code may be lacking now, but the finished software may well output decent code. You cannot say it won't, because it hasn't happened yet. Adobe Flash generates code too, so I wouldn't say they are two different things. Yes, Edge currently lacks the ability for you to tinker with the code yourself, but that doesn't mean it won't be a future feature. The criterion for the specification becoming a W3C Recommendation is "two 100% complete and fully interoperable implementations".[23] In an interview with TechRepublic, Ian Hickson guessed that this would occur in the year 2022 or later.[24] However, many parts of the specification are stable and may be implemented in products HTML5 will fully officially be finished 2022 or later, it is not complete don't spread false information. As for creating a website WITHOUT using AS I simply won't believe it you atleast need to set the movie clip to a start and end point in flash. .....Edge is just as much free as any other Adobe Software it has a trial period, and no it's not meant for developers Even Adobe strays away from describing it as a developer program they do mention designer on quite a few occasions and code-free or "without touching code" in their presentation video's. You're quite hasty for killing off flash I can see that, but again the time and tool will come, edge is not that tool and this is not that time. Even if Adobe is working on a developer's feature this same moment they will not release it until they are positive that Adobe Flash sales are going down and will continue going down or are otherwise forced i.e by competition Software companies don't like to release software that would clash with one and other or steal sales from one and other it's better to wait a few years maximize income from previous products THEN release something else. Edited March 8, 201214 yr by D.Schuster
March 8, 201214 yr 8 bit animated gifs FTW. And flaming text...Scrolling text...and java menus... Haha that made my night. +1 to both of you comediants.
March 9, 201214 yr HTML5 will fully officially be finished 2022 or later, it is not complete don't spread false information. So you're going to continue to code all your websites using HTML and CSS2 until 2022? I also never said it was complete, I said it's ready to use, and it is. So yeah, don't put words into my mouth I didn't say. To re-iterate: "There are some features we cannot use yet, but it is ready to start using now." That is the same view as held by industry professionals. As for creating a website WITHOUT using AS I simply won't believe it you atleast need to set the movie clip to a start and end point in flash. I'll find the website I made. But it's possible, whether you believe me or not. I don't know any Action Script, yet I have made Flash files. Dozens of times. Used to do it loads as a kid. .....Edge is just as much free as any other Adobe Software it has a trial period, and no it's not meant for developers. Even Adobe strays away from describing it as a developer program they do mention designer on quite a few occasions and code-free or "without touching code" in their presentation video's. It's not free like any other Adobe software, and it's not a trial period either. It's developmental software that hasn't been finished yet, and is an experiment by Adobe. It is not a finished, ready to release piece of software. It may never be released as full software. You're quite hasty for killing off flash I can see that, but again the time and tool will come, edge is not that tool and this is not that time. I'm not hasty at killing of Flash, but I do believe it's time is coming to an end, and thus there is going to be a need for software like Edge to replace it. I am not saying Edge is necessarily that software, so in a sense, you are agreeing with me there. Edited March 9, 201214 yr by brightonmike
March 9, 201214 yr So you're going to continue to code all your websites using HTML and CSS2 until 2022? I also never said it was complete, I said it's ready to use, and it is. So yeah, don't put words into my mouth I didn't say. To re-iterate: "There are some features we cannot use yet, but it is ready to start using now." That is the same view as held by industry professionals. To re-iterate myself HTML 5 is going to be complete by 2022, never said it's can not be used today. I'll find the website I made. But it's possible, whether you believe me or not. I don't know any Action Script, yet I have made Flash files. Dozens of times. Used to do it loads as a kid. flash websites without ActionScript is like a normal website without HTML It's not free like any other Adobe software, and it's not a trial period either. It's developmental software that hasn't been finished yet, and is an experiment by Adobe. It is not a finished, ready to release piece of software. It may never be released as full software. Funny how I just downloaded it a few days ago and got 19 days left to try it, and like I said it's more of a designer software. I'm not hasty at killing of Flash, but I do believe it's time is coming to an end, and thus there is going to be a need for software like Edge to replace it. I am not saying Edge is necessarily that software, so in a sense, you are agreeing with me there. Yup, all I'm trying to say is Adobe won't release a flash killer until, flash sales go WAAAY down, it would be madness to create software that would rival your own product, you'd split the potential buyers that way, so people who might get flash will get "Edge" or any other software they will wait until Flash goes down then release something that does the same for CSS3 and Javascript, even if they already developed the perfect software for it. I see what you're getting it, I just don't really think that Edge is a good step in creating a piece of software that does what adobe flash does for flash to javascript and CSS3, quite frankly I feel it's a step in the very wrong direction, since adobe lately keeps releasing software that promises code-less designing, I for one am NOT a fan of that, for instance some of our potential clients might think they know how to make their own website now, trusting in what Adobe sells them, I do not want a web full of ugly websites the 90s were horrible enough. Adobe is going for a wider approach with these product as opposed to their previous releases which were very narrow on who they were meant for, for instance dreamweaver.
March 9, 201214 yr To re-iterate myself HTML 5 is going to be complete by 2022, never said it's can not be used today. You said it won't be ready until 2022, I don't know about everybody else but to me if someone says something isn't ready, they mean you can't use it yet. But meh, it's a point that is irrelevant to what we're tlaking about anyway. flash websites without ActionScript is like a normal website without HTML Dunno what you mean here. I've built basic, working websites, in Flash, without using Action script. I have found them, but if I'm honest I don't really want to show them because I hate them so much and they're rubbish and old and embarrassing. Funny how I just downloaded it a few days ago and got 19 days left to try it, and like I said it's more of a designer software. That's because it's a developer preview. It's not the same as getting a free Photoshop trial. The reason you have limited time to use it is because they will update the preview, so the one you use becomes out-dated. Microsoft release developer previews of IE, there's one out for IE10 I believe. But IE10, like Edge, is still being developed, isn't finished, and isn't released, and the final version could be very, very different from the developer preview. That is why I believe when using experimental, development software, you should keep an open mind. Yup, all I'm trying to say is Adobe won't release a flash killer until, flash sales go WAAAY down, it would be madness to create software that would rival your own product, you'd split the potential buyers that way, so people who might get flash will get "Edge" or any other software Nonsense. Adobe have plenty of Software that do very similar tasks. You have no basis for what you are saying here, you are just speculating but wording it as fact. Creating competition among your own products and services is a very common place business practise. Car manufacturers do it all of the time. since adobe lately keeps releasing software that promises code-less designing, I for one am NOT a fan of that I'm not a fan of that either - but it depends what it's for. Do I want code-less website making software? Absolutely not. I can't stand Dream Weaver. But things like Games, complex animations etc, need to involve a WYSIWYG. You cannot make a game like what they have in Miniclip just by hand coding, there has got to be software that does what Adobe Flash does - but for HTML5/CSS3. You need a timeline. You need scenes. You need keyframes. You need to be able to change colours and draw shapes easily. If you're saying that Adobe will release software like Adobe Flash but for HTML, then you actually agreeing with me that there is a need for it! Edited March 9, 201214 yr by brightonmike
March 9, 201214 yr You said it won't be ready until 2022, I don't know about everybody else but to me if someone says something isn't ready, they mean you can't use it yet. But meh, it's a point that is irrelevant to what we're tlaking about anyway. Dunno what you mean here. I've built basic, working websites, in Flash, without using Action script. I have found them, but if I'm honest I don't really want to show them because I hate them so much and they're rubbish and old and embarrassing. That's because it's a developer preview. It's not the same as getting a free Photoshop trial. The reason you have limited time to use it is because they will update the preview, so the one you use becomes out-dated. Microsoft release developer previews of IE, there's one out for IE10 I believe. But IE10, like Edge, is still being developed, isn't finished, and isn't released, and the final version could be very, very different from the developer preview. That is why I believe when using experimental, development software, you should keep an open mind. Nonsense. Adobe have plenty of Software that do very similar tasks. You have no basis for what you are saying here, you are just speculating but wording it as fact. Creating competition among your own products and services is a very common place business practise. Car manufacturers do it all of the time. I'm not a fan of that either - but it depends what it's for. Do I want code-less website making software? Absolutely not. I can't stand Dream Weaver. But things like Games, complex animations etc, need to involve a WYSIWYG. You cannot make a game like what they have in Miniclip just by hand coding, there has got to be software that does what Adobe Flash does - but for HTML5/CSS3. You need a timeline. You need scenes. You need keyframes. You need to be able to change colours and draw shapes easily. If you're saying that Adobe will release software like Adobe Flash but for HTML, then you actually agreeing with me that there is a need for it! we need to stop making longer and longer posts...... so here goes, Yes I used the wrong words in the HTML5 thing. Ah developer preview, well trust me it won't be free Adobe has this nasty habit of being quite costly. No, a strong point with adobe is that their software goes hand in hand with each other, never against each other. And a software for that will come when there is a need for it, currently flash based games are doing quite good. No I am not saying ADOBE will release software like flash, I am saying that software like adobe flash will come, not neccesarily by Adobe, someone might beat them too it Edited March 9, 201214 yr by D.Schuster
May 3, 201214 yr remember in webdesign there are no simple drag and drop solutions, software can never truly substitute the experience and knowledge of a web designer. Well said!
Create an account or sign in to comment