Thanks for the recommendations, after looking at them and looking around the web, I have decided to work with http://www.commentics.org/
It looks perfect for what I need, all the various options and buttons in the comments can be switched on or off, you can create permissions in the backend to allow users to only access certain menus, it can be styled, and once integrated into the site I'm doing @throzen I might style it with one of those speech bubbles you recommended in your link.
Oh and its free.
Not sure if anyone else has come across it before, if so have you used it?