JonSnow28
Members
-
Joined
-
Last visited
Reputation Activity
-
JonSnow28 reacted to terydinho in READ THIS BEFORE REVIEWING SOMEONES WORKSegments taken from the brilliant article at Smashing Magazine: http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2010/03/02/web-design-criticism-a-how-to/
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Note Your Gut Reaction, But Take Time to Explore It.
If you can’t articulate your reaction, stop there and keep it to yourself. As I’ve said, gut reactions can be valuable, but we need to explore them. Think of the last time you saw one of your favorite websites after a redesign. You may have liked it or hated it right away, but after using the website for a bit, your opinion (hopefully an intelligent one) became more moderate. Take the latest redesign of Facebook, for example. I was immediately confused. I think I actually typed something to that effect in the search field, which had been moved to where I thought the status update field would be. But I quickly found my way around and was soon comfortable with it. What’s more, the changes made a lot of sense overall. My gut reaction was expected; big changes can be disruptive, but I needed to look more closely to see that these changes were positive.
2. Learn to Articulate Your Observations, and Invite Being Questioned.
A designer should never, ever critique another designer’s work unless they are willing to have a meaningful conversation about it. This is a biggie. Expressing an opinion without offering to talk about it holds little value. You may be passionate about your craft (and your opinion for that matter), but for that passion to have much merit, you need to be willing to have a two-way conversation about it. Off-hand comments, particularly anonymous ones, are unhelpful for a number of reasons, most of which are pretty obvious. The point is simply that if you’re going to form and share an opinion, be willing to go a bit deeper and have a conversation about it.
3. Be Specific, and Offer Suggestions if Appropriate.
This is related to the last point. The more specific you are in praising or knocking a design, the more helpful you critique will be. Use descriptive terminology, speak the language of design, relate your opinion back to established principles. Think of your critique as one side of a debate in which you have to defend your opinion.
4. Always Consider Context and Audience-Appropriateness.
A personal website can be judged on how well it captures the personality of the designer. A mobile-specific website should be evaluated on a mobile device. And so on. This one can be hard, especially if you don’t know the context or audience. That said, avoid critiquing a design without knowing the context going in. Sure, by understanding visual design principles, you can critique just about any design on that level, but that’s usually just scratching the surface—helpful, but not nearly as helpful as it would be if you took the time to go deeper.
5. The Most Important Measure of a UI’s Success Is How Well It Meets Expectations.
I recently wrote about this in depth. The point is that you should judge the utility of a user interface by how well it meets your expectations. Of course, if your expectations are exceeded in some way, that’s great, too, but simply having everything behave as you expect is a good start.
6. Subjectivity Is Fine if Labeled as Such and Articulated Properly.
Following on the point about noting your gut reaction, judging a design subjectively is perfectly fine. Sometimes, even after having taken our time and knowing the context and audience and all that, a design still just doesn’t feel right. As long as you articulate that in a way that makes it clear you’re not sure why you feel that way (and if you accompany it with other helpful remarks), the feedback is probably worth sharing.
7. Don’t Neglect the Content.
Unless you take the time to use the website and to read and absorb the content, your review will likely be superficial. While content doesn’t often fall under the responsibility of the designer, it’s still a big part of the design. Judge a design based on how well it presents the content and facilitates its use or consumption. Of course, here we have one of those “it depends on the website” situations, so context is doubly important.
8. Study the Principles Used to Judge Design, and Learn the Language.
I’ve touched on this quite a bit already. It’s probably the best thing you can do to give better criticism and to become a more educated designer. In order to properly form and articulate an opinion about a design, we need to know the principles and patterns we’re dealing with. And without understanding the language, we can’t easily have a conversation about the quality of the design.
-
JonSnow28 reacted to Dizi in This forum is NOFOLLOW!All the forums and sub forums on The Web Designers Forum are NOFOLLOW. This means that a link posted in any section of this forum will not be included as a backlink to your site.
The reason why this post is in here rather than on the main forum is because this is the main forum that gets abused when people come here just looking to link to their sites. If you want a review of your site then by all means post it here as we welcome all people to post their sites for reviews if you need help or want opinions. But if you are just here to post a site to get a backlink then you are wasting your time on this forum all together as you won't get one here.
Happy posting.
-
JonSnow28 reacted to Dizi in Post A Site For Review At Your Own Risk!When posing a physical link to a site to be reviewed remember that some people may not like your site and could leave comments to that effect. These threads can appear on a search engine results for your website or other searches, so if you get negative comments people who search for your site may see these.
Please be sure that you don't mind that some members may not like your design and may criticise the work you have done. Most of these members will offer opinions on how to improve, which is what this section of the forum is about. So if you are looking for helpful advice and a honest view of your site this is the perfect place to do it. If you are just looking for a back link then it won't help as all outbound links include NOFOLLOW so searchengines won't pick them up as a back link to your site.
Really all we are saying is post your sites link at your risks as this forum will not be held responsible for any loss of business or negative things that happen due to you deciding to place your site here for a review.
Also be warned that we will not delete threads bases on you getting negative feedback of your design or coding skills, you wanted opinions and that is what you have gotten. We will however still delete any post that break the forums rules or are not relevant to the topic at hand that could be seen as slanderous.