May 31, 201016 yr Hi there, my site is not completly finished as of yet, but its getting there! I'm not at home on my main machine so I cannot update and find it a bit of a bother to ftp all my updated stuff from the different computers I use. I've finished the design and would like some feedback on what you guys think? The site is to showcase my portfolio, and I'm currently working on a lightbox feature to do this. I've done the wireframes for my about, portfolio, services and contact page and just need to get to work on them as soon as I get back. Would be nice to get a bit of feedback on the design and layout itself of the home page. I've set up a small splash page, and linked a 'sneak peak' link so if anyone wants to, they can view the design and get the concept of what the site does. The site is: http://www.tim-price.co.uk/ and the section where the layout I'm going to use located at http://www.tim-price.co.uk/temp/index.html but ofcourse this is linked from the first page. I'm thinking I'll do the site in different colours as a change of contrast etc, cool, thanks!
May 31, 201016 yr Seems way over photoshopped to me. Also, Im never too keen about lightbox. That is overdone as well, as it its no longer original. May I suggest linking to a page that actually tells the visitor about the site and what you did to complete it? The navigation is way too close together, and it was hard for me to tell it was even a nav in the first place. The social media icons looks like site buttons (one oddly larger than the other), so I would change that. It is an odd place for them anyhow. The background also clashes with the plantish graphics in the main header. It doesn't make much sense.
May 31, 201016 yr Author Thanks for your input, I've built web sites that were the standard, I'm a white background and have my content in the middle, with gradient toolbars, etc! However these sites were mainly for business's that wanted a proffessional look and didn't want the design to take away the thunder from what the business's where actually doing. What I'm doing it actually showcasing what I can do with photoshop, so why not build a site that's 'over' photoshopped? I do agree with the navigation and I've been working on a text version rather than an image! And the social networking buttons were mainly just a test, and I use facebook most so I made that one the largest! But the idea is to make them as large as the facebook one when hovered over! I think your right in saying they are in the wrong place! I have to disagree on the design though, I find it nice to look at and simple, believe you me some portfolio websites are quite hard to understand! The top with the flowers etc is just a temp for my work! I'm going to put a jquery script in there much like your site to allow the use of different works, etc!
May 31, 201016 yr What I'm doing it actually showcasing what I can do with photoshop, so why not build a site that's 'over' photoshopped? Because over-photoshopped isn't something to be proud of. Surely the purpose of a website or piece of graphic design is to communicate something. In your case, to show visitors what your websites are like. If your own website overpowers your message in a sea of bevels and gradients, then I think I know the answer. I have to disagree on the design though, I find it nice to look at and simple. Each to their own, but I would say that if you come to a community asking for criticism, you'll get more out of it if you try to take it on board, or at least think about it and be able to justify your work from a design standpoint. Personally I think your design is getting in the way of your message. Visually there's too much going on and the parts that really seem to draw my eye are the white parts of the container borders. Not going to learn much about your work there... I think what cib was trying to say is that there's a difference between using photoshop well, and using a lot of photoshop effects in your layout. At the moment your website is about itself, and it should be about your work.
May 31, 201016 yr I think what cib was trying to say is that there's a difference between using photoshop well, and using a lot of photoshop effects in your layout. Exactly.
May 31, 201016 yr Author Yeah, couldn't agree more! Then again I could go into how using a simple texture with a colour overlay on would be tacky, or how using a picture of a tree and cutting out the edges to fit the width of a page just doesn't look appealing at all, but you must be happy with them?
May 31, 201016 yr It doesn't look terrible, but I agree with the comments made here. For me it seems that there is too much contrast in the colour scheme - the {almost) black and white border just seem a bit too jarring, and some of the drop/inner shadows are either way too obvious or not really appropriate to use. A bit of work and it will look nice
May 31, 201016 yr Yeah, couldn't agree more! Then again I could go into how using a simple texture with a colour overlay on would be tacky, or how using a picture of a tree and cutting out the edges to fit the width of a page just doesn't look appealing at all, but you must be happy with them? As it happens I'm not happy with it, and I've taken feedback (good and bad) from members on this forum. I value their advice, and I'm following some of it for V3 of my website. However, it's you who's asking for feedback. I gladly gave my time and said what I thought. But because you don't like what I said, you decided to be rude about my work. No wonder I don't spend much time on this forum any more.
May 31, 201016 yr I agree with the comments here, over photoshoped. Strip it back abit and you'll have a good design. I'd start by reducing the amount of drop shadow used.
May 31, 201016 yr Yeah, couldn't agree more! Then again I could go into how using a simple texture with a colour overlay on would be tacky, or how using a picture of a tree and cutting out the edges to fit the width of a page just doesn't look appealing at all, but you must be happy with them? I just realised what you are referring to. You need to grow up a bit and learn to take feedback when you actually ask for it.
May 31, 201016 yr Sorry but I think it's horrible!! Over Photoshopped by a LONG way and no real consideration into how the different elements work together in the design. Whatever that header image is, remove it - the holes need to be MUCH smaller in order to give it a more "textured" effect. Go easy on the drop shadow and, if you insist on (over)using it, make sure you set the shadow to drop to the bottom right of the image - it works much better visually. The organic-looking brush you've used to create that "Tim Price" bit doesn't fit at all with the rest of the "polished plastic" design. White text on black background rarely looks good. Use light greys and dark greys instead Your links have no rollover effects, which is a big no-no (although this might be a bit you haven't finished yet). Use image sprites for the rollovers. If you're advertising a web design service, you NEED to come up with a design that is absolutely stunning OR one which 99% of users will think looks professional. You have done neither. Also, to be honest, looking at your code, I'm not exactly sure that you should be offering web design as a service until you've brushed up on your design AND your coding AND your attitude towards feedback. I'm sure you posted on here thinking that the majority of people will love your site. Please don't be offended by any of the above - you need to take on board what these people have said because you will improve if you do!
June 2, 201016 yr Perhaps some people post on here expecting to hear how great they are - rather than to seek the objective criticism that is provided. I don't think anyone was trying to be cruel. They seem like valid observations to me.
June 3, 201016 yr I wish him the best of luck really... but if he is going to make it in this field, he has to learn how to take criticism because we get a lot of it. And if he can't take it from fellow designers... how is he going to take it from clients?
Create an account or sign in to comment